Buying A Home
Dear Community,

Our tech team has launched updates to The Nest today. As a result of these updates, members of the Nest Community will need to change their password in order to continue participating in the community. In addition, The Nest community member's avatars will be replaced with generic default avatars. If you wish to revert to your original avatar, you will need to re-upload it via The Nest.

If you have questions about this, please email help@theknot.com.

Thank you.

Note: This only affects The Nest's community members and will not affect members on The Bump or The Knot.

Difficult family while buying a house

My husband and I are trying to buy a house. We found the perfect home and we are just waiting to see of the bank accepts our offer. Even though we don't need our family's approval and are making this decision on our own, we invited our parents to come see the house since we are close and value their opinion (my fil is an electrician and my dad is really good with hot water heaters and other things). The economy is getting a little better so the market is rising of course. We got really lucky with this house. It's not huge but it's very nice and well kept. It's a steal! The problem is his parents. I hate to say it like this but I almost think they are jealous. His dad always makes comments about not understanding why we can't start out in a smaller fixer upper "like they did" and work for nicer things in life. Now let me say, I am all for working for what we have.. But our reply is why would we not take advantage of the housing market and get a nicer house for less that falls in our price range?? They keep making negative comments about the few things we would need to replace but can't seem to give us an answer when we ask if they like the house. It's really hard on my husband and it's making this whole process even more stressful than it is already. Has anyone ever dealt with difficult family members when buying a home?

Re: Difficult family while buying a house

  • Why do you feel like you need your parents' approval to purchase a home? You're financially independent, yes?

    If you love the house, just get it. You don't need his parent's permission.
  • STOP asking if they like the house.
    If they point out things that need attention - just say "thanks for noticing that".
    I am assuming they have no clue as to your true financial picture and think you are not in a position to buy this house and are concerned you are over extending.
    And, yes, they may be jealous as well. So what?
    STOP looking for their approval. - just move on. 
    They do NOT have to like the house, how you decorate, what kind of car you buy, where you vacation, what you name your kids --- and you can not let that bother you nor influence your choices - and you can still love them and get along.
  • It sounds like they are just having some trouble adjusting to you all not going quite the same route they did, when they bought their first home.  Aaannnddd, how long ago was that ;)?

    Housing markets can change drastically almost by the season.  What worked great for them 10-20-30 years ago has ZERO relevance for what works in the housing market today and/or what works for your family.

    The only reason people buy starter and/or fixer upper homes to begin with is because they often can't afford to buy the "forever home" right off the bat.  However, nowadays, people are both getting married later in life and buying their first home later in life.  This allows a lot of couples to go straight to their "move-in ready forever" home as their first home.  And that is an AWESOME place to be!

    Don't let them get you down about that.  Keep pointing out to yourself and your DH that, while it is disappointing they are not as excited as you all thought they would be, that YOU all know you have made the right decision and that is what is important.

    Are they aware of the price of the house?  If so, that also might be a factor because, if it has been a long time since they last personally house hunted, there might be some sticker shock going on. 

  • Ok so before ths goes any further, please read before you comment. If you cant do that then please keep scrolling. Im not trying to sound rude but im stressed right now and I do not want to repeat myself. I did say that we do NOT need their approval. I did say we are making the decision on our own. I stated the reason we brought them- their professional expertise on things that could be a problem and a deal breaker. We are first time home buyers. The process is confusing and emotionally stressful enough of making sure it is the "right home" for us without dealing with negativity. I'm looking for people who have had similar situations with buying a house? How did you deal with negativity? Thanks short+sassy, yes they do know the price and it's in our range so we are excited :) you make a good point. The price in their mind could be really high for what it would ave been in their day- actually I'm positive it is. I guess just in my mind if it were my kids, I would be really excited. We will get it regardless if it works out.. it just means the difference when there are positive vibes during stressful times. Maybe it will just blow over and we won't feel tension when we get together and stuff. Thanks for the replies.
  • If you don't need your in-laws approval and you are making this decision independently, I am having trouble seeing how their comments can sway your choice. It seems like you and your husband have not effectively individuated from his parents. People who don't need approval aren't upset when they don't get it. There's also no reason to get angry just because forum members have pointed out the inconsistencies in your words and reactions to your in-laws comments. 

    My husband and I don't care what our parents think, so we don't even ask their opinion when we make decisions. We won't be taking my parents to see the house that we decide on because they will not be living in our home. We also do not discuss finances with either set of parents because it is none of their business. Having said that, I realize that some couples are much closer to their parents and they feel comfortable letting their parents know certain things. The more your parents and in-laws know about you, the more they will have the opportunity to judge your choices. Perhaps it would help to be careful about what you share. I just don't understand why your in-laws need to know what you paid for your house. 

    How I deal with negativity from my mother and my MIL is I rarely interact with them. I also refrain from sharing personal aspects of my life because they cannot be critical if they don't know anything. I know that I can't change my mother or my MIL or control what they say. I can, however, limit my contact with them and be mindful of what they know about me. My mother has tried to ask me what I make at work and I refused to answer. She also told me to have my brother (He's a lawyer) look over our legal documents for the house, but I know my mother just wants to pump my sibling for info after he does that. We will be using our own lawyer to protect our privacy. 

    When your in-laws make negative comments, you can say "I'm sorry you feel that way. We will be buying this house because we like it." Use the broken record technique with the same phrase every time they bring it up. If they become too insistent and pushy, have your husband talk to his parents about boundaries. You may also want to renegotiate boundaries with your husband. It's nice to be close to parents but sometimes that can do more harm than good. 


  • When you make your own decisions - part of that is ignoring/dealing with other people's negativity. You cannot control other people and their responses/feelings about your choices. YOU need to be happy with the choices you make, THEY do not.

  • DH and I already make more money than my parents ever did.  We are looking at $200k budget for a home.  My parents current home is worth about $160k. They also had 3 kids and we won't/can't have any, so that also affects our expenses. They think us looking at $200k is horribly expensive, but that it the average market price where we live and comfortably within our budget. They are happy that we are doing so well, but they have made a couple comments about how high our housing budget it and thinking we should look at something more financially reasonable. They had to work their way up to their home and had been married 30 years before they could afford it. That comparison makes it harder for them to see a $200k home as a "starter home" for us. But, just because it wasn't feasible to them, doesn't mean it isn't feasible to our income and lifestyle.  Maybe your parents are going through the same thing.  Parents want their kids to do better than them, but I think sometimes they try to compare our circumstances to theirs, and when it doesn't match up there is some conflict in their minds.

  • I completely understand why you asked for their opinion, even though the decision will still be yours.  If they are knowledgeable about repair work (electrical/appliances, etc.), then it makes sense that you would want to know if their experience gives them any serious "red flags" about the condition of the house that may have been missed by your general inspector.  It is wise to seek counsel from experienced people who love you and have your best interest in mind. 

    Part of the problem is that the very nature of asking for someone's opinions on this type of purchase, is that they're going to be more prone to point out the negatives (because apparently, you won't notice them unless your nose has been rubbed in every little flaw), instead of hyping you up for a purchase before you've made your decision.  That part comes later.....no sense in getting excited about a house purchase until you know it will be actually go through. 

    However, since it doesn't seem like their negativity has much benefit, then stop asking for their opinion.  If you have your own eyes, and your own opinions and the money for a lot of specialist & professional inspections, then use those and save yourself the stress in the future. 

    Try to ignore the negativity that they've already offered in the process, and if they offer any more opinions, say something like "thank you, but at this point we're just discussing the house purchase between the two of us, so we can really determine for us whether or not we feel it's the right decision."
  • We dealt with something ... I don't want to say similar, but FI's parents were a bit on the fence about the place we eventually selected. This was because they live in an entirely different real estate market, where paying what we were paying for a two bedroom was insane. We had them talk to our realtor (who turned out to be a snake for unrelated reasons) who explained WHY the house we were interested in was such a good buy. Walking distance to the train, 20 minutes from downtown, on a quiet side-street but easy commute for most places, bigger than most other houses in the neighborhood, and buying at a time when we were getting it for less than it was worth. He was right - a smaller house in the same neighborhood just sold today for $30,000 more.

    If you don't want FIL to talk to the realtor, talk to him yourself. Really get into the nitty gritty as to why this is a good house. It sounds like you picked a great house - maybe they just need it laid out in front of them like that.

    Also, and this was a dirty trick, but I would start talking about how I could see our future family growing in this house. Which I can, so I guess it wasn't that dirty. :)

    Achievement Unlocked: Survived Your Wedding! 
  • I just don't see why adults owe their parents an explanation when it comes to such a personal choice. 
  • It's not a matter of whether or not we "owe" our parents something, it's recognizing that someone who loves us greatly has some genuine concern, and so we are being considerate of their feelings, and being kind enough to put their minds at ease.  Not every situation of love and concern points to an unhealthy codependency, and even though in some circumstances it is needed - not every solution has to be "tough love:  cut the ties." 

    Not every parent/adult child has the exact same relationship, so if you see a relationship or a concern or a consideration that you can't relate to, just keep in mind that "different" doesn't mean "wrong."  It's fine that you don't understand an adult child's desire to offer a little consideration and comfort to their parents.  If you don't understand it, it just means that you have a different kind of relationship with your parents, or in laws.  It's no big deal. 
  • OtterJ said:

    It's not a matter of whether or not we "owe" our parents something, it's recognizing that someone who loves us greatly has some genuine concern, and so we are being considerate of their feelings, and being kind enough to put their minds at ease.  Not every situation of love and concern points to an unhealthy codependency, and even though in some circumstances it is needed - not every solution has to be "tough love:  cut the ties." 

    Not every parent/adult child has the exact same relationship, so if you see a relationship or a concern or a consideration that you can't relate to, just keep in mind that "different" doesn't mean "wrong."  It's fine that you don't understand an adult child's desire to offer a little consideration and comfort to their parents.  If you don't understand it, it just means that you have a different kind of relationship with your parents, or in laws.  It's no big deal. 

    Being considerate and comforting to parents doesn't mean that they need to have a say in your choices, especially huge ones like buying a house or other life altering decisions. If my parents are not pleased with a decision I am making, their feelings are not my responsibility and theirs to sort out. 

    Would you refrain from buying a certain home if your parents didn't like it? 

    My husband and I live very far away from his parents and my parents will be leaving the country to retire this fall. The distance helps us realize that our parents aren't going to be here all the time to advise us. It's healthy for married couples to learn to keep their own counsel for when that day comes. You're right that your way isn't wrong...it's just very different from the way my husband and I handle our life together. 

    I believe that keeping certain aspects of our life private protects us from any negativity about what we do.  
  • I understand your point completely.  When I bought my house I took my parents with me every time I looked at a new house.  I was single at the time, so maybe it would've been different after I got married, I'm not sure. But, there was one house that I liked, but my parents did  not like.  They encouraged me to keep looking, and in retrospect, I'm glad I did bc now I LOVE the house we live in. I know my parents had my best interests as heart, and that is what made me take their opinions seriously.
    With that said, it sounds like your in-laws are being difficult for some other reason (perhaps jealousy, like you said).  I think you need to thank them for their time/opinions/love, explain to them that you value their opinion greatly, but tell them you have decided to move forward on the house anyway and just leave it at that.  I can certainly see why this puts your husband in a bad spot, but if you truly think you found your house, then move forward on it.
Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards