Connecticut Nesties
Dear Community,

Our tech team has launched updates to The Nest today. As a result of these updates, members of the Nest Community will need to change their password in order to continue participating in the community. In addition, The Nest community member's avatars will be replaced with generic default avatars. If you wish to revert to your original avatar, you will need to re-upload it via The Nest.

If you have questions about this, please email help@theknot.com.

Thank you.

Note: This only affects The Nest's community members and will not affect members on The Bump or The Knot.

carnival cruise line - yay or nay??

we've gone on Royal Caribbean and Norwegian - so far RCCL is the better choice for us...we haven't been on carnival yet - just wanted some opinions. :)

 We're looking at Carnival Triumph - going to Grand Cayman, Ochos Rios & Cozumel...any advice?!!?

image BabyFruit Ticker

Re: carnival cruise line - yay or nay??

  • Carnival is more gauged towards younger crowds (20's and 30's than the others).  Also, more of a party ship I guess.  Wasn't really for me. I've been on Norwegian and going on RCCL this fall.

    There is a lot to do though, so you should have a good time. :)  I went to cozumel on my trip. :)

    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • I don't think you'll be happy if you're used to nicer one.  The are considered the "Wal-Mart" of the cruising industry. 
  • Nay!

    Had a bad Carnival experience two years ago...was not very luxurious and pretty "cheesy". DH had previously taken a Royal Caribbean cruise and said that was much better.

  • I say nay.  We went for a graduation cruise with a group of friends, and I felt like cattle being herded (inefficiently) and there were just gobs of drunk dorks staring at everyone by the pool.  I even felt badly for the staff, some of them were so rude... and they see this all the time.  Given, it was quite affordable, but I'll NEVER do another Carnival cruise... they couldn't even get our grilled cheese room service correct.
  • I just got back this morning from Freedom of the Seas (Royal Carribbean and it went to the stops you just mentioned. I don't think you can do better than this ship and line, so I would say nay to Carnival.)
  • I disagree with some of the previous posts...I think Carnival is great.  I sailed with them once when I was younger (in 1998) and then DH and I cruised on Carnival Pride for our HM.  It was fantastic!  IMO, there is not that much difference between RCCL and Carnival.  We cruised RC in '06 and had a very similar experience to that of the Pride.  Pics and comments in my bio if you're interested.
    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • like pp said...it depends on what your looking for. i have been on both lines and they offer different things.  Carnival was fun but a younger crowd and I didn't care for the food.  RC was an older crowd, fantastic food but still fun...just not carlos and charlie's style.  Now that i'm in my 30's i have different priorities and would not choose Carnival.
  • I'll never go on a another Carnival ship again, ever - and unlike many people we had no problem with any of the other guests. But we had one service problem after another, some of which were really serious. CCL just has poor screening/training processes for their staff.

    Like the creep in the kitchen obscene-calling us at 5:30 AM. The worst part was that the person to whom I reported this denied it was staff and insisted it was another guest. I knew better because 1. We never gave our room number to anyone and 2. I could hear dishes and silverware in the background.

    Our cat died on the third day of the cruise (our honeymoon) . At dinner in the "fancy" restaurant, the waiter asked "How was you day?" I said "Not too good - our cat just died". His response: "Aww, get a dog, they're eaiser". Nice huh? And yet he, and everyone else on the ship constantly hit us up for tips.

    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • We're going on Carnival Miracle next May for my birthday. Can't wait!! It's a newer ship and looks beautiful. I've heard nothing but fantastic reviews.

    Want other responses? Go on cruisecritic.com- They'll give you a toin of reviews.

    BTW. I've never heard it referred to as the 'wal-mart' of cruiselines.

     Just remember, everyone has bad and good experiences with cruiselines.

  • We sailed on Carnival once and I will never do that again. I actually thought it was worse that the "Walmart" Cruise Lines.

     The people on the ship were unlike any I had ever seen, and that takes a lot from someone that grew up in the woods of Maine. The staff we talked to asked us if we had gotten on the wrong ship and one bartender said he had another couple describe it as a "floating trailer park"

    We have cruised many of the lines and just found everything about Carnival to be low budget. The food was marginal at best, the entertainment cheesy as heck,and the "vibe" on the ship was just not our style.

    I know that some people like Carnival but it is definately not for us. I prefer a bit of luxury on vacation and they just did not deliver on that at all. 

     

Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards