Green Living
Dear Community,

Our tech team has launched updates to The Nest today. As a result of these updates, members of the Nest Community will need to change their password in order to continue participating in the community. In addition, The Nest community member's avatars will be replaced with generic default avatars. If you wish to revert to your original avatar, you will need to re-upload it via The Nest.

If you have questions about this, please email help@theknot.com.

Thank you.

Note: This only affects The Nest's community members and will not affect members on The Bump or The Knot.

Is milk bad??

I'm a fan of Food Inc. on facebook and there's a post about soda and junk food in schools.  Some people suggested they have milk vending machines and a few people are saying milk is as bad as soda and junk food.  One lady said it's horrible and the devil and another person thinks it's sad that kids are drinking milk for a snack and lunch.  I'm not really a milk person in the first place so I don't pay attention but what the heck am I missing?  Why is milk so bad?
image
Tired after a long morning of hiking and swimming.

Re: Is milk bad??

  • IMO, there is going to be some fringe opinion on everything.  There are people who think that milk is nasty (pus! ;-p), people who think that pasteurized milk lacks health benefits, people who that it's unnatural for adult mammals to drink milk, and I'm sure the list goes on...

    Milk is a better alternative to soda, and probably a better alternative to juice, too. Of course, I don't see why schools have to have vending machines in the first place.  Or at least why they can't have only water.

  • Well, it IS weird to drink what's meant for the infants of another species, and even with the best milk, there are some issues of humanity (ie boy calves become meat, using animals, etc). I think most people who are against milk are so either because they don't believe its appropriate/healthy for humans to drink and/or humane issues.

     

    image
  • Ditto, the other reasons mentioned.  I am a substitute teacher, a few weeks ago, I was at a school with a breakfast program for lower income students. (Which I think it a great idea).  All the students were drinking flavored milk, like strawberry and chocolate. Most students were drinking double chocolate (if regular chocolate wasn't enough.)  Basically the milk was loaded with sugar.  The breakfast was pretty unhealthy too, it looked like a corn dog, but it was a sausage that could be dipped in syrup.  What happened to oatmeal, cereal, fruit for breakfast?
  • There can also be some baaaaad hormones in milk.  But I love it, personally.  I drink only organic from my local marketplace, but I'm sure that's not that great, either. 
  • imageJewelsEF:
    Ditto, the other reasons mentioned.  I am a substitute teacher, a few weeks ago, I was at a school with a breakfast program for lower income students. (Which I think it a great idea).  All the students were drinking flavored milk, like strawberry and chocolate. Most students were drinking double chocolate (if regular chocolate wasn't enough.)  Basically the milk was loaded with sugar.  The breakfast was pretty unhealthy too, it looked like a corn dog, but it was a sausage that could be dipped in syrup.  What happened to oatmeal, cereal, fruit for breakfast?

    What you're describing is probably a lot cheaper for the school to serve than nutritious oatmeal, cereal or fruit.

  • Okay, I thought maybe I was missing something like milk causes cancer or whatever.  I read more of the comments on facebook and see they are all over the place from one extreme to the other. 
    image
    Tired after a long morning of hiking and swimming.
  • i live in Wisconsin, America's dairy land, and I don't appreciate all the hate on milk. I have had to cut my intake of dairy considerably because I am doing traditional chinese medicine for TTC. But once I'm done with this, I'm going back to milk, preferably organic. and cheese, lots of cheese, and frozen custard.... mmmmmmm........
  • imageAlisha_A:

    Well, it IS weird to drink what's meant for the infants of another species


    To play devil's advocate on this point, we are also the only species to cook our food. Is that weird? Should we all forego the stove and eat raw meat instead? 

  • imageAlisha_A:

    Well, it IS weird to drink what's meant for the infants of another species, and even with the best milk, there are some issues of humanity (ie boy calves become meat, using animals, etc). I think most people who are against milk are so either because they don't believe its appropriate/healthy for humans to drink and/or humane issues.

     

    Totally agree here.  We're not only the only species to drink another species milk but to also do so after infancy!  I had to stop drinking milk when my son was born and after cutting all dairy out of my diet I feel so much better - my skin cleared up, I got fewer headaches, fewer allergies, and less stomach issues.  My husband has also cut out dairy for cholesterol reasons and he feel so much better too.  

     I do believe there is a link between cow's milk and diabetes.  I know there's been a few studies.  

    image Ethan 12.31.07 Lillian 4.1.11
  • imageZoe01:
    imageAlisha_A:

    Well, it IS weird to drink what's meant for the infants of another species


    To play devil's advocate on this point, we are also the only species to cook our food. Is that weird? Should we all forego the stove and eat raw meat instead? 

    Good point. I would say that, as a species, we've probably adapted to milk by now, although there are individuals and groups of people with sensitivities.  I do see how it's weird from a philosophical standpoint, I guess. I remember reading a lot about it as an argument for veganism back in my vegetarian days.

  • I use almond's milk in my cereal and when I bake.  I don't drink milk just to drink it, though.
    image
    They see us rollin'...they be hatin'.
  • I love milk.  Love it.  I'll drink it just to drink it, on cereal (the rare times I have it), and in cooking.  Like PP, DH doesn't think it's natural to drink another animal's milk so he makes his own almond milk, which I gotta say is getting really expensive. 
    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • imageSuperGreen:
    I love milk.  Love it.  I'll drink it just to drink it, on cereal (the rare times I have it), and in cooking.  Like PP, DH doesn't think it's natural to drink another animal's milk so he makes his own almond milk, which I gotta say is getting really expensive. 

    And yet squeezing "milk" from an almond is natural.  

  • imagefoundmylazybum:

    imageSuperGreen:
    I love milk.  Love it.  I'll drink it just to drink it, on cereal (the rare times I have it), and in cooking.  Like PP, DH doesn't think it's natural to drink another animal's milk so he makes his own almond milk, which I gotta say is getting really expensive. 

    And yet squeezing "milk" from an almond is natural.  

    Well then, is any food preparation? We should just hunt-kill and forage-pick and eat things as is.

    image
  • I drink milk everyday. I've always loved it. If we forego all diary, what about getting enough calcium? I can't imagine not consuming diary. I love it!
  • imagesm23:

    imageJewelsEF:
    Ditto, the other reasons mentioned.  I am a substitute teacher, a few weeks ago, I was at a school with a breakfast program for lower income students. (Which I think it a great idea).  All the students were drinking flavored milk, like strawberry and chocolate. Most students were drinking double chocolate (if regular chocolate wasn't enough.)  Basically the milk was loaded with sugar.  The breakfast was pretty unhealthy too, it looked like a corn dog, but it was a sausage that could be dipped in syrup.  What happened to oatmeal, cereal, fruit for breakfast?

    What you're describing is probably a lot cheaper for the school to serve than nutritious oatmeal, cereal or fruit.

     

    So true. 2/3 of school meals do not meet the federal standards! Why do they do it? Because it's cheap.

    Love is an activity, not a passive affect; it is a "standing in," not a "falling for." -Erich Fromm <a href="http://www.thenest.com/?utm_source=ticker&utm_medium=HTML&utm_campaign=tickers" title="Home D
Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards