Entertaining Ideas
Dear Community,

Our tech team has launched updates to The Nest today. As a result of these updates, members of the Nest Community will need to change their password in order to continue participating in the community. In addition, The Nest community member's avatars will be replaced with generic default avatars. If you wish to revert to your original avatar, you will need to re-upload it via The Nest.

If you have questions about this, please email help@theknot.com.

Thank you.

Note: This only affects The Nest's community members and will not affect members on The Bump or The Knot.

baby shower POLL

All my family and friends have always had a baby shower thrown for them for each baby they have had.  In a post earlier someone mentioned that showers are only for the first child.  That is really new to me...so just wondering what the majority of people do.

[Poll]

Re: baby shower POLL

  • I'm pretty sure that etiquette dictates that it's just for the first child.  It's fine to honor the birth of subsequent children, but you don't do it via a shower.  It's more like a reception once the baby is born and those who feel the desire to bring gifts can.
  • imagekimnelson09:
    I'm pretty sure that etiquette dictates that it's just for the first child.  It's fine to honor the birth of subsequent children, but you don't do it via a shower.  It's more like a reception once the baby is born and those who feel the desire to bring gifts can.

    Wow!  I cant believe Ive never heard of that.  Guess it's just different here in VA

  • I had to google this to find out if this was only something here in VA and I found this on a website about baby showers:

    Who To Invite To The Baby Shower: Historically, a baby shower was only for the first born as well as there was only one shower so everyone important to the Mommy-To-Be was invited (women only). Today, many woman have multiple showers for the same baby and that it is not only for the first born anymore!

     

  • The shower is not for the baby.  The shower is for the mom-to-be to help her outfit the house and the baby.  Since she's already a mom for the next babies I find subsequent showers to be in poor taste. 

    I understand it's regional.  I also understand that people want to celebrate the new babies.  I just don't like multiple showers unless there are extenuating circumstances.

  • imageMrsSmiley09:

    imagekimnelson09:
    I'm pretty sure that etiquette dictates that it's just for the first child.  It's fine to honor the birth of subsequent children, but you don't do it via a shower.  It's more like a reception once the baby is born and those who feel the desire to bring gifts can.

    Wow!  I cant believe Ive never heard of that.  Guess it's just different here in VA

    As a Virginian living not too far from the Beach, it's not really different living in Virginia.

    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • You know, I really think it just depends on what is acceptable in your circle.
    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
  • Unless there is a big gap between children, (my friend had a 12 year gap between children) I would say just the first baby.
    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • Just because you found a random website that said it was kosher doesn't mean it isn't tacky. Hell, you can find a website to justify anything if you want to.
    Lilypie Kids Birthday tickers Lilypie Second Birthday tickers
  • imageMaybride2:
    Just because you found a random website that said it was kosher doesn't mean it isn't tacky. Hell, you can find a website to justify anything if you want to.

    Im not trying to change any ones opinion.  I honestly have never heard that its only for the first baby.  Every friend and family member I have, even in other towns, have had showers before each baby was born.  Just the norm to me. Ive never heard of anything different.  Interesting to find that other people do not do the same thing that is all

  • One more time.  The shower is for the MOM TO BE.  Not the child.
  • My friends and I have been throwing Sip & See's for our friends having their second child. It takes place about a month after the baby is born and we invite people over to sip beverages and see the baby! We have food and drinks and people just hang out! Some people brought gifts and some didn't it was just a chance for people to get together and meet the new baby!
  • imagetoadstool:
    You know, I really think it just depends on what is acceptable in your circle.

    I agree with this.  If it's fine within your group, it's fine.

  • I think a shower for subsequent babies is only acceptable when either the babies are VERY far apart or they are of a different sex. And for a different sex, registering for new furniture (and other unisex things) is not ok.
    PhotobucketAnniversary Holiday
  • imageMandySB:

    imagetoadstool:
    You know, I really think it just depends on what is acceptable in your circle.

    I agree with this.  If it's fine within your group, it's fine.

    ITA.  I've been to showers for the 2nd baby before.  I, personally, would not have one for the 2nd, but whatever floats mommy's boat.  I don't think it's WRONG to have 2nd baby showers...every person's situation is unique and etiquette doesn't speak to the outliers, it speaks to the norm.  If someone has an issue with attending a baby shower for the 2nd child, well, they don't have to attend.  Ha, it kinda reminds me of one of my mom's sayings: "If you don't like it, you don't have to look."

  • I think it really depends on several different things: whether that's an acceptable norm in your circle of friends and families and how far apart the children are.

    I personally would not spend a lot of money for gifts for 2nd child shower, like maybe $10-$15 max. But I'd spend more for the first child, maybe $75-$100 depending on how close I am with the parents to be. If people want to buy you gifts--they will do so without showers.

     

    Image and video hosting by TinyPicMy food blog: Blissfully Delicious BabyFruit Ticker
  • We usually have showers for the first, sprinkles for the second, and mists for the third!  A little smaller each time, but a celebration nonetheless!
    Lilypie Fifth Birthday tickers Lilypie First Birthday tickers

    after several m/c, DD#1 born 7-7-08, more m/c and failed IVF, started adoption process March 2011, matched Oct 2, 2012, DD#2 born 10-31-12
    Hope Wait Pray Adoption Blog
  • In our circle we have showers for every baby, not just the first born, we just like to celebrate such a wonderful occasion. To me a shower has always been for the baby and mom, most of the time we have them after baby is born. Especially if there is a large age gap or a change in sex. Oh and with the second child shower first child usually gets a little something too. I guess we just like to have reasons to get together and celebrate and buy gifts.
    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • usually in my circles 2nd showers are diaper showers.

    i think that if your friends or social circles have changed since prior baby showers, its fine to have another.

    i think that it is fun to celebrate every pregnancy and expectant child somehow, but i never liked the after baby was born idea, i just dont think that i would want my baby around a bunch of people for at least a few months.

    we did do this for my brothers gf about a month after my neice was born, because issues arose before hand and had to postpone it, it was very small though. It was logically better because i got them most of what they needed 2nd hand before baby was born, and that left only diapers and wipes for gifts. (im not saying the shower is all about gifts, im just pointing something out here...) economically it was better to have our guests spending their gift budget on diapers (which have to be bought new) versus clothes etc (which are WAY better bought used, because people dont get used items as gifts). so that $20 was a package of diapers valued at $20 instead of like 1 outfit valued at $3 used.

    anyways, i also think that if there are a few years between kids or if the 2nd 3rd etc are a different father than 1st than its fine to have a full shower.

    now that i think about it, 3 of the last 4 showers ive been to were NOT 1st kids but i hadnt gone to the 1st shower for some reason, so i was happy to go and shower them with love, and gifts.

     

    10-10 siggy favorite summer picture Image and video hosting by TinyPic http://hiscb.blogspot.com/
  • imageHisCB:

    usually in my circles 2nd showers are diaper showers.

    i think that if your friends or social circles have changed since prior baby showers, its fine to have another.

    i think that it is fun to celebrate every pregnancy and expectant child somehow, but i never liked the after baby was born idea, i just dont think that i would want my baby around a bunch of people for at least a few months.

    we did do this for my brothers gf about a month after my neice was born, because issues arose before hand and had to postpone it, it was very small though. It was logically better because i got them most of what they needed 2nd hand before baby was born, and that left only diapers and wipes for gifts. (im not saying the shower is all about gifts, im just pointing something out here...) economically it was better to have our guests spending their gift budget on diapers (which have to be bought new) versus clothes etc (which are WAY better bought used, because people dont get used items as gifts). so that $20 was a package of diapers valued at $20 instead of like 1 outfit valued at $3 used.

    anyways, i also think that if there are a few years between kids or if the 2nd 3rd etc are a different father than 1st than its fine to have a full shower.

    now that i think about it, 3 of the last 4 showers ive been to were NOT 1st kids but i hadnt gone to the 1st shower for some reason, so i was happy to go and shower them with love, and gifts.

     

    I loved the idea of a "Diaper Shower" so much, that I've thrown 2 in the last 3 weeks for friends and family :)  To me (and especially to my best friend, who miscarried a few times since her first-born) all pregnancies and babies are a reason to celebrate.  And the Mommies (as well as their guests) loved the idea of the Diaper Shower-- it's an excuse to get together, have fun, eat good food, and give the Mommy some useful stuff for the 2nd baby. 

  • Amongst our friend group we've done large couples showers for the first baby then "sprinkles" as more of a girl outing for second babies.  At the sprinkles we often bring gifts for mom / family - then food giftcards for after birth etc.  We've paired the sprinkle with a mommy pampering event like brunch or a pedi afternoon.

     

    Although I'm of the belief that a real 25+ person shower with formal invitations is a first baby only, it doesn't mean other children aren't celebrated.  Personally I do the same dollar amount of a gift for the following child as well.   Some things will always still be needed regardless of how many children are in a family.

  • That is a really cute idea - Sip and See.  I'll have to be sure to remember that.  Thanks for sharing!
Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards