Gadgets & Technology
Dear Community,

Our tech team has launched updates to The Nest today. As a result of these updates, members of the Nest Community will need to change their password in order to continue participating in the community. In addition, The Nest community member's avatars will be replaced with generic default avatars. If you wish to revert to your original avatar, you will need to re-upload it via The Nest.

If you have questions about this, please email help@theknot.com.

Thank you.

Note: This only affects The Nest's community members and will not affect members on The Bump or The Knot.

Mac vs. PC?

I need help choosing between an iMac (21.5? screen) and a Gateway PC (Intel quad core processor).

 

I want to use the computer for the basic internet, office stuff, converting VHS to DVD, slides to pictures and learning how to edit pictures.

 

Here are my thoughts on the computers:

iMac- Pros: Everyone loves it, great editing software. Cons: Expensive and I've never used a Mac.

PC- Pros: Less expensive ($499 for the CPU), I can buy a larger monitor, and I?m getting it at Costco, which has a great warranty. Plus, I have the VHS and slide converter equipment and software already.

 

Which do you think I should go with?  And if I do go with Mac, do you think I need to get the 3 year extended warranty for $150 from Best Buy?

 

Thanks so much for your help!

[Poll]

Re: Mac vs. PC?

  • Mac all the way.  The photo suite that comes free with mac is great for organizing photos!  I'll admit - I had a slight learning curve in my transition but I couldn't go back now. (Their tutorials are quick and really help figure out how to operate the mac).  I tend to skip extended warrantees on desktops.. less chance of things happening to them.
  • You have the hardware for the PC for what you have said you will do with your computer.  IMO, there is no need to spend extra to get the same hardware that connects to an even more expensive computer.  You can get some awesome photo editing software on your PC.

    There is nothing wrong with owning a PC.  I actually think that buying a Mac because "everyone likes it" is not a good idea.  That being said, you also should not shy away from a Mac just because you've never used one; they're pretty easy to figure out.

  • IMHO although macs are superior in photo and video editing (although for pc's there's some great software out there) that's about where it ends for me. For your other basic computer uses they seem to be about the same except for price that is. I just got a new laptop last year and really really debated about getting the mac book air (it's thin,light and easy to carry outside when I sit on the patio). However, $2k vs $800.....yeah I stuck with a good ol' pc and have no regrets. IMHO you're paying for a name.
    Our Website

    Kristi and Kerry June 21,2008
    image

    Daisypath Next Aniversary Ticker
  • Well, I had a dell laptop for work until a couple months ago. Against my wishes, the office bought me a Mac instead of a new laptop. I don't handle graphic design like some of our other staffers, and quite frankly I found the Mac to be intimidating...still do. If you use excel a lot, do NOT get the Mac. It's just not user friendly like it is on a regular PC.

    I say, if you're only using it for those things that you indicated, you should get a PC.

     

     

  • I love my mac and would never go back to a PC. For photo management and editing it is superior. And I think the Mac is MORE user-friendly than the PC, it just takes a little while to get used to it. However, I hate running Microsoft Office on the Mac. I use the iWork stuff and that works great but it's not 100% compatible with MS software so if you have to use that a lot it might not work as well for you.

     

    I don't have an imac though. I have a Macbook Pro and at work it is hooked up to an external monitor. However, if the Mac is going to be much more than the PC you might want to stick with the PC. 

  • I am a huge mac fan - more than a pc, but I bought an iMac in 2007 and no longer use it for my main computer.  Once any part goes/breaks/needs an upgrade (including the monitor), the entire computer is toast - because Apple uses all proprietary parts.  I successfuly swapped out a harddrive, but the graphics chip was bad in the model I have. 

    If you do go with the iMac, definitely get the 3 year warranty.  Sadly mine ran out just in time for us to realize the graphics chip was bad. 

    Get the spec'd out PC and put Linux on it =)

    image
    "They say with time it gets better. Not true. With time you only get used to it."
  • Thank you all so much for your opinions and feedback! You all have been so helpful!
  • I recommend the iMac if you are going to do a lot of video and picture editing.  The Mac in general is quicker in video and picture editing.  I use both Mac and PC, and I prefer my Mac for those kinds of jobs.

     

    Need computer help?  www.m-cs-c.com

     

  • If you do get a mac, don't get the Best Buy warranty but get Applecare. It is also a three-year warranty and Apple is really good about replacing parts when it's under warranty and they'll even work with you after the warranty has expired. 
  • One vote to PC. I am a gamer, and I really enjoy the high quality graphic that a PC can bring to me.
Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards