Entertaining Ideas
Dear Community,

Our tech team has launched updates to The Nest today. As a result of these updates, members of the Nest Community will need to change their password in order to continue participating in the community. In addition, The Nest community member's avatars will be replaced with generic default avatars. If you wish to revert to your original avatar, you will need to re-upload it via The Nest.

If you have questions about this, please email help@theknot.com.

Thank you.

Note: This only affects The Nest's community members and will not affect members on The Bump or The Knot.

Possibly a stupid question

(XP from Entertainment, bc I posted on the wrong board.)

But I really don't know the answer. Embarrassed  I offered to host a wedding shower for my brother's fiancee as soon as I found out they were engaged.  Since then, they have talked about getting married at the justice of the peace, or maybe eloping.  My question is - If they don't have a "wedding" can I still have a shower for them?  I'm thinking that it would be tacky to invite people to give gifts, but them not invite them to a wedding KWIM? 

 

Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml

Re: Possibly a stupid question

  • Yes it would be tacky. 
  • Since they are interested in a small ceremony or eloping, I would assume that the bride is not really in to registering and participating in all of the wedding "stuff," which wouldn't give people much to work with for a shower. Another idea might be to have a party after their ceremony in celebration of their new marriage. It wouldn't necessarily be a reception or shower, just a celebration party. Guests wouldn't feel obligated to bring a gift, but they could if they wanted to and you still get the opportunity to help the new couple celebrate with friends and family!
  • I think they should have a shower or a reception (doesn't have to be same day as the marriage). Most people would love to congratulate them in person and give a gift...or at least that's how I feel in this situation.  It isn't always tit-for-tat, if they aren't inviting anyone to their ceremony it doesn't seem gift-grabby to have a shower or reception.
  • imagesoon2Bmrs.pip:
    Another idea might be to have a party after their ceremony in celebration of their new marriage. It wouldn't necessarily be a reception or shower, just a celebration party. Guests wouldn't feel obligated to bring a gift, but they could if they wanted to and you still get the opportunity to help the new couple celebrate with friends and family!

    This.  Ask the bride how she feels about doing a party after the ceremony.

  • What about doing an engagement party instead?  That way people can come and congratulate them (and bring a gift if they want) but really just be there for them!
  • As long as everyone invited is clear that they aren't going to be invited to the wedding, you are good to do whatever you want.  Many people LIKE to give gifts to the bride/newlyweds, regardless of if they are invited to the wedding.  The key is full disclosure.

    The invite can say something like:

    Susie is running off and getting hitched... let's celebrate! 


  • You could also host/coordinate a spa day for you both and a few other people to celebrate.
  • imagejulie5220:

    As long as everyone invited is clear that they aren't going to be invited to the wedding, you are good to do whatever you want.  Many people LIKE to give gifts to the bride/newlyweds, regardless of if they are invited to the wedding.  The key is full disclosure.

    The invite can say something like:

    Susie is running off and getting hitched... let's celebrate! 


     

      I agree with this, just keep it small.  I don't think it would be gift grabby at all, I think people will want to celebrate.  Have fun planning!

  • i agree on the "Engagement Party" for the two of them. But you could still have a bridal shower too, she's still getting married =)

    have fun!

  • I personally think it would be tacky.  If it was a shower for just family, then I think its ok!
  • If they haven't lived on their own or "shacked up" together yet, then I think close friends and family are appropriate because they'll need things.  I would go smaller scale so it doesn't seem tacky.  If anyone, invited to the wedding or not want to buy gifts, they will. 
  • A JOP wedding can still include guests.......not a ton, but they could get married at the JOP and still invite their close friends and family to witness it.  In that case, a shower would be fine to do......but just like with a traditional wedding, only those invited to the wedding should be invited to the shower. 

    Eloping, on the other hand, is by definition NOT inviting anyone to the wedding.  If no one is invited to the wedding, then a shower is really inappropriate and tacky. 

    Those who truly want to give a gift to the couple even without attending their wedding will do so without a party obligating them to do so.  But asking people to come and celebrate an impending marriage with a gift when they're not invited to witness said marriage rubs a lot of people the wrong way.

    Lilypie Kids Birthday tickers Lilypie Second Birthday tickers
Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards