Green Living
Dear Community,

Our tech team has launched updates to The Nest today. As a result of these updates, members of the Nest Community will need to change their password in order to continue participating in the community. In addition, The Nest community member's avatars will be replaced with generic default avatars. If you wish to revert to your original avatar, you will need to re-upload it via The Nest.

If you have questions about this, please email help@theknot.com.

Thank you.

Note: This only affects The Nest's community members and will not affect members on The Bump or The Knot.

Mr. Clean

Would you consider the mr. clean magic erasers environmentally friendly? they're made of melamine (but don't contain formaldehyde, that's a myth) and don't contain any additional chemicals/cleaners...I would figure that they would still beat the heck out of the kind of chemical warfare people sometimes get into trying to get things off of walls and tubs and so on. 

 What do you think? 

Re: Mr. Clean

  • No because they are disposable.  I would rather use my own rags and wash them and not generate the waste. 
  • imagekass11:
    No because they are disposable.  I would rather use my own rags and wash them and not generate the waste. 

    Ditto

    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • I love Magic Erasers.  I haven't found anything else that gets the soap scum from the very green Dr. B's off my shower doors.  I use 2 erasers a month and they're pretty disintegrated by the time I'm done with them, so I don't considered that to be a lot of waste.
    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • imageSuperGreen:
    I love Magic Erasers.  I haven't found anything else that gets the soap scum from the very green Dr. B's off my shower doors.  I use 2 erasers a month and they're pretty disintegrated by the time I'm done with them, so I don't considered that to be a lot of waste.

     I agree. I would only consider them disposable in a VERY broad sense. I guess those dual-sided ones would be, but obviously you don't have that extra sponge the originals.  

  • Hmmm... I haven't used them since they took the paint off my living room wall (it was flat paint- does that make a difference?).

    I would consider them semi-reusable.  It isn't like a one-use kind of thing.  And even rags fall apart and have to be replaced periodically (says the lady who is about to have to replace all the kitchen rags AGAIN bc our tile countertops have rough edges and rip holes in them).

    SG I am impressed that you clean enough to go through 2 of them a month.  I am also curious what else you tried to get the soap scum off.  Did vinegar not work?  It seems like people always recc. that, but personally I have to use some nasty chemicals to get soap scum off bc vinegar doesn't touch it. 

  • I used to work in the chemical industry and we supplied the products for this product (and helped to make it). So there are chemicals in them. But the question would be if you look at the entire lifecycle of the eraser vs what you would use to get something off a wall/tub I am not sure what would come out ahead.

  • imageJen&Joe06:

    I used to work in the chemical industry and we supplied the products for this product (and helped to make it). So there are chemicals in them.

    Snarky comment:  EVERYTHING has chemicals in it!  Sorry that is just my personal pet peeve as a chemical engineer.  Natural crap is still full of chemicals, they are just (hopefully) less harmful chemicals.

    I know you know that Jen and I know I am being anal, but seriously once on a different Nest board a whole list of people were shocked that OMG SPLENDA IS A CHEMICAL! 

    ::headdesk::

  • imagesuzymarie:
    imageJen&Joe06:

    I used to work in the chemical industry and we supplied the products for this product (and helped to make it). So there are chemicals in them.

    Snarky comment:  EVERYTHING has chemicals in it!  Sorry that is just my personal pet peeve as a chemical engineer.  Natural crap is still full of chemicals, they are just (hopefully) less harmful chemicals.

    I know you know that Jen and I know I am being anal, but seriously once on a different Nest board a whole list of people were shocked that OMG SPLENDA IS A CHEMICAL! 

    ::headdesk::

     

    lol, I feel you on this one. organic chem will leave you no delusions. at any rate melamine is made from cyanamide, I think ... then again I'm not in the habit of eating my cleaning products either, so I'm ok with that.

    do YOU think you would come out ahead using a magic eraser vs. like...scrubbing bubbles or easy off or comet? 

  • imagesuzymarie:

    SG I am impressed that you clean enough to go through 2 of them a month.  I am also curious what else you tried to get the soap scum off.  Did vinegar not work?  It seems like people always recc. that, but personally I have to use some nasty chemicals to get soap scum off bc vinegar doesn't touch it. 

    Honestly, I clean our bathrooms once a month and go through 2 erasers when I do it Embarrassed.  1 eraser for the shower, and 1 for everything else (tub, sink, toilet, and floor).  Our shower has those little nubs on the floor to keep you from slipping, and they dissentegrate (sp) the Eraser hardcore.

    Yes, I tried all my green cleaning products including vinegar.  Soap scum doesn't budge.  I'm sure it's a combo of (a) I don't clean the door often enough; (b) the door is 15 years old; and (c) it's a builder's grade crap door that's 15 years old.

    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards