Cakes in Madison

JnJ04

I was going to try to be ambitious and make Isabelle's birthday cake but I think it'd be better if I just order one. We used Craig's Cakes for our wedding and like it but I don't think I want to use him for birthday cake. I'm open to any type of cake, regular cake, ice cream cake, cheesecake, cupcakes...

aglauner

I don't know if you have or know someone with a Sam's Club membership. But they do an really good job on cakes my mom uses them for everything and so do we. Plus they are really inexpensive. for a sheet it's like 25 dollars.

MadCity_WI

We did Craig's for our wedding as well.

Our new favorite cake in town is the choc cake with choc fudge icing at Lane's.  It's to die for, but kind of hard to cut in the sheetcake version (we had it for my baby shower).

I also really like Rolling Pin Bakery in fitchburg.  I went to a wedding in July that served three different flavors of their cakes (lemon, choc, carrot).  All of them were really good.  They also make a very good cake with whip cream frosting and fresh strawberries  (I had that last month at a friend's 40th b-day party).

 

 

mellytexas

I used to be all about Craig...until I had The Rolling Pin at a wedding in August. It is freaking fabulous. They had the fresh strawberry cake and a lemon cake. Both were amazing.

kmkaull

Ooh, the Rolling Pin is amazing.  Strawberry is awesome, and so is their "cow" cake. 

Katie