Upstate NY Nesties
Dear Community,

Our tech team has launched updates to The Nest today. As a result of these updates, members of the Nest Community will need to change their password in order to continue participating in the community. In addition, The Nest community member's avatars will be replaced with generic default avatars. If you wish to revert to your original avatar, you will need to re-upload it via The Nest.

If you have questions about this, please email help@theknot.com.

Thank you.

Note: This only affects The Nest's community members and will not affect members on The Bump or The Knot.

Need advice for engaged friend

Since it's so quiet over here :)

My friend is engaged, getting married next year.  She is going through a rough time with her future inlaws.  I would say she and her fi spend equal amounts of time with her family and his, even though his family lives prob 2 hours away and her family lives here.  Part of the problem is that his family never comes to visit, and then complains they don't see the couple much.

Also, she wants a small wedding and his family wants a huge Catholic wedding.

My guess is, the problem is that her Fi doesn't stand up for her, to his family, but he also sort of buys into his family's sense of 'entitlement' (like that if they want him to have a big expensive Catholic wedding, they should get it, even though the couple can't afford it).

It's strange, because I have been to hell and back with my inlaws, but I don't have much advice for my friend.  She should try to have her Fi stand up for her and what they want, as a united front, but it seems like many guys have a really hard time standing up to their mothers.  I was going to suggest the books "Toxic inlaws' and "Toxic Parents", but I feel bad, I have a feeling this is going to be a long-term issue for her.  I can tell she is so stressed that it is causing serious issues in her relationship.  Any suggestions?

Re: Need advice for engaged friend

  • I think her and FI need to talk ASAP. If he isn't standing up for her now...will he ever? That is a huge problem. You need to stand up for one another...even against your parents at times. If he's ruled by his parents, they sound like they will have a very unhappy marriage.

    My advice....resolve this issue BEFORE walking down the aisle. There is nothing wrong with walking away if it isn't right and the FI can't or won't chose his soon to be wife over his parents. It will be harder to separate after a wedding than before.

    Took 2 years & 8 months to make our baby! Lilypie First Birthday tickers
  • That's not for her to deal with with his parents. It's definitely an issue between the 2 of them and a wedding should be held off until it's resolved. The fact that he won't stand up for her and communicate THEIR wishes strongly to his family is a major issue, IMO.

    (And this comes from someone with a HUGE Catholic Italian family and I had to step up and draw the line on some things my family wanted and we did not. And visa-versa as my MIL was a bit more traditional-decor wise (no bows, paper decor, etc) and Jeff stood up and communicated that effectively.

  • This sounds EXACTLY like how my ILs are toward my BIL and his wife.  They live 4 hours away because that is where BIL could find a good job and they really didn't want to be close to ILs.  MIL blames her DIL for making her son move away from her.  BIL drives home about once a month, and MIL goes up there no more than once a year.  She complains he doesn't come home enough and feels that it is his responcibility to come here since he is the one who chose to move away.  When they got married, MIL had a problem with everything.  DIL is not catholic but compromised and had the wedding in a catholic church, but with the short ceremony.  You would think world was coming to an end with how ILs reacted to this.  For a month MIL refused to go to the wedding.  And they also refused to hold the rehersal dinner because of the church thing.  Finally at the last minute she changed her mind and they had a small rehersal dinner at a local restaurant.  But only set it up the day before.

    I don't have any advice because in our situation, there is no fix.  If BIL stood up to his mother she really wouldn't take it in and understand.  She would 100% blame her DIL for everything he says no matter what he says.  She would not talk to them, and do whatever she could to make thier lives hel without talking to them.  And she would cry and cry and cry. 

Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards