New Jersey Nesties
Dear Community,

Our tech team has launched updates to The Nest today. As a result of these updates, members of the Nest Community will need to change their password in order to continue participating in the community. In addition, The Nest community member's avatars will be replaced with generic default avatars. If you wish to revert to your original avatar, you will need to re-upload it via The Nest.

If you have questions about this, please email help@theknot.com.

Thank you.

Note: This only affects The Nest's community members and will not affect members on The Bump or The Knot.

Best place to buy an engagement ring?

Someone close to me is in the process of looking. He was disappointed in the prices the Jewelry Exchange had, but he went on Valentines weekend so maybe that's why.....anyway, I know there is a Diamond District in the city, but any recommendation as to where to go? Or other places. Also, what should be a decent price for a quality one carat diamond? I know it can vary but he is looking for something nice but knows he won't get a flawless colorless diamond. Thanks!

Re: Best place to buy an engagement ring?

  • imagewrysmyguy:
     Bluenile?
    That's where I was going to suggest. DH used them and the used an independent appraiser to assess it's value for insurance purposes.
  • tell him to go see John at Neves on Main Street in Woodbridge...he's a trustworthy guy.
  • our jeweler in the DD closed shop...a good friend's husband works at one but i don't know the name.  I can get it for you if you need it - let me know.
  • MH and I got our wedding rings off bluenile.com. 

    No complaints. 

    image

    image

    Lilypie First Birthday tickers

    Lilypie Fourth Birthday tickers

  • depending on her style maybe an antique shop? We got my engagement ring (yes, together) at Victorious Antiques in Cape May and I love it. When I put the diamond details (from the appraisal sheet) into the Blue Nile pricer it gave us a MUCH higher price than what we paid for it.
    AlternaTickers - Cool, free Web tickers
  • If he doesn't mind driving to Philly, Jeweler's Row is on 7th and Sansom. We've bought many items from Barsky Jewelers (wedding rings, earings, rings, necklaces) And my engagement ring was from Harry Marrell Jewelers. Both are family owned stores that have been selling high quality jewelry on Jeweler's row for over 75 years.
    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • Thank you! I will give him this whole thread to read. Bluenile users--are there safeguards in place when you purchase a diamond there? Like, if you get it and it's not the quality you had hoped for, can you return it?
  • Hubby got our all rings at Steven Singer in Philly...quite a trek but lovely store & rings!
    imageimage
    You will forever be my best friend. I can almost feel our hugs. I will ensure everyone will know (now and in the future) what a genuine, kind, loving person you were...I already miss your laughter and our daily conversations. I love you, Samantha. May 20, 1983- February 20, 2012
  • Bluenile is great! My husband got mine there. You can speak with a customer service rep so that you can be sure to get exactly what you want. I think my husband said he was on the phone for 2 hours! lol.The prices were great in comparison to some of the other places we had gone and looked at (a few months before).

    As long as it is not engraved, you have 30 days to return it.

    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • i also recommend bluenile! I lost my original wedding set when we were married for like 2 years. I ordered a new set off of bluenile. I've had it for like 3 1/2 years now, and couln't be happier! such great quality! even after wearing it everyday for 31/2 years, i still get people telling me " your ring is so shiny!"  haha the other day i was getting some bloodwork done and the girl was like " wow! look at that ring!"

      I was a little hesitant to buy something this expensive online, but our friend got his FIs ring from there and couldn't say enough good things. they had a 30 day return policy, so i figured why not give it a shot? it comes with a GIA certificate and an appraisal, and i think they have some guarantee that it will appraise the same at a jeweler you take it to?? can't remember, though. they will only deliver it when you're home, too- so i felt secure with that.  i would definitely recommend it!

  • we did bluenile as well and were very happy. Rings appraised higher than we paid also!
  • Mine are from this website: http://www.danforthdiamond.com/

    I took my e-ring to an independent appraiser and he verified that the diamond was what DD said it was, and it appraised for higher than MH paid for it.

    Plus their rings use conflict-free Canadian diamonds and recycled metals, which makes me feel good!

    image
  • Joe went to the Diamand District in the city... he took my BIL when he was getting ready to get my sister's ring... He went to Salvatore's (I only know because we get a card from them each year!)... I can find out the guy's name...
  • I can't believe how many bought a diamond off the internet - I don't think I would ever be comfortable with that or be happy buying something site unseen (in person)!  Just my opinion, but I'm obviously a minority!

    We use The Diamond Castle in Marlboro, NJ for everything!  They are amazing, they stand behind their work 100%, you can always exchange things, they resize my ring up/down with the seasons without even asking for proof of purchase/receipt, I stop in when in the area just to have it cleaned and to make sure the stone is secure - they're really an amazing jewelry store!  I never feel comfortable in those places, but this store is a different story!  GL 

    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker Lilypie Kids Birthday tickers
  • check out pricescope.com...great info/forums/referrals on diamond buying.
    image
  • DH went to the diamond district in NYC. My SIL at the time was working for a well known jeweler and one of his jewelers suggested this person. Once the ring was made it was taken to my SIL's friend who examined it and said it was perfect. I can find out who it was for you if you want.
  • I used a family friend who has been our jeweler for 20 years or so.  She's out of the Philly diamond district but travels to NJ for clients.  PM me if you want her info.

    She's made pieces for everyone I know (mom, mom's friends, me, SIL, SIL's SIL, etc)

  • Blue Nile was amazing.  MH got my ring there, he had to call and get the delivery location changed last minute b/c he was planning on proposing on vaca and a family member died right before so our plans were all over the place.  Customer service was amazing and worked everything out for him and the quality is amazing - I get compliments every time a jeweler looks at my ering.
    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • i got mine from Yanina & Co. in Cedar Grove. everyone in my family gets their jewelry there and i've sent almost all my friends there too. it's a family run business and they have amazing customer service, great prices, and really unique jewelry.

    they also custom make jewelry if you want something specific.

    http://yanina-co.com/pages/bridal/ 

    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • imageromil:

    i got mine from Yanina & Co. in Cedar Grove. everyone in my family gets their jewelry there and i've sent almost all my friends there too. it's a family run business and they have amazing customer service, great prices, and really unique jewelry.

    they also custom make jewelry if you want something specific.

    http://yanina-co.com/pages/bridal/ 

    Wow, I just checked out this site. Beautiful. I may have told DH I want the pink diamond ring when we hit the lottery LOL

    OP: We got my rings at a Diamond Exchange (Fairfield). We used a jeweler my FIL dealt with a lot so he was great to work with/negotiate with etc.

    Lilypie First Birthday tickers Lilypie Fourth Birthday tickers
  • I would suggest you to browse online. You will get plenty of options there and also you can hit on the best looking one in your budget range. The shopping is easy and also the delivery is safe and secure. The online stores like Angara.com can prove out to be the best online place to find your dream ring.
Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards