International Nesties
Dear Community,

Our tech team has launched updates to The Nest today. As a result of these updates, members of the Nest Community will need to change their password in order to continue participating in the community. In addition, The Nest community member's avatars will be replaced with generic default avatars. If you wish to revert to your original avatar, you will need to re-upload it via The Nest.

If you have questions about this, please email help@theknot.com.

Thank you.

Note: This only affects The Nest's community members and will not affect members on The Bump or The Knot.

Half-Birthdays

http://www.stfuparentsblog.com/post/12241798498/half-birthdays-are-the-new-black

 

I cant imagine people celebrating a half-birthday. I was born in the winter but I just wouldnt have the nerve to invite people to my house in the summer and have a half-birthday with gifts and cake. Maybe I am missing something. Please explain.

Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker

Re: Half-Birthdays

  • I think it's crazy and self centered.

    I LOVE that blog though!!!

  • I think that's dumb and annoying, but I really don't care what other people do.  If they want to celebrate a half birthday then go for it.  

    That blog is hilarious.   

  • Meh. Maybe my mom is a crazy, but my brothers (Jan and Feb birthdays) always celebrated their half birthdays INSTEAD so that they could have pool parties.

    Duke's House: Eating and Running with the Big Dog in Chennai: eatrunbrit.com

    imageimage

    2010 Race PRs:

    5K - 24:57 10M - 1:28:20 13.1M - 1:57:29 26.2M - 4:28:29

  • My Dad's birthday is the day after Christmas, and when he was growing up an old maiden aunt "switched" birthdays with him -- their birthdays were 6 months apart -- so that he could have a true birthday celebration, not just Christmas leftovers.  

    I can see that kind of thing for kids, especially as people are apt to combine Christmas and birthday presents for December babies.

    And I made a note of my BFF's daughter's half birthday, but only because it happens to be my DH's actual birthday.  I am weird and notice things like that.

    But I would never throw a half-birthday party and then an actual birthday party.  That's just self-centered and gift-grabby. 

    I don't mind being held to a higher standard; I mind being held to a lower one. (Sam Seaborn, The West Wing)
    Anniversary
  • I just skimmed the blog so I was thinking they were having a half birthday party AND an actual birthday party.  

     

  • I can understand that having your birthday around Chrismtas is not fun. But the people from the  blog were complaining about all winter birthdays not just the ones that fall close to Christmas.

    If you want to celebrate your half-birthday then good for you. But I think it is gift-grabby to invite people. Just have a pool party in the summer if you want a party in the summer. Plus, close family memembers and friends will feel obligated to buy two gifts even if you tell them not to.

    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
  • Gah!  I'm totally against them in any form.  

    If your kid is born around Christmas, oh well.  He will learn that life isn't all about his birthday at an earlier age.  Not a bad thing.  Summer birthdays aren't always that great - if you go to a private school away from home, you're less likely to have a lot of friends in your neighborhood and so may not end up with a big celebration anyway.  Or people are away for the summer, etc.  Again, it's life.

    I know someone who is 30 and goes on and on about her half birthday.  She counts down to it in her gmail status.  She gets offended if people don't come to her birthday party - like it's a wedding (not that you should get offended at that, but at least that's not a yearly event).  She also thinks she gets a birthday week.  I am sure that her parents generally spoiled the shiit out of her and that is part of it, but I'd bet that the bigger part of the problem is that they set a precedent by making way too big a deal out of her birthdays specifically.  

    You are born on one day and get one day.  Also, being born is nothing to brag too much about.  EVERY single person you know did it, too.  

    FWIW, DH's birthday is around thanksgiving and I still sometimes get him one present for that and Christmas.  If I'm going to spend 2 grand on something, sorry, but it's not going to happen twice.  Of course we'll still do something special and celebrate both, but it's the celebration that counts.  Not the presents. I don't know why this is such a bad thing to teach kids such that people feel the need to re-arrange things.

    IN Siggy Challenge for November - Favorite Cartoon Character: Rainbow Brite!
    Image and video hosting by TinyPic
  • imagedulcemariamar1:

    I can understand that having your birthday around Chrismtas is not fun. But the people from the  blog were complaining about all winter birthdays not just the ones that fall close to Christmas.

    If you want to celebrate your half-birthday then good for you. But I think it is gift-grabby to invite people. Just have a pool party in the summer if you want a party in the summer. Plus, close family memembers and friends will feel obligated to buy two gifts even if you tell them not to.

    I agree.

  • We may do some sort of thing like this for LO, but not quite the same.  We may have a big party in the early summer, invite LO's friends, get a cake, and give him presents (but before the party,) because he will be a very close to Christmas baby. Since the Germans around here aren't big on presents, we will tell the parents that we don't expect any gifts, just a party.  Anyway, I don't expect on doing many of these, but a few, just so he gets some sort of birthday party experience.  
    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • My birthday is in January.  Having it in winter never bothered me.  I always felt bad for the summer birthday kids because there was no school on their birthdays so they couldn't bring cupcakes to school, have their class sing happy birthday or anything like that, and it was harder for them to have parties because so many people were out of town during the summer.  But as long as you're only having one birthday celebration per year I don't suppose it matters THAT much when it is.

    My cousin, who is now 15, was born in February and didn't like having a winter birthday because he wanted to have outdoor birthday parties.  When he was about 5 or 6 he decided he was "changing" his birthday to September.  I thought that was kind of silly but his parents went along with it and celebrated his bday in September instead! He actually still celebrates in September I think.  But now he realizes it's kind of a weird thing to do and that you cannot actually change your birthday.  And we all make fun of him for celebrating a fake birthday :)

  • Eh, I feel bad for kids who are born in December and get dual gifts. It seems unfair when other kids, their siblings, whatever, get birthday gifts and christmas gifts but kids born near or on christmas don't generally get 2 sets of gifts. I can see how that would bother kids. 

    I also see, with ds's birthday in February, how a spring or summer birthday is better for parties, we have a hard time coming up with ideas for his parties when I would love to have an outdoor one but can't guarantee the weather will be warm enough, even here in the South.

    I don't care when people celebrate their birthdays, as long as they do it once a year, not twice. 

    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • I have a friend who had twins born on boxing Day so they celebrate with a party in June.  Then five years later, they got a brother born in June very close to when the twins celebrated.  So, now they have two big birthday parties in June.
    Photobucket
  • Each to their own. I am not one for celebrating half birthdays, but I do believe in birthday weeks. I have a son that has a birthday the same week as Christmas. He thinks that Santa brings both his Christmas and birthday presents. We do try and keep it seperate for him, but every year that we had a birthday party for him most people can't come because they are away or going to a Christmas party already so I could see the logic of celebrating a kids half birthday.
    Lilypie Kids Birthday tickers
  • In grade school we used to get to bring in treats on our birthdays, but mine was in the summer, and those with summer birthdays got to bring treats in on their half birthdays. But mine always fell in the Christmas holiday. So I was always assigned to bring in treats on some random holiday like Christopher Columbus Day or Arbor Day.

    I had never thought about throwing a birthday kind of half-birthday party for a kid born in the winter. I wouldn't be opposed to it, but it would be an "instead of" option and not an "in addition to" one. 

    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • My birthday is December 22 and honestly it's not really that big of a deal. My parents always treated my sister and I the same, I never had birthday presents wrapped in christmas paper or anything. I had birthday parties that included winter activities like ice skating or something and it was great. I am honestly shocked about how many people don't want winter babies just so their birthday is not near christmas, it seems so strange to me that people care that much. Also, I too used to feel bad for all the summer birthday kids at school because they had to bring cupcakes in when it wasn't really their birthday and most of the time people were away on vacation and missed the parties. It is bizarre now though that my birthday is now in summer!
    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards