Military Nesties
Dear Community,

Our tech team has launched updates to The Nest today. As a result of these updates, members of the Nest Community will need to change their password in order to continue participating in the community. In addition, The Nest community member's avatars will be replaced with generic default avatars. If you wish to revert to your original avatar, you will need to re-upload it via The Nest.

If you have questions about this, please email help@theknot.com.

Thank you.

Note: This only affects The Nest's community members and will not affect members on The Bump or The Knot.

What do you think? (housing question)

We are leaving for KS this weekend. Im kinda excited but we are having a hard time figuring out where we want to live off post. So here is my question.

Choice 1:Would you rather live 30-40 min away from post with little bit cheaper rent but dh would have to make that drive everyday,

Choice 2: 25 min from post with a little bit more expensive rent but with a bit shorter drive

Choice 3: 15-20 min from post with rent at your max budget (until he get promoted which *should* be soon but we all know how that works) but the shortest drive

DH and I are on seperate pages on this one. He wants to live further away to be more seperate from the Army life so he likes choice 1. While I want to be closer so it won't have to leave for work so early and save wear on our car. So I like choice 3. I know the simple thing would be go for choice 2 but neither of us really like that house. haha. So what would you do?

Also the rent is all within $100 range if that helps.

Image and video hosting by TinyPic Pregnancy Ticker Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker

Re: What do you think? (housing question)

  • I know my husband would rather be closer to work. You said it's on the max end of your budget, but can you really afford it? Would you have to give anything up to make room for the rent?
  • We live about 30 min from the base.  The area is far safer, we like being away from the base and the schools are better. 

    I would look around the three areas and see what other pros and cons there are before I decide. 

    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • Have you budgeted in gas prices? Thinking about milage that your car gets to price of gas? Does it balance out whats left over from BAH or is it more?

    We also take the price of gas into a decision like this.

  • The difference between choices 1&3 in rent is negated by the cost of gas. An extra 20 minutes each way, likely 5 times a week, costs money. Our comfort zone is 25-30 minutes door-to-door, then we look at proximity of grocery stores, gas stations, and the stuff we'd be driving to every weekend, like the dog park, and with all our animals, distance to the vet and training classes are also important. What fun is it to get away from work if you're not close to the stuff you'd rather be doing? 

    Twin boys due 7/25/12
  • Choice 2 seems like a happy medium to me. 

    Lilypie Second Birthday tickers
  • Have y'all ever lived that far from post before? If not, I'm sure your husband will change his mind after making the drive a few times at 4am. My husband said it wouldn't be a problem, now 3 months later and a 15 mile drive on the highway every day, we're counting down the days until our lease ends and we can move on post. Think about the cost of gas, my car is great on gas but since I also go on post almost everyday we're both having to fill up twice as much as we usually do and it sucks. I would go with choice three, maybe two if choice three had absolutely horrible neighborhoods. 


    TTC#1 since 12/2010- 12/2011 Hyperthyroid with Grave's
    DX 10/2012 Unexplained IF
    IUI #2- 4/25/13- BFP 5/9/13- CP
    IUI#4- 9/3/13- BFP 9/17/13- Due Date 05/27/14
    First ultrasound 10/8/13- 7weeks 130bpm

    BabyFruit Ticker
  • We live 40 minutes away and love it. But we made sure that we could afford the gas prices, and got a car that had excellent gas mileage. There isn't much around our base, so most of the people we know live farther away.
    image
  • Hmm. I was really going to vote for option two, but if that's the least favorite for both of you then you may need additional criteria, or another choice in the same area as option 2. Is there any chance something else may come available in time or are you practically ready to sign a lease?
    PhotobucketMilitary Newlyweds FAQ Button
  • I usually give DH's opinion more weight when we are trying to decided where to live. He is the one that has to make the commute, not me. But that is just how we work it. I think PP's offered really great advice regarding gas. 
  • Option three. We both work on base and I would hate to live somewhere we both disliked. Option 1 would leave you with an hour drive a day. I also would factor in doctor's appointments in base, trips to the pharmacy, shoppette, commissary, and BX. I love living on base and being within walking distance of our friend's. I also take classes on base so it would be a nightmare living 40 minutes from all those places.
    30 Rock Pictures, Images and Photos
  • imageDeblondie1:
    I usually give DH's opinion more weight when we are trying to decided where to live. He is the one that has to make the commute, not me. But that is just how we work it. I think PP's offered really great advice regarding gas. 

    Ditto.  The house we are buying is 30-35 minutes away from one base he has to go to, and 45 minutes from the other, and that's not including traffic.  H made the choice and the decision that he wanted to live that far since he loves the house and it's a great area that we'll be living in.  He is the one that has to drive it everyday, not me. 

    imageBabyFruit Ticker
  • Wow you ladies are great! Yeah we kinda figured about the gas thing. After thinking about it we will probably go with number 2 if its in a nice neighborhood, and its close enough to shopping and what not. I would love to live on post, but we have been on the waiting list for 6 months already and they said it would be another 4-6 before we would get anything. Kinda a PITA. I think we are going to drive the distances to kinda get our own idea of how long the drive is. At our last base DH drove 15 min each way. I know he wouldn't mind doing 5-10 min more, but anymore then that I think he would be mad. I just really wish there was more open but we are moving in when all the college kids are coming back and they are taking up a lot of the housing. boo.
    Image and video hosting by TinyPic Pregnancy Ticker Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
  • What post in Kansas? You can PM if you like. I have a friend at Fort Riley, they had a really bad experience on post and purchased a home in a brand new development pretty close.
  • I think I'd take option #2.

    When we moved here, we chose a place 40 mins from base. DH assured me that he was ok with the drive and it'd be worth it to live in a nicer place/area. 6 months in, he was dying to move. We had to wait for our lease to be up but now we're living in town, 10 mins from base.The cost of gas, extra miles on our car, time spent away from family due to commute was just not worth it. It was an extra PITA before he had a locker at work and they'd send him home for equipment. Imagine making a 40 min drive four times in one day.

    (lurking from TB/MF)

    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards