New Jersey Nesties
Dear Community,

Our tech team has launched updates to The Nest today. As a result of these updates, members of the Nest Community will need to change their password in order to continue participating in the community. In addition, The Nest community member's avatars will be replaced with generic default avatars. If you wish to revert to your original avatar, you will need to re-upload it via The Nest.

If you have questions about this, please email help@theknot.com.

Thank you.

Note: This only affects The Nest's community members and will not affect members on The Bump or The Knot.

Would you work for free?

Let's say your company tells you they can't currently make payroll. Would you continue to work?

I'm not currently in this position. I was just reading an article about basically an entire school district that teachers worked at for free (or close to it) because of budget cuts. The article was about WHY they did it. I think its admirable, but would people in other fields do the same?

Now at my last company I was in this position. I was told they couldn't make payroll but if we stayed on board at least half time, they'd pay us back in full when (or was it if) they got the money. I was 9 months PG at the time so I stayed on. Had I not been PG I would have stayed on only until I found something new.

So, what would you do? Just curious.

ETA: In my case they found money for payroll so in the end it didn't matter

Re: Would you work for free?

  • that is very admirable of them, I applaud their dedication to the students.  In my current job and position, absolutely not.
  • I would completely depend on whether or not I liked my job enough - are my benefits still there? etc etc.  If I truly liekd my job, then yes, I would stay on - I think it woudl prove my dedication if and when the payroll can be made (or cuts need to be made).

    ps - i left that disability tel number in the post below that we were takling about.

    imageAlternaTickers - Cool, free Web tickers Lilypie Second Birthday tickers Lilypie Maternity tickers
  • My sons and daughters teachers were doing just that when they went to the JCC in Deal. Eventually the school shut its doors, but the teachers were working without pay. I think what they did was commendable and admirable. I would hope that those who could afford it would keep doing what's best for the kids, but it's not always possible (financially).

    Would I do it for the short term? Yes. Forever? No.

    image
  • imageddelo23:

    I would completely depend on whether or not I liked my job enough - are my benefits still there? etc etc.  If I truly liekd my job, then yes, I would stay on - I think it woudl prove my dedication if and when the payroll can be made (or cuts need to be made).

    ps - i left that disability tel number in the post below that we were takling about.

    Thanks. I sent it to him.

    I assume the benefits went away at my company. I didn't get through them and the CEO said "oh good. then you are lucky".

  • TSDTSD member

    I am sort of working for free right now. It's for the greater good of the bigger picture. I don't know how else to put it but I'm not actually getting paid money to be at work.

    I probably would in a situation like you describe because working for me has never really been about money. Even before I had a husband and a child, none of the jobs I took were about how much money I could make. I was a social worker because I thought I could make a difference. I worked in tanning because social work broke me mentally/emotionally and put me in the hospital physically (I was attacked by a 14 yr old client), and tanning was less stressful, fun and exciting. I got to travel and party. The job I worked in NYC in between was for a paycheck to pay for necessities but not fulfulling in any way. Then I came to work with my husband to do something creative. I stayed home with E for 3 yrs and now have to work to help our second store get going and improve sales.

    For me work is about much more than a paycheck. Obviously certain costs have to be covered, I like nice things, etc, but it was never like a paycheck swayed me to do a job I didn't want to do, or made me put less into something I loved because I wasn't being paid more.

  • it would depend- at my last job- I worked in a lot of bad conditions and I did it, but if it was to happen again, I am not sure I would.  I felt abused and taken advantage of, if that was not the case then yes, for as long as I could-
    Kristen(formerly kristen8/16/03, but the nest stinks and I had to change my name)Wife to Mike, Mommy to Kieran 7/25/06 and Michael 7/14/10
    The Journey of Me
    Vacation, 2011
    image
  • Only until I found a job that paid me. And even then I'd probably be pretty pissed, tbh. My eye is on my family's bottom line.
    image

    Lilypie Kids Birthday tickers
  • imageTSD:

    I am sort of working for free right now. It's for the greater good of the bigger picture. I don't know how else to put it but I'm not actually getting paid money to be at work.

    makes sense for you, considering you own the business.

    I am essentially working for free right now because i'm 100% commission and it takes time to get paid out on deals.  but, I know there's money coming, so it's not really the same thing as the example cited.

    It is an honorable thing to do, but certainly not always a financially feasible option.  If you have children in daycare, covering that expense may be an issue, as well as it being unnecessary, if you could be home with them instead.

    there are a lot of factors, I guess. 

  • imageAmyRob04:
    Only until I found a job that paid me. And even then I'd probably be pretty pissed, tbh. My eye is on my family's bottom line.

    Absolutely this.  Maybe if I was single and living at home and could swing it but not when I have a family to support.  At this point I work for money.  If not i would be home w/ my kids

  • TSDTSD member
    I did it in tanning when the company I worked for was going bankrupt. Not for too long but I did. I had a serious loyalty to my bosses. They took care of me when I needed it- when 9/11 found me with no job they took me on without even knowing what to do with me- they had to make-up a job description and hope it worked out. So when it came time to help them, I did.
  • depends on the type of work and salary.

    my husband does continue to work and payroll isn't always made. And there's no advance warning either - they just an email the day it's due to arrive that it won't be. They have made it up - sometimes it takes a few weeks. He stays with it because we have enough savings to cover a few weeks, he will qualify for unemployment if they lay him off or close up, it is convenient to the kids' daycare. 

    yet, FIL owned a courier service and when dh told him about the sporadic paychecks, he said his employees would stop working if they didn't get paid. but maybe that's the difference between salaried and hourly? or the type of job? 

  • I work for a non-profit overseeing community health education programs.  Clearly, my job is much more than money to me.    I could make much more money in a private sector job that had a similar level of responsibility.  That said, my salary does help pay the mortgage, so I don't think I could swing it for very long.  

     

    image
  • I would if it was for an industry that was typically underpaid/understaffed and there to help people (education, museum work, hospital work), but not if it was a standard for-profit industry.

    I logged a ton of volunteer hours in addition to paid hours when I was working at the history museum. I knew their operating budget for the year and it was insanely low, so I was happy to donate my time in the interest of keeping the doors open. I loved that job and knew that volunteering in the off-season helped make sure I would have a job during spring/summer since those events frequently brought in donations and kept repeat visitors interested. I was invested enough in that museum that I wanted to see it remain a success.

    imageimageBaby Birthday Ticker TickerBaby Birthday Ticker TickerBaby Birthday Ticker Ticker
  • My benefits might keep me going, but not for too long without some sort of guarentee that I would see my money.
    Brenna Married 4.30.05

    Mom to Teagan 4.11.07 and Cora 9.30.11

    imageLilypie Fifth Birthday tickers

    Lilypie First Birthday tickers

    D&E @ 22w 9.30.09 CMV infection BFP 10.15.10 C/P 4w4d

  • I've done it.
    proof that i make babies. jack, grace, and ben, in no particular order
    imageimageimage
  • If I was in a traditional job I couldnt do it.  If I was working its because I need the paycheck.  Right now I work in mhs business and although I don't really get a paycheck in my name, it's our business  and it's work that needs to be done so I don't consider it working for free.  
  • No....flame me I am a teacher.

     

    My time away from my kids is too precious to not get paid and I need that money.

  • imageMrsEvans2Be:

    No....flame me I am a teacher.

     

    My time away from my kids is too precious to not get paid and I need that money.

    No flames here!  You didn't choose to teach to retire in Bali in the first place.  Our time is valuable and we do need money to feed ourselves!

    image
  • As a teacher, yes, temporarily.  If there was no guarantee of back pay, I'd definitely be actively looking for another job, but I'd continue to show up and do the teaching for sure for the time being.... I love my job and my students.
    AlternaTickers - Cool, free Web tickers
  • imageMrsEvans2Be:

    No....flame me I am a teacher.

     

    My time away from my kids is too precious to not get paid and I need that money.

    No flames here.  I don't think you can expect someone to work for free. If they are willing and able and do it I think it's admirable (especially in a job like teaching) but you certainly can't expect it.

    If you said "I was told next year I won't get paid so I'm calling in sick every day this year", I'd flame you. But to say "hey if I'm not getting paid I think i'd have to spend time with my kids", no flames here. Just as no one in any other industry gets flamed. 

  • imageLiz051405:
    imageMrsEvans2Be:

    No....flame me I am a teacher.

     

    My time away from my kids is too precious to not get paid and I need that money.

    No flames here.  I don't think you can expect someone to work for free. If they are willing and able and do it I think it's admirable (especially in a job like teaching) but you certainly can't expect it.

    If you said "I was told next year I won't get paid so I'm calling in sick every day this year", I'd flame you. But to say "hey if I'm not getting paid I think i'd have to spend time with my kids", no flames here. Just as no one in any other industry gets flamed. 

    I wouldn't expect anyone not to get paid for their time.  That's part of the reason why we all work, right?  I can see why some people may choose to do this-- they are loyal to their profession/ company, it's a small business you believe in, it's family run, etc.  Ultimately, there's some light at the end of the tunnel.  As much as I might want to do that, I don't think we could swing that financially.  

    I do think that people in the helping field get guilted into doing more for less.  I'm all about the cause, but I have a family that I'm helping to support, too.  I know we're all doing more with less in this economy--  so I don't know if this feeling exists in other industries.  And maybe it's my own personal issue, lol.

    image
Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards