AI

magsugar13

Everyone is wonderful...everyone sounds so great....everyone has a wonderful voice...incredible....amazing...so special....you can sing...wow

The judges make me want to poke my eyes out.

iLikeSloths

Saaaame here.  I was really hoping they'd be more honest this season and you know, actually give some helpful feedback!

I haven't been impressed with many of the guys so far.  The only ones I've somewhat liked are Colton Dixon and Phillip Phillips. 

magsugar13

I really like phillip and Josh he was awesome

FINALLY!!

bringjoy2theworld

We aren't hearing the same sounds as the judges apparently.  White chocolate is the only one I've liked so far as in he wasn't totally off key.

fl4lovers

I liked Josh and Jeremy the best. I am dissapointed Johnny wasn't the wildcard #13.

 

iLikeSloths

My phone rang so I missed the last 2 and I saw they gave Josh (I think?) a standing ovation!  Hopefully someone posts it on YouTube.  What song did he sing?

thetruthhurtsyo

J LO is apparently getting Paula disease. Some of her comments tonight were just weird. 

SWOG31

I'm a Colton Dixon fan, so I hope he goes far this time around.

KatiesCats

Aaron Marcellus is my fave fave fave.  I'd love to see him win.

All the girls this season are too pretty to stand a chance at winning.

Also, I don't get DeAndre Brackensick.  Dude's voice hurts my ears.  Also, Creighton Fraker, aside from the atrocious name, has an awful voice.

I just read that Jermaine was the wild card guy.  A good choice, I think.

GatorMrs_Esq

That Eben kid was horrible. Please tell me the judges didn't sing his praises too; I ff'd thru most of his performance and the comments.

fl4lovers

GatorMrs_Esq:

That Eben kid was horrible. Please tell me the judges didn't sing his praises too; I ff'd thru most of his performance and the comments.

They tried to be as nice as possible, but gave him cristicism. The song choice sucked.

SWOG31

fl4lovers:

GatorMrs_Esq:

That Eben kid was horrible. Please tell me the judges didn't sing his praises too; I ff'd thru most of his performance and the comments.

They tried to be as nice as possible, but gave him cristicism. The song choice sucked.

His song choice was really unfortunate.  He was really good during all the audition rounds.  I don't expect him to move forward.

GatorMrs_Esq

SWOG31:

fl4lovers:

GatorMrs_Esq:

That Eben kid was horrible. Please tell me the judges didn't sing his praises too; I ff'd thru most of his performance and the comments.

They tried to be as nice as possible, but gave him cristicism. The song choice sucked.

His song choice was really unfortunate.  He was really good during all the audition rounds.  I don't expect him to move forward.

Yeah...15 yr old boys should stay away from Adele as a rule. Lol. 

festivegal2008

I actually liked all the guys a lot, with the exception for one.  The guy that sang the Phil Collins song didn't impress me much.  Otherwise I think they brought their A+ game, and I am so glad Jermaine got another chance.  I like him.  But, I don't think he'll make the top 12.

As for the girls, some of them were strong, while others sounded too karaoke (as Simon would say).  Hollie is my favorite of the ladies.  That Skylar annoys the holy crap out of me.  She can sing, and she does have good stage presence.  But I can't stand to hear her talk.

 

festivegal2008

KatiesCats:

Creighton Fraker, aside from the atrocious name, has an awful voice.

Every time I listen to that name in my head it reminds me of something Yosemite Sam would rant in one of his tantrums.