Politics & Current Events
Dear Community,

Our tech team has launched updates to The Nest today. As a result of these updates, members of the Nest Community will need to change their password in order to continue participating in the community. In addition, The Nest community member's avatars will be replaced with generic default avatars. If you wish to revert to your original avatar, you will need to re-upload it via The Nest.

If you have questions about this, please email help@theknot.com.

Thank you.

Note: This only affects The Nest's community members and will not affect members on The Bump or The Knot.

Atheists - I went to Church tonight and I need to talk about it!

2

Re: Atheists - I went to Church tonight and I need to talk about it!

  • imageStrawberryBlondie:
    image2Vermont:

    For those that say they experienced this, did the priest literally say this or did you interpret what he said to mean this? 

    In the particular service I was referring to, during the homily, it was said literally. I don't think he was actually trying to be that blunt and was actually trying to do some sort of baptism/salvation theme but it came out very wrong.

     During the prayer at the end of mass, it was strongly inferred. Something about praying for all the non-Catholics, that they may see the light and experience eternal paradise.

    To be fair, I wasn't offended. But I did find it really odd. 

    I think my jaw would have hit the ground.

    Anyway, I think the closest I've heard to this sort of rhetoric is during the prayers during Good Friday services.  These prayers are the Church's formal prayers (said throughout the world I believe) for the Church and the world.  Prayers are said for the Pope, the Church, the Jewish people, non-Christians, etc.  With respect to the latter groups, I think reference is made to coming to know the fullness, but Hell is never mentioned. 

    And so I say to you, you are Peter, and upon this Rock I will build my Church, and the gates of Hell shall not prevail against it.
  • image2Vermont:

    I think my jaw would have hit the ground.


    Speaking of jaw hitting the ground... I also went to a wedding once where the pastor repeatedly said that the only reason the bride & groom found love was because they also love Jesus. Seriously. Like at least 5 times.

    That wasn't a Catholic church, though.

  • Glad you are on the same page.

    There are other interpretations of creation (someone/something started the whole ball rolling = God) and Virgin - not in the sexual sense, but "pure" in the sense of goodness.

  • I am sorry you had a bad experience. I do want to point out that the Catholic church isn't against evolution though. Their official position is that faith and the  any scientific findings are  not in conflict . It is called theistic evolution. I am not sure if someone else mentioned this but, figured it was worth pointing out.

    I am also really surprised the priest bashed other religions or that spoke for an hour about anything. So, sorry again that you had to experience that.

    Edit: To be fair I now go to a super liberal Catholic church that does collections for day labor workers and had a drag queen contingency today.  We also pray for Congress to get off its butt and create more social programs. I love my church.

    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • I'm sorry it was so awful, but I guess it answered some questions for your husband.

    You know what a heathen I am, but I usually enjoy Easter church. I like the music. I'm a singer, though. 

    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • 1) why was the homily an hourZ. The whole mass is an hour

     

    2) I have never ever heard a catholic priest say non Catholics are going to hell. We don't believe that. We believe in being good people. That's why so many other Christians don't consider us Christians.  

    3) we believe in evolution

     

     

    Are you sure you were at a catholic church lol? 

  • image2Vermont:
    imageReeve:
    imageLaurierGirl28:
    imageReeve:

    I never go into religious places for the same reason I never go to football games - I dont like them, they dont like me, and everyone is better off if I am not there lol.

    But my brother is getting married, and its a Hindu wedding because his fiance is a Hindu. I have been told that it will be in a temple, and I have to bow to some religious person or other when I enter. I will absolutely not do this. So now I have to work out the best thing to do - go and not bow, go and not enter the building, or not go.

    Luckily, my brother is a DNA scientist and an atheist too, so he will understand, but its still lame.

     

    I had this debate last night in the Church over this part of the baptism where the family is supposed to stand around FIL and support him '100% in his Catholic endeavors" or something to that effect. I didn't want to do it - I mean, i can support my FIL as a person without supporting his choice to join a church whose views/teachings I strongly disagree with. I also felt it would be rude of me to do when I didn't mean it. I have enough respect for the religion that i didn't want to participate in an important part of the ceremony when I didnt believe it. Does that make sense?

    I asked DH what to do, and he wanted me to stand up there, but I still felt like i shouldn't, not only to be true to MY beliefs but because i was lying to the Priest.

    In the end, I stood up there, but didn't recite any lines.  

     

    Yeah, this stuff is tricky. I have no wish to cause offense - at least, I wont go into someone else's place of worship and be offensive. But if I did bow it would be a mockery, and offensive to me as well, so thats no good. What use is fake piousness to anyone? And yet, its my brothers big day, and I don't want to do even the slightest thing to mess with it. For a whlie I just said I wouldn't go to any religious building, but then my stepfather died, and he was religious, so I had to go to his church funeral.

    That made me so mad, the whole service was basically "we are sad Brian has left us, but isn't the blood of Jesus totally awesome y'all? Wow, we really love Jesus!" I wanted to punch the priest in the face, and am still furious about it even now. In an hour service, about 5 minutes was dedicated to my stepfathers life, the rest was bullsh!t efforts to convince the very obvious non believers that Jesus was don dada.

    I don't know if it helps but my Jewish mother and brother attended the Easter Vigil when I entered the Church.  I'm sure it wasn't all that comfortable for them either, but they did it out of love for me (I suspect!)

    Perhaps I am too stubborn then (lol, I know I am too stubborn, I just add the "perhaps" out of vanity) - but I see no reason to put aside my beliefs for someone else's. I never usually run into this issue, because its easy for me to avoid being in places where I have to compromise. 

    Can I ask what you would do - would you pay homage to a false god if you had to enter another faiths temple for a relatives wedding? This is not a snarky question, just in case my tone isn't coming through right!

    Because on the one hand, I don't believe in any god, so I could pay homage to a sausage and it would mean nothing. But on the other hand, I am very uncomfortable with standing in front of a group of sausage worshippers and acting like I am down with it, because Im not.

    Probably shouldn't have used sausage in that example, but its funny, so I wont change it! 

  • I don't personally think being respectful means putting aside your own beliefs. Heck, I've been to Temple 4 times this year for various ceremonies. I don't share their beliefs. But, I am just there to support people I care about. I've never felt like my presence is compromising my beliefs. Me being there doesn't mean I believe what they do. 
  • imageIrishBrideND:
    I don't personally think being respectful means putting aside your own beliefs. Heck, I've been to Temple 4 times this year for various ceremonies. I don't share their beliefs. But, I am just there to support people I care about. I've never felt like my presence is compromising my beliefs. Me being there doesn't mean I believe what they do. 

     

    I feel the same way about just being there. But just being there and then being expected to join in specific religious actions of ceremonies? Thats a different thing, for me. Like, I had to go to a catholic wedding a while back. No problem, I can sit in the pew, not bow my head and not pray, and not give any money as the plate is handed around. If I did any of those things, I would be either mocking, or false, or compromising my own values, and I see no reason to do that.

    But I have been told I specifically have to bow to some dude as I come into the building - and as far as I can make out, it is like being told I had to pray to jesus on the way in to a christian building - and I am simply unwilling to do this. 

  • I'm sorry your DH was so hurt about the service. I do agree that many church groups/denominations do not agree with pretty much anything that he had a problem with anyway. I like our pastor at this church because he always uses "it was written that" instead of "it was" - so "it was written that Mary was a virgin" not "Mary was a virgin."

    Some people have a way of ruining it for everyone else....

    image
    magicalkingdoms.com Ticker
    Lilypie Third Birthday tickers
  • Who do you have to bow to? Thats odd. I think sitting respectfully is just fine. Hack, I often do not put money in either. I give one big check a year instead if spreading it out. Tons of people do that so it isn't odd to not put a donation in. 
  • We've occasionally entertained the notion of attending church when we visit my Catholic mother or ILs, just because it would mean a lot to them to show off the grandkids.  We've reached the conclusion we're not going to do it until they are older, because we don't feel like spending the time fighting the kids to be quiet when they are this little, and it would go double for Easter...at least IME, that mass is so long it bores the daylights out of me, and I'm an adult.  It must vary by parish, though, I've heard others say their Easter mass is no longer than any other Sunday.


    image
  • Ime, the only mass that often goes longer is Palm Sunday, and that is only if the priest is sits on reading the parts in brackets. I avoid palm Sunday mass like the plague.

     

     

    Mow,growing up we had a long winded priest. All of is masses were long,,lol. They finally demoted him. 

  • I've been in many Hindu temples (I was raised Hindu) and they are generally very accepting of different traditions, given that Hinduism encompasses many different beliefs.  None of the temples that I have been in have anything at the entrance to bow to.  I would suspect that you can avoid bowing without much fuss.

     

  • imageIrishBrideND:

    1) why was the homily an hourZ. The whole mass is an hour

     

    2) I have never ever heard a catholic priest say non Catholics are going to hell. We don't believe that. We believe in being good people. That's why so many other Christians don't consider us Christians.  

    3) we believe in evolution

     

     

    Are you sure you were at a catholic church lol? 

    1) Started at 730, finished at 10:25. I timed it :) Now, there was a whole bunch of different stuff going on - I think regular mass, the baptism/confirmation ceremonies, some singing, some more mass, the Eucharist, some random prayers.

    2) The priest implied it, wasn't said literally. Again, this is a VERY conservative area so I'm not shocked. I know that not all would say that.

    3) Evolution is a dirty word in this specific church.

    Oh and whomever said normally just the sponsor goes up - they did that first, and THEN the family/friends had to join and do the same thing. I didn't know that isnt common. 

    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • imageIrishBrideND:

    1) why was the homily an hourZ. The whole mass is an hour

    She went to Easter Vigil. Those can be 2-3 hours...but usually it's not the homily that makes it long!

     

     

    Are you sure you were at a catholic church lol? 

    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • imagekimi_brighteyes:

    I've been in many Hindu temples (I was raised Hindu) and they are generally very accepting of different traditions, given that Hinduism encompasses many different beliefs.  None of the temples that I have been in have anything at the entrance to bow to.  I would suspect that you can avoid bowing without much fuss.

     

     

    Good to know - thank you! Hopefully it will all be easy and smooth. 

  • imageReeve:
    imagekimi_brighteyes:

    I've been in many Hindu temples (I was raised Hindu) and they are generally very accepting of different traditions, given that Hinduism encompasses many different beliefs.  None of the temples that I have been in have anything at the entrance to bow to.  I would suspect that you can avoid bowing without much fuss.

     

     

    Good to know - thank you! Hopefully it will all be easy and smooth. 

    What kind of bow are you talking about?  Like bend to your knee or just tilt at the waist?  I could see not wanting to do the former, but if it's just a little waist bend, I think you could do that without compromising your (non) beliefs.  You can show respect to a spiritual leader without agreeing with with his religion.
    image
    Anything you can achieve through hard work, you could also just buy.
  • It seems masses in West Africa are 2-3 hours on the regular. Or people are taking me to the wrong churches! They manage to get all kinds of extraneous stuff in there...
    "We tend to be patronizing about the poor in a very specific sense, which is that we tend to think,
  • imageMrsAxilla:
    imageReeve:
    imagekimi_brighteyes:

    I've been in many Hindu temples (I was raised Hindu) and they are generally very accepting of different traditions, given that Hinduism encompasses many different beliefs.  None of the temples that I have been in have anything at the entrance to bow to.  I would suspect that you can avoid bowing without much fuss.

     

     

    Good to know - thank you! Hopefully it will all be easy and smooth. 

    What kind of bow are you talking about?  Like bend to your knee or just tilt at the waist?  I could see not wanting to do the former, but if it's just a little waist bend, I think you could do that without compromising your (non) beliefs.  You can show respect to a spiritual leader without agreeing with with his religion.
    and to make it pcer ...if obama can bow and still be the president, so can you Stick out tongue
    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
  • imageMrsAxilla:
    imageReeve:
    imagekimi_brighteyes:

    I've been in many Hindu temples (I was raised Hindu) and they are generally very accepting of different traditions, given that Hinduism encompasses many different beliefs.  None of the temples that I have been in have anything at the entrance to bow to.  I would suspect that you can avoid bowing without much fuss.

     

     

    Good to know - thank you! Hopefully it will all be easy and smooth. 

    What kind of bow are you talking about?  Like bend to your knee or just tilt at the waist?  I could see not wanting to do the former, but if it's just a little waist bend, I think you could do that without compromising your (non) beliefs.  You can show respect to a spiritual leader without agreeing with with his religion.
    and to make it pcer ...if obama can bow and still be the president, so can you Stick out tongue
    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
  • imageReeve:
    imagekimi_brighteyes:

    I've been in many Hindu temples (I was raised Hindu) and they are generally very accepting of different traditions, given that Hinduism encompasses many different beliefs.  None of the temples that I have been in have anything at the entrance to bow to.  I would suspect that you can avoid bowing without much fuss.

     

     

    Good to know - thank you! Hopefully it will all be easy and smooth. 

    I think I missed the part about your thinking you'd have to bow to something you do not believe in.  It looks like you may not have to do so afterall.  However, to answer your earlier question to me....NO, I would not take part in a religious ceremony in another house of worship that goes against my Catholic faith.  So, I wouldn't be bowing in a Buddhist temple either.

    And so I say to you, you are Peter, and upon this Rock I will build my Church, and the gates of Hell shall not prevail against it.
  • imagesapphireb:
    imageIrishBrideND:

    1) why was the homily an hourZ. The whole mass is an hour

    She went to Easter Vigil. Those can be 2-3 hours...but usually it's not the homily that makes it long!

     

     

    Are you sure you were at a catholic church lol? 

     

    I go every year... To different catholic churches and all take an hour.  They don't want to tick of the Chrieasters ;)

  • imageIrishBrideND:
    imagesapphireb:
    imageIrishBrideND:

    1) why was the homily an hourZ. The whole mass is an hour

    She went to Easter Vigil. Those can be 2-3 hours...but usually it's not the homily that makes it long!

     

     

    Are you sure you were at a catholic church lol? 

     

    I go every year... To different catholic churches and all take an hour.  

    And I've never been to an Easter Vigil that lasted only an hour....lol.

    And so I say to you, you are Peter, and upon this Rock I will build my Church, and the gates of Hell shall not prevail against it.
  • Can I just say that I hate bowing, regardless of religious connotations? Working in countries with bowing cultures constantly freaks me out. I never know what to do and always make a fool of myself. And I spend the entire day dreading my next encounter.

    I know you don't like handshakes 2V, but it just seems so much less stressful to me! 

    "We tend to be patronizing about the poor in a very specific sense, which is that we tend to think,
  • imageIrishBrideND:
    imagesapphireb:
    imageIrishBrideND:

    1) why was the homily an hourZ. The whole mass is an hour

    She went to Easter Vigil. Those can be 2-3 hours...but usually it's not the homily that makes it long!

     

     

    Are you sure you were at a catholic church lol? 

     

    I go every year... To different catholic churches and all take an hour.  They don't want to tick of the Chrieasters ;)

    excuse me, apex Catholics is the proper term :)
    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
  • imagemxolisi:

    I know you don't like handshakes 2V, but it just seems so much less stressful to me! 

    Wow.. some people really do remember everything.

    And so I say to you, you are Peter, and upon this Rock I will build my Church, and the gates of Hell shall not prevail against it.
  • imageTefLepOM:
    image2Vermont:

    imagemajorwife:
    lol. no one hates catholics more than former catholics! 

    Yeah, I guess I shouldn't have entered this thread. 

    Hugs to you too!

    I don't think  that was to be rude.  The most vocal against a faith are the fallen/no longe members  

    Yeah, this is me. I was raised in a pretty strict Catholic church and my level of bitterness towards it is off the charts. I still identify myself as a Christian, but I feel much more "at home" at my UU church.

    "Get your facts first. Then you can distort them as you please." ~ Mark Twain
  • image2Vermont:
    imagemxolisi:

    I know you don't like handshakes 2V, but it just seems so much less stressful to me! 

    Wow.. some people really do remember everything.

    Photographic memory. A blessing and a curse :)

    I hope you didn't take that the wrong way, it wasn't intended as a dig. 

    "We tend to be patronizing about the poor in a very specific sense, which is that we tend to think,
  • Saw this and thought of this thread.  Was entitled: Me when people post bible passages on Facebook. 

     

Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards