Eyeliner recommendations please?

Dr.Bean

Any recommendations for a long lasting, preferably waterproof, eyeliner pencil that I don't have to sharpen? (My new Urban Decay eyeliner is half gone b/c I can't sharpen for sh!t)  Thanks!

Yellow+Belle

What kind of sharpener do you have? I have UD's Grind House. It works great, & that's coming from someone who also used to suck at sharpening pencils. Before buying that I'd resort to putting my pencils in the fridge to firm them up before sharpening (which still isn't a bad idea). My everyday liner is currently UD's 24/7 liquid liner. It's fantastic unless you're looking for something to smudge.

Madison830

I don't know about ones that don't have to be sharpened, but I love Clinique eye pencils. I have a cheap sharpener (those little plastic ones) - and it sharpens really well even with that. Goes on smooth & stays put all day. Don't know if they are waterproof or not. 

Newlywed718

Covergirl Perfectpoint Plus eyeliner pencil, its self sharpening.  You just twist the bottom when it starts getting low.  I have been using it for years, it works great, and no need to sharpen.  It even has a litle smudger attached to it.

NSL

I'm not sure if Bobbi Brown's long wear gel eyeliner is waterproof, but it's never given me any problems.  

keeshondowner

I picked up 2 Stila waterproof eyeliners in March and really like them.  I can't sharpen an eyeliner to save my life!

MrsSandro

I have given UD 24x7 a go and I wasn't overly excited with the results. 

My favorite cheapie is CG Liquilineblast. It worked just as good as UD. 

http://www.amazon.com/Covergirl-Liquilineblast-Eyeliner-Blackfire-1-count/dp/B003FL3UNA 

fashion0police

The Stila smudge sticks are the best!! I received one in a Birchbox and fell in love. Its waterproof and is the only eyeliner I've used that has lasted all day. Much better than UD.

hz80408

Clinique Quickliner; I use the chocolate brown and love it

TexasSmith

I LOVE Neutrogena Nourishing Eyeliner. You twist it up, no sharpening.

Dr.Bean

Bought a Stila eyeliner at Ulta.  Hope I like it.  Thanks for the recommendations1

FrannyS

Stila is actually pretty good.  I would highly recommend the Ulta brand eyeliners.  They are cheap and IMO the best!!