Drug store makeup remover recommendations

krisim

I've finally used up all of my neutrogena oil-free make-up remover (which works really well, but it smells like dirt, ugh...!), so I'm in need of a new one.

I'm going to Walmart this week-any recommendations?

bim38106

Almay makes a good one...one-time-use round pads in a "jar".

TexasSmith

bim38106:

Almay makes a good one...one-time-use round pads in a "jar".

This is what I use, and I can actually get 2 uses out of each pad.

ToBeMrsT

I love Jojoba oil for removing makeup.  I order mine from Amazon.com.

Brixan

Unpetroleum jelly. (Amazon)

 

http://www.amazon.com/Un-Petroleum-Multi-Purpose-Jelly-3-50-Ounces/dp/B00028LUB8

~NB~

krisim:

I've finally used up all of my neutrogena oil-free make-up remover (which works really well, but it smells like dirt, ugh...!), so I'm in need of a new one.

HUHWhat?? I do not agree....!

krisim

~NB~:

krisim:

I've finally used up all of my neutrogena oil-free make-up remover (which works really well, but it smells like dirt, ugh...!), so I'm in need of a new one.

HUHWhat?? I do not agree....!

I don't know-maybe I got a bad bottle of it, but it smells awful.  Even my dh thinks it smells. I'm not picky about fragrances at all, but this is the worst one I've ever smelled!

 

adlove

I love the "Yes to Blueberries" brightening facial towelettes. They smell delicious and work really well!! 

Merryfj

I just bought Rimmel's and I love it. I was having trouble getting my carbon black volumuinous mascara off and my eyeshadow primer was making things hard too. This works great.

jessicah628

I've been using this one from Maybelline for years: http://www.cvs.com/CVSApp/catalog/shop_product_detail.jsp?filterBy=&skuId=263301&productId=263301&navAction=jump&navCount=3

~NB~

krisim:

~NB~:

krisim:

I've finally used up all of my neutrogena oil-free make-up remover (which works really well, but it smells like dirt, ugh...!), so I'm in need of a new one.

HUHWhat?? I do not agree....!

I don't know-maybe I got a bad bottle of it, but it smells awful.  Even my dh thinks it smells. I'm not picky about fragrances at all, but this is the worst one I've ever smelled!

Oh dear, it HAS to be a bad bottle. Was that the first time you used this product? I've been using it for years and it has no smell (to me). I just went into the medicine cabinet, opened it, and pressed it to my nostril... it smells like nothing!

krisim

~NB~:

krisim:

~NB~:

krisim:

I've finally used up all of my neutrogena oil-free make-up remover (which works really well, but it smells like dirt, ugh...!), so I'm in need of a new one.

HUHWhat?? I do not agree....!

I don't know-maybe I got a bad bottle of it, but it smells awful.  Even my dh thinks it smells. I'm not picky about fragrances at all, but this is the worst one I've ever smelled!

Oh dear, it HAS to be a bad bottle. Was that the first time you used this product? I've been using it for years and it has no smell (to me). I just went into the medicine cabinet, opened it, and pressed it to my nostril... it smells like nothing!

Well...I did buy it at Walmart, so who knows how long it had been on the shelf, or if it had been returned.   I forced myself to use it since I spent the money on it, which I'm now kind of regretting! 

dbucks

jessicah628:

I've been using this one from Maybelline for years: http://www.cvs.com/CVSApp/catalog/shop_product_detail.jsp?filterBy=&skuId=263301&productId=263301&navAction=jump&navCount=3

Yea, this is what I use, too.

But I agree that the Neutrogena one shouldn't have a smell. That's what I used to use, and I never thought it smelled. I only switched to Maybelline because I get bored and like to try new things. 

gwynnetx

i've used this for a long time and really like it: