Married Life
Dear Community,

Our tech team has launched updates to The Nest today. As a result of these updates, members of the Nest Community will need to change their password in order to continue participating in the community. In addition, The Nest community member's avatars will be replaced with generic default avatars. If you wish to revert to your original avatar, you will need to re-upload it via The Nest.

If you have questions about this, please email help@theknot.com.

Thank you.

Note: This only affects The Nest's community members and will not affect members on The Bump or The Knot.

How much would you pay for a birthday cake for a 3 year old?

A custom Snow White cake (not fondant - buttercream icing) for say 15 toddlers and about 10 adults...

I'm getting prices upwards of $85 and feel like that's just way too much. Am I out of touch with pricing?

Re: How much would you pay for a birthday cake for a 3 year old?

  • Sounds about right to me. I paid 30 dollars for a 6inch custom made batman cake. It fed 2 people (my husband and I.)
    image


    Lilypie Fourth Birthday tickers

  • WOW $30 for 2 people????? Indifferent
  • I guess it could feed maybe 4 but my husband likes a lot of cake lol.
    image


    Lilypie Fourth Birthday tickers

  • That sounds about right, I think.  They're probably counting the toddlers as full servings, so that's a cake for essentially 25 people.  just over $3/piece.  not too bad, but it would kill me to pay that kind of $$ for a cake for a 3 year old's party.  They only want the frosting anyways.  ;)

     

    image

    Daisypath Vacation tickers
  • Nothing. I'd just make it myself.
    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • imageJalapenoMel:
    Nothing. I'd just make it myself.

    I can't bake!!!

  • Sounds about right.  Would cupcakes be a cheaper option?  
  • imageMooseloover:
    Sounds about right.  Would cupcakes be a cheaper option?  

    I'm getting a quote on those tomorrow - hopefully!

  • I had 4 dozen princess cake pops, 2 dozen cupcakes, and a cake for 20 for $75 this year.
    I like salad bar, I like Despicable Me, tosh 2.0, I like Connect 4, Freedom of Speech, David Fincher, sidewalk, I like 1-800-SLIM, yo mama jokes, strawberry, Wilmer Valmavelma, Leon J. Panetta, ice skating for fun, not to save life. Cheese. Is for mouse. Are you Mick Mouse? WHY DON'T YOU GET IN YOUR SPACESHIP LIKE MICK MOUSE?
    Lilypie Kids Birthday tickersLilypie First Birthday tickers
  • imageone.sweet.world:

    imageJalapenoMel:
    Nothing. I'd just make it myself.

    I can't bake!!!

    oh, yes you can.

    Get to the store.  Buy a box of cake mix and a tub of icing.  walla.

    Want to get fancy?  Check out the Cake Doctor book from the library.  TONS of recipes that are based on a box of cake mix.

    Check out pictures online of cupcake ideas, and snow white cakes.  There are some that aren't that fancy at all.  My first doll cake was Snow White, and I had NO idea what I was doing.  Turned out fine.  And like I said, just used a plain old box mix for the cake.  Actually, if you make a doll cake, you'd be best to stick w/ a box mix, as the fancy crazy moist recipes won't cook all the way through (learned that the hard way, when I cooked the cake for almost 2 hours and it was still raw in the middle of the skirt).

    If you want to try it, let me know, and i can give you tips.  I promise it looks WAY more difficult than it actually is.  

    image

    Daisypath Vacation tickers
  • Yeah, that sounds right for what you're asking and no, I wouldn't pay that much for my 3 year old's birthday party. His cakes were in the $30-$40 range.
    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • Sue_sueSue_sue member
    5 Love Its

    About four dollars. I'd make it myself and it would taste great 

    Id serve it on snow white paper plates. 85 dollars for a cake is nuts 

    SO SINGS MY SOUL *WHAM!* MY SAVIOR GOD TO THEE *WHAM!* HOW GREAT THOU ART *WHAM!* HOW GREAT THOU ART *WHAM!*
  • I spent $120 on 50 cupcakes (if I remember correctly) for D's parties for a little gym and school, he was turning four.  

    The cake price doesn't sound totally outrageous.   

    ETA: The cupcakes were organic, ta da, lolz.  

  • The cake places around here are freaking rip off artists. Make some cake pops and call it a day
    image



  • I am going to try this myself!!! $85-$100 is nuts for cake that will end up half eaten and smooshed by 3 year olds on a sugar high.

    Have been googling and I think I can at least do Snow White inspired cupcakes (from cake mix in a box).

    Stay tuned!

  • I think the issue is that you want it custom made. 

    Can you just do a sheet cake from the local grocery or costco?

    Or make her a princess cake re: dr&rn. Her cake for Natalie was awesome this year.  

    image
  • imageelevendiamonds:

    imageangelaa73:
    The cake places around here are freaking rip off artists. Make some cake pops and call it a day

    Cake pops are FAR more work!

    Cupcakes are the easiest.

    No way josay. The kind we make is easy peezy 

    image



  • imageangelaa73:
    imageelevendiamonds:

    imageangelaa73:
    The cake places around here are freaking rip off artists. Make some cake pops and call it a day

    Cake pops are FAR more work!

    Cupcakes are the easiest.

    No way josay. The kind we make is easy peezy 

    I've never had a cake pop--keep that in mind.  But the idea seems gross, all that mushing together of cake, yick, even if someone wore gloves, still eww.   

  • imageAppleBear:
    imageangelaa73:
    imageelevendiamonds:

    imageangelaa73:
    The cake places around here are freaking rip off artists. Make some cake pops and call it a day

    Cake pops are FAR more work!

    Cupcakes are the easiest.

    No way josay. The kind we make is easy peezy 

    I've never had a cake pop--keep that in mind.  But the idea seems gross, all that mushing together of cake, yick, even if someone wore gloves, still eww.   

    Not for the cake squeamish! 

    image



  • sonrisasonrisa member
    Ancient Membership Combo Breaker

    Fluffy white cupcakes with fluffy white icing, on a tiered cake plate with a shiny red apple at the top.

    Walla!

    Snow White.

  • imagesonrisa:

    Fluffy white cupcakes with fluffy white icing, on a tiered cake plate with a shiny red apple at the top.

    Walla!

    Snow White.

    Pretty....I think that's what I will do. And I am going to buy the template on etsy and make cupcake toppers like this too.

    image 

     

  • That's awesome, ML (sonrisa :) just saved you moolah!
  • imagesonrisa:

    Fluffy white cupcakes with fluffy white icing, on a tiered cake plate with a shiny red apple at the top.

    Walla!

    Snow White.

    With a gilded mirror as a backdrop. Perfect.  

  • sonrisasonrisa member
    Ancient Membership Combo Breaker
    imageQuesera:
    imagesonrisa:

    Fluffy white cupcakes with fluffy white icing, on a tiered cake plate with a shiny red apple at the top.

    Walla!

    Snow White.

    With a gilded mirror as a backdrop. Perfect.  

    Oh yes!
Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards