Help me pick a palette!

Witchys_Woman · June 2012

I am shopping for a b-day gift for my sister. She is a dark blonde, fair/pink complexioned girl with green eyes. She likes neutral colors with shimmer and also tends towards pinks.

Should I get:

a) Naked 2

http://www.sephora.com/naked2-P302916?skuId=1393636

b) Sephora Moon Shadows in In The Nude

http://www.sephora.com/moonshadow-baked-palette-in-the-nude-P292307?skuId=1325885

c) Two Faced Natural Eye

http://www.sephora.com/natural-eye-neutral-eye-shadow-collection-P241303?skuId=1189224

Or something else entirely? I have the first naked and I love it but I think naked 2 would suit her better. Anyone have any experience with the other 2 or any other recommendation?

amandad18 · June 2012

When in doubt, I would always go with a Naked palette

ToBeMrsT · June 2012

Definitely Naked 2- I love mine btw. I've read the reviews on the Sephora palette and I don't think everyone loves it.

I think the first Naked palette would be a good option too though. I have it and my coloring is similar to your sisters. I use it often.

Earls_Bride · June 2012

Definitely go with the Naked, it would be perfect for her.

Photo5kCupcakes · June 2012

I have both Naked palettes and I have the Matte Eye by Two Faced. I use my Naked palettes more and I have considered the Natural Eye palette for myself, but I went with the Naked 2 instead

skyllingstadl · June 2012

I have similar coloring except with blue eyes and I LOVE my naked 2 palette- its the only eye shadow I wear actually.

StephB320 · June 2012

Naked 2! I have it and love it, and I also have green eyes and a fair complexion.

UnconditionalLove90 · June 2012

I have the Sephora Moon Shadows palette and I absolutely love it. I have the same complexion as her and eye color, but my hair is dark. The colors go on smoothly and blend nicely and the darker colors work wonderful as a powder eyeliner. I have wanted to try the Naked 2 palette though. A lot of my friends have it and they adore it. From my understanding, as much as I love the palette I have, Naked is a better choice.