Sex & Romance
Dear Community,

Our tech team has launched updates to The Nest today. As a result of these updates, members of the Nest Community will need to change their password in order to continue participating in the community. In addition, The Nest community member's avatars will be replaced with generic default avatars. If you wish to revert to your original avatar, you will need to re-upload it via The Nest.

If you have questions about this, please email help@theknot.com.

Thank you.

Note: This only affects The Nest's community members and will not affect members on The Bump or The Knot.

Paraguard vs Mirena

Looking for opinions on IUDs

I understand the basic differences between the 2 IUDs, effective years, hormone vs non-hormone, etc. but I was curious about opinions, side-effects (weight gain, pain, headaches, how long you still had a period, etc) from those who have tried one or the other (or both).

I'm currently on the pill and have been for about 10 years however my FI and I have been discussing going this route instead so I don't need to worry about taking a pill every day (like most people I will forget on occasion).

I appreciate any input and opinions out there! Thanks!

Re: Paraguard vs Mirena

  • MIrena is the best. Along with not needing to take a pill everyday, you usually only get very light periods or no periods after it is inserted. NO PERIOD for 5years is a great deal With paragard, there is much heavier periods and cramping from people that I know that have it. Seems like Mirena is a better choice.
  • Thanks for the response!  

    Did you notice any changes in sex drive, appetite, etc.

  • I've had the paragard for 4yrs.

    The only side effects I have are heavy periods ( day 1 light days 2 and 3 go through super plus tampon in 4 hrs day 4 normal day 5 light) and bad cramps for a day. Although, some months I only get little twingy cramps instead of bad cramps and some months none at all.  

    All in all, the worst of it is heavy periods. Which, is what every woman I know who has it complains about.  

    Our Website

    Kristi and Kerry June 21,2008
    image

    Daisypath Next Aniversary Ticker
  • With Mirena, I had no change in weight, appetite or sex drive.
  • I have Paragard and went that route due to how my body felt on hormones (worsening migraines, mood swings, etc) and family history of factor 5 (a clotting disorder).

     

    I have had an increase in how heavy my periods are, but I went from a very light, 1-3 day period with the pill to a 6 day period that was heavy the first couple months and now is more "normal" (how it was before I was ever on any BC).  Along with the first couple months having heavier periods, I also had more cramping those months.  The more recent months, I've had extremely MINIMAL cramping, average bleeding, and my headaches are almost non-existent which is a lovely change from my horrible migraines before.  Not to mention, I'm not constantly freaked out about getting a blood clot.

    Where there is love, there is life.-Ghandi
  • I'm on my 4th year of Mirena. I love it! Getting it put it was minimal pain and I just had some light cramping afterwards.  I was looking forward to no periods but I still get my period regularly every month but they are much lighter than before. I can wear a pantyliner the whole time. 

    I didn't gain weight and my appetite didn't change. I never had headaches before and don't have them now.  I would absolutely recommend it to anyone! I love not having to worry about taking a pill or changing my birth control monthly. I plan on getting another one put in next year and not keeping it the whole time bc we will be TTC within the next 3 yrs. It's really nice that as soon as it's taken out you can TTC that same day. I have no complaints, it's the best especially with a .1% chance of getting pregnant on it.  

    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • I have Mirena and I love it.

     Family history of blood clotting, extremely heavy, painful periods, and extreme migraines connected to my cycle.

     I am on my second Mirena and I'll keep them until I'm spayed or we decide to have a baby.

    No change in weight, diet, attitude, sex drive, or anything.

    image
  • thanks for the input everyone!!
  • Another positive vote for Mirena - I've had mine for 2 years and have had no ill side effects. I don't get a period and just get the mildest cramping every now and then (nowhere near as bad as I used to get before the IUD).
    image

    Created by MyFitnessPal - Free Calorie Counter

    image
  • I have paraguard and love it. I have had it for 1.5 yrs.

    No real side effects. No heavy periods. Periods comparable to the periods I had before BC in length and flow.

     Totally recommend it.

    Anniversary
  • i've had paraguard for 5-6 months. My periods are exactly the same, except that for the first 3 months or so I would cramp the entire week before my period. Its pretty back to normal now.
    My biggest complaint with paraguard i that after I got it I spotted on and off the entire month after I got it until I got my next period, so I had to wear a panty liner every day and that was annoying. 
Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards