Money Matters
Dear Community,

Our tech team has launched updates to The Nest today. As a result of these updates, members of the Nest Community will need to change their password in order to continue participating in the community. In addition, The Nest community member's avatars will be replaced with generic default avatars. If you wish to revert to your original avatar, you will need to re-upload it via The Nest.

If you have questions about this, please email help@theknot.com.

Thank you.

Note: This only affects The Nest's community members and will not affect members on The Bump or The Knot.

Seven bank accounts??

I recently read an article on Pinterest written by this woman (organizing pro, financial expert), who suggests that the typical married couple have SEVEN bank accounts! Wtf! If I remember it's a joint checking, wife's checking, husbands checking, emergency acct, regular savings account, "fun" savings account, and one other I can't remember. I'm sure you could google and find the article.
I thought it was kind of ridiculous. Do any of you follow this? Don't get me wrong, I WISH I had enough money to do all of this.
Which brings me to my next issue: she says you need an emergency fund that holds 12 months of salary that you don't touch ever...unless it's a true emergency. Like...you lose your job or crazy medical bills etc. ummm...12 months salary??! And you start saving by putting away 20% of your paycheck. That would take a long time to get to 12 months salary level!
Opinions?
«1

Re: Seven bank accounts??

  • vlagrl29vlagrl29 member
    Sixth Anniversary 2500 Comments 500 Love Its Name Dropper
    edited April 2014
    Seems a bit much.  We are self employed so we have 2 business account, 1 joint checking, 1 joint savings, 1 minor savings, DH has his own personal checking, and I want to open 1 more savings to save for house remodeling.  Now that I list it all out, we do have a lot!

    Regarding the 12 months savings, it's too much for us.  We just got 3 months fulfilled and feel fine with that. We don't work for corporate america so we will never be "unemployed" as we can always find work.
    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
  • I actually read that article from Pinterest about 3 years ago and H and I had 7 accounts.

    It ended up being a complete mess.  We had accounts between 3 different banks up until 4 months ago. 

    When I added everything up, we had a lot of money split up into all of these accounts.  Now we just have 1 personal checking that we both do our daily purchases and bills out of, and 2 savings accounts (1 for saving up monthly for annual payments and the other for our Efund).   I also have a checking account at a different bank that I run my business out of.

    If you do a written budget on a monthly basis, then there's no need for 7 accounts.  We also have "fun" money, but that's put into our budget and is a shared expense.  If one of us has a few more things going on that month, then the other person will spend less to make up for it. 

    As far as the emergency fund, that's a bit excessive.  The general rule is 3-6 months of EXPENSES in your Efund.  For our family, we feel okay with just 3 months of expenses saved because we can still easily pay our bills if one of us were to lose our job. Once we're done with Dave Ramsey's TMM we will likely save up 6 months of expenses.  That efund will go into a Mutual Fund through New York Life. So it won't be easy to touch.

    TTC since 1/13  DX:PCOS 5/13 (long, anovulatory cycles)
    Clomid 50mg 9/13 = BFP! EDD 6/7/14 M/C 5w6d Found 11/4/13
    1/14 PCOS / Gluten Free Diet to hopefully regulate my system. 
    Chemical Pregnancy 03/14
    Surprise BFP 6/14, Beta #1: 126 Beta #2: 340  Stick baby, stick! EDD 2/17/15
    Riley Elaine born 2/16/15

    TTC 2.0   6/15 
    Chemical Pregnancy 9/15 
    Chemical Pregnancy 6/16
    BFP 9/16  EDD 6/3/17
    Beta #1: 145 Beta #2: 376 Beta #3: 2,225 Beta #4: 4,548
    www.5yearstonever.blogspot.com 
                        Image and video hosting by TinyPic

  • I think she is using the word "typical" very loosely, lol.  I highly doubt many couples have 7 or more bank accounts.  Not that there is anything wrong with that, it's just excessive for the average couple.

    12 months of expenses...not necessarily income...is a great goal for an e-fund.  One million dollars is an even better one, but I don't find either scenario as being very likely for me anytime soon, lol.

  • Between me & my husband we have 5

    1. Joint Checking
    2. Joint Savings
    3. His Checking (we have our weekly allowance deposited into our individual accounts and it's money we can do whatever with & not have to answer for)
    4. My checking
    5. New car savings account - ever since I've had cars once I've been done paying off a car I open a seperate savings account where I keep putting my monthly car payment into. My theory is I'm use to not having the money, why not keep going that route. Each month money gets deposited to help me have a healthy downpayment for my next new car or for repairs when needed on the current car. This account is also not accessible by debit card either. Money gets direct deposited into this account every payday
  • I feel that is excessive. DH and I have:

    Joint checking - for everything (bills, fun, extras)
    Efund/house savings - saving up for a home and our efund
    vacation savings - just for vacations
    Christmas club - savings for Christmas
    Savings for DD

    We will open up another savings for LO#2 but that won't happen until September.

    3-6 months expenses & enough for deductibles sounds more reasonable to me. Since we can live comfortably on 1 income, 3 months expenses will be good enough for us to start while saving on other things.

    image image image

    Anniversary

    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker

    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker

  • Wow, I just realized we technically have 8! This is mostly because of a quirk with our credit union. We each have to have separate checking accounts so we can each have a high- yield savings account (4% on the first $3000!) They also automatically open a regular savings account with each high-yield. H never touches his; I use mine to put away for state taxes. We then have our e-fund and house fund with other banks.
  • We have 7

    Joint Checking
    My business checking
    e-fund
    House savings
    vacation savings
    car savings
    "other" big purchase savings

    this works for us, H has a long time not saving money that isn't flagged for a specific purchase...so having the various savings accounts helps him see the bigger picture of things.  last year he needed a new computer...which he could onlt have once the "other" fund has sufficient cash for it. 
    Me: 28 H: 30
    Married 07/14/2012
    TTC #1 January 2015
    BFP! 3/27/15 Baby Girl!! EDD:12/7/2015
  • H and I have 4.

    Our Checking

    Savings for E fund

    Savings for short term goals

    His old checking account(Which we don't use)

    As far as an E-Fund we only do living expenses. We live off of less than $300 a month right now so a 12 month e fund would only be about $3,600. We have agreed that $10,000 is a much better number and we are about $2,000 away from having it fully funded. 


    Anniversary
    Love: March 2010   Marriage: July 2013   Debt Free: October 2014   TTC: May 2015
  • I mean, we have 8:

    -Joint checking
    -Joint savings that I keep trying to close but Well's Fargo won't let me without charging me on the checking (which we do use)
    -Joint checking with me and my dad -  we mostly use it to send money back and forth to buy gifts for my mom and my husband
    -Fidelity checking (currently our house savings)
    -Fidelity brokerage (currently our e-fund)
    -H's checking account that holds his student loan money so that it's separate
    -2 credit union accounts - one for each of us.  We keep $5 in them.  These get us a really great interest rate on car loans and mortgages.

    We'll be closing H's student loan account in May after he graduates, so then we'll be down to 7.  I don't find it difficult to manage.  It's only 3 separate banks.

    I'm pretty sure my parents have like 15 bank accounts.  My dad works high-interest checking accounts like mad.  He makes something like $400/month in interest doing that.  And it's 100% safe.

    And 12 month's salary is overkill.  You need to calculate based on expenses, not income.... unless you spend every penny you make, in which case there are bigger issues.

    Wedding Countdown Ticker
  • I don't get this at all... It costs money to have that many accounts. I wouldn't have my own checking even if i wanted to cus its not free unless i have direct deposit. But either way i wouldn't want to. Right now we just have 1 joint checking and 1 joint savings. And thats all i care to have - all our money goes in and out of that one checking account - SO much easier to manage. It was a living nightmare keeping track of our money for the 2 months before we closed our personal accounts.

    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
  • juliebeannnjuliebeannn member
    Fifth Anniversary 100 Comments 25 Love Its Name Dropper
    edited April 2014
    We have 6:

    daily checking (bofa)
    autopay/bills checking (bofa)
    e-fund savings (ally)
    house maintenance money market (ally)
    car maintenance money market (ally)
    vacation/weddings savings (ally) - i'm in 3 weddings this year and have 5 more to attend, so having a separate account to save for this is very handy

    To each their own.  This works for us!
    Married 5.7.11 | Me: 31 | DH: 32
    TTC Countdown to 8/2015

    image
    image
  • It all sounds a little excessive, but we have accounts in 2 banks. Bank of America for basic checking, and then we have capital one 360 for all of our savings accounts broken down by what categories we are saving for. We only have a few months emergency saving but we are trying to build that up some more.
  • Why does it cost money to have accounts?  There are dozens (hundreds?) of banks that offer free checking all the time. And since a deposit is actually a private loan TO the bank, they legally have to pay you interest, even if it's minimal.

    If you work the high-interest checking account offers, you can make some pretty sweet money by having many accounts.

    I don't know why having multiple accounts is a big deal - whatever works.  Some people do better seeing things broken out into separate "pots."  Others do better with one big number to keep track of.  Given that cash is fungible, it's the same difference whichever method you use.


    Wedding Countdown Ticker
  • blondie42107blondie42107 member
    Ancient Membership 1000 Comments 250 Love Its Name Dropper
    edited April 2014
    My aunt and uncle saved their butts off from day one of their marriage. Living in a very inexpensive home, no cable, gardening, etc. They saved like it was their full time job. When they were ready, they paid for their brand new house in full - that they designed.

    My aunt knew she would want to stay home once they started a family. I seriously think that they were married almost 10 years before they had kids. My cousins are now in middle school, junior high and one just started high school.

    Because of downsizing, my uncle lost his job. They had a 5 year emergency fund but thankfully my uncle found a job in about six months and my aunt picked up a part time job since the kids are all in school, etc.

    I can't ever see myself being able to do this but I'm very proud of how well they planned!
    Lilypie Kids Birthday tickers Lilypie Kids Birthday tickers
  • We have a joint checking and a joint savings. I have a checking for my Mary Kay stuff and each of the kids (3) has their own savings account. So, that's 6 accounts.
  • We have two joint checkings, joint saving and joint credit card all with one bank. Then, the emergency funds are in two separate mutual fund accounts, so I guess that brings us to 6? We only use the checking and credit card on a regular basis.
  • hoffse said:
    Why does it cost money to have accounts?  There are dozens (hundreds?) of banks that offer free checking all the time. And since a deposit is actually a private loan TO the bank, they legally have to pay you interest, even if it's minimal.

    If you work the high-interest checking account offers, you can make some pretty sweet money by having many accounts.

    I don't know why having multiple accounts is a big deal - whatever works.  Some people do better seeing things broken out into separate "pots."  Others do better with one big number to keep track of.  Given that cash is fungible, it's the same difference whichever method you use.


    I think because if you don't keep the minimum balance in a lot of accounts you get fees.  Not sure.

    For us it would be great to have several savings account for annual bills, e fund, home remodeling projects, and vacation.  We are not there yet financially but I can see where I"m already starting to get confused by having our annual bill savings money mixed with our emergency fund.  When we switch to Community America we will probably open up a couple savings for my sanity.

    Kudos to your dad getting that much money in interest a month.  that would be awesome!
    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
  • The older you get the more money you have. The more wealth you build, the more accounts you will open. I think it's a great idea to have several accounts. I wouldn't call it excessive at all. H and I have several accounts too, and we don't pay a dime for any of them.
  • Having that many accounts would be overwhelming to me. I like to keep things simple and I'm constantly checking the accounts we do have to make sure no weird transactions are going on, etc. We have 2 main bank accounts. We opened the 2nd one recently to take advantage of a money back system. That one is checking and savings so I guess that is considered 3 accounts. But the 2nd two are just minimally maintained to get the cash.
    Anniversary
  • I just closed 3 accounts because it was overwhelming. One account required me to make at least 5 purchase a billing cycle to avoid fees. Now I realize I was spending more than necessary just to keep the account. I am using that money to pay towards debt. Eventually I will close 2 more.
  • I wouldn't have many accounts if there were fees associated with them.  our checking accounts are free (except we had to buy checks) and as long as we have at least $100 in each of our savings accounts there aren't any fees.
    Me: 28 H: 30
    Married 07/14/2012
    TTC #1 January 2015
    BFP! 3/27/15 Baby Girl!! EDD:12/7/2015
  • We have 5, but FI and I don't combine finances for the most part. They're all free accounts at our local credit unions because we have direct deposits going in them.

    1. My checking/savings

    2. His checking/savings

    3. Joint checking/savings (mortgages goes in/out automatically) and covers our quarterly bills water and HOA

    4. My checking for car/school payment, they both come out automatically

    5. His checking for insurance payments which come out automatically

  • We have 9 accounts.  No fees on any of them.

    1. Combined general checking account.
    2. His savings (used as a rarely touched buffer for the checking account).  Only have $1000 in here.
    3. Her savings account.
    4. Emergency Savings
    5. Car fund
    6. Travel fund (our parents are long distance, so this allows us to afford the "oh shit, I need airfare tomorrow) rates.
    7. Mortgage checking account.  We get a rebate toward our mortgage if we allow them to direct debit from an account with them.  We deposit just enough in here to cover the mortgage.
    8. EasyStart Certificate #1 (A CD with a 3% interest rate)
    9. EasyStart Certiificate #2 (A CD with a 3% interest rate)

     

    Daisypath Anniversary tickers
  • cbee817cbee817 member
    Ancient Membership 250 Love Its 500 Comments Name Dropper
    edited April 2014

    We have:

    1. My Checking Account (main bank)

    2. DH's Checking Account (main bank)

    3. Vacation Savings Account (at a local credit union)

    4. Savings Account (main bank)

    5. 3 CDs (main bank)

    6. DD#1's Savings Account (main bank)

    7. DD#2's Savings Account (main bank)

    We have separate checking accounts, but can push money into each others, our savings account, and the girls' savings accounts (all bank and credit union accounts are fee-free). Between Accounts 3-5, we have 15 months of expenses saved if we don't change any of our habits (like full time day care for 2 children). The girls' savings accounts are just for when they get older- not for college. College savings will start once day care payments are gone. We also have my 401K (fidelity), DH's 403B (AXA), 2 Roth IRA accounts (AXA), and a mortgage (with our main bank).

    Lilypie Kids Birthday tickers Lilypie Kids Birthday tickers Daisypath Anniversary tickers
  • We have bank 1 - joint account and joint savings
    Bank #2 - online joint account for savings for long term goals (cars, vacations,)
    Bank 3 - MY personal money
    Bank 4 - DH personal money
    Bank 5 - savings money for house - taxes, renovations &
    Bank 5 - checking - auto deduct for utilities
    additional
    Annuity
    Investments
    Retirement

    I find this easy to track., no fees and keeps our accounts covered by FDIC

  • I don't get this at all... It costs money to have that many accounts. I wouldn't have my own checking even if i wanted to cus its not free unless i have direct deposit. But either way i wouldn't want to. Right now we just have 1 joint checking and 1 joint savings. And thats all i care to have - all our money goes in and out of that one checking account - SO much easier to manage. It was a living nightmare keeping track of our money for the 2 months before we closed our personal accounts.

    I can't speak for the others, but we have managed to set all of ours up where they are fee free. They don't all earn interest, but at least there are no fees.
  • Erikan73 said:
    I can't speak for the others, but we have managed to set all of ours up where they are fee free. They don't all earn interest, but at least there are no fees.

    We don't pay fees on any of our accounts either and they all earn interest even if it is a pathetic amount.
    Daisypath Anniversary tickers
  • I do much better having things separated instead of in one big account--DH is the opposite but since I'm the one that deals with most of our money he doesn't seem to mind. I didn't realize how many accounts we had until I wrote it all down! It looks like a lot but I think it's easy to manage them since they're at credit unions that have no fees attached to them and we only have accounts with 3 organizations. We can easily transfer money between all our accounts which is important to us.

    Pretty much all the money from my paycheck goes straight into my checking account which is used to pay all of our bills, then DH's paycheck (he makes a lot more than me, lol) gets split into all our other accounts. We started this as a trial because DH's work was going through layoffs a few months ago and we wanted to try to live off of just my income, and put his income away as savings--it worked for us. When we have kids we would like one of us to stay home with them, so we're trying to save up as much as we can for now.

    -My Checking-used for all bills

    -My Savings-mostly used to save up for random things we might need for the house or pet expenses.

    -My Savings2-a joint account with my mom from when I was little. I still use it to transfer money to her on occasion when she needs it, but aside from that I rarely use it.

    -Joint Checking-used for pretty much everything that isn't a bill--ie groceries, eating out, gas, etc.

    -Joint Savings-Our E-Fund

    -DH Checking-This was for his SLs but now it's rarely used.

    -DH Savings-He uses this mostly to transfer some money between his parents and himself on occasion. This one also stores our long-term goal money (mostly vacation funds)

    -DH Savings2-Money for our godchildren. We started this as a possible college fund/e-fund for our 2 nieces and nephew. The plan is to give them the money when they turn 18 or 21--no one else knows about this fund except us--DH's brother is horrible with money so we didn't want to let him know about it, but we wanted to have something in case the kids really needed it

    -DH is planning on opening up another savings account tomorrow when he gets paid--this one will be for our future kids and to cover expenses. Apparently that article I showed him the other day really hit home.

    We both also have Roth IRAs through Fidelity, and DH has a 401k through work.
  • hoffsehoffse member
    Sixth Anniversary 2500 Comments 500 Love Its Name Dropper
    edited April 2014
    ^^I love that idea about the account for your godchildren.  H and I need to consider that for any future nieces/nephews we have.  His brother is also horrible with money, and it sucks when kids are the ones who pay for it.

    Right now our "baby fund" is primarily a bank of Amazon rewards points.  I've been saving them for about a year, and H gets free Amazon gift cards as perks for his on-campus job.  So we're saving those too.  We did this before we got married and ended up spending less than $100 out of pocket to complete our registry.  I'm hoping for a similar result when it comes to "start up" expenses for a kid.  Between trying to be minimal/thoughtful with the baby crap we buy and our Amazon account we ought to do pretty well.

    By the way - Amazon gives you a 15% one-time discount off your baby registry if you register with them and sign up for Amazon Mom.  You can also make the registry private if you want to stock up on some things that are sort of awkward and still get the discount.  I was totally that girl who set up a bunch of extra registries when we got married just for the completion discounts....
    Wedding Countdown Ticker
  • Haha, I did the same thing with our marriage registries @hoffse. DH thought I was crazy, but he's known me long enough to just go with the flow. That's a great tip about Amazon rewards though--I'll have to look into that some more.

    And I totally agree that the kids shouldn't have to pay for their parent's mistakes. It was easier when we lived nearby and could take the kids shopping for clothes and stuff if they needed it (contrary to what DH's brother thinks, toddlers do in fact need a winter coat and mittens--especially if they live someplace where it snows a lot like Colorado! But apparently we're the weird ones in the family--go figure!) but being long distance this is the best we can do. At least the kids will have some sort of cushion if they ever need it.
Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards