Nest Book Club

What is your star rating criteria?

We all rate our books many different ways, I am curious how you decide how many stars to give a book :-)

image
my read shelf:
Jess (Shepherdjel)'s book recommendations, liked quotes, book clubs, book trivia, book lists (read shelf)

Re: What is your star rating criteria?

  • 1*-Did not Finish
    2*- Hated/ highly disliked
    3*- It was just ok, nothing great but nothing awful (or too awful)
    4*- Really liked it but something bothered me
    5*- Absolutely LOVED!

    image
    my read shelf:
    Jess (Shepherdjel)'s book recommendations, liked quotes, book clubs, book trivia, book lists (read shelf)
  • One Star : I don't think I've ever rated a book one star.  Probably because if I hated a book that much, I wouldn't bother finishing it.
    Two Stars: I got through it,barely, but I would not recommend it to other people. 
    Three Stars: I enjoyed reading it, but probably would not read it again. 
    Four Stars: I enjoyed reading it and would recommend it to someone else.
    Five Stars: LOVED IT!!  It could be a terribly written book for all I care, but if it sucked me in enough to overlook the mistakes, it will still get those 5 stars.

    I need to rate more books.  Most of the books I have rated have been 4 or 5 stars.

    my read shelf:
    Miranda's book recommendations, liked quotes, book clubs, book trivia, book lists (read shelf)
    image
    “Would you tell me, please, which way I ought to go from here?"
    "That depends a good deal on where you want to get to."
    "I don't much care where –"
    "Then it doesn't matter which way you go.”
    ― Lewis Carroll, Alice in Wonderland


  • Menrandes said:
    One Star : I don't think I've ever rated a book one star.  Probably because if I hated a book that much, I wouldn't bother finishing it.
    Two Stars: I got through it,barely, but I would not recommend it to other people. 
    Three Stars: I enjoyed reading it, but probably would not read it again. 
    Four Stars: I enjoyed reading it and would recommend it to someone else.
    Five Stars: LOVED IT!!  It could be a terribly written book for all I care, but if it sucked me in enough to overlook the mistakes, it will still get those 5 stars.

    I need to rate more books.  Most of the books I have rated have been 4 or 5 stars.

    This is almost exactly my criteria
  • I basically just use what gr has.
    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
    Anniversary
    Image and video hosting by TinyPic
  • sonore32 said:
    Menrandes said:
    One Star : I don't think I've ever rated a book one star.  Probably because if I hated a book that much, I wouldn't bother finishing it.
    Two Stars: I got through it,barely, but I would not recommend it to other people. 
    Three Stars: I enjoyed reading it, but probably would not read it again. 
    Four Stars: I enjoyed reading it and would recommend it to someone else.
    Five Stars: LOVED IT!!  It could be a terribly written book for all I care, but if it sucked me in enough to overlook the mistakes, it will still get those 5 stars.

    I need to rate more books.  Most of the books I have rated have been 4 or 5 stars.

    This is almost exactly my criteria
    Me too, but I do rate books 1 star, I usually only end up finishing one star books if they are for book clubs or challenges.
    my read shelf:
    B's book recommendations, liked quotes, book clubs, book trivia, book lists (read shelf)
  • 1* = DNF
    2* = Meh.
    3* = Enjoyed it well enough, maybe even enjoyed it a good amount, but it didn't stand out as something I'm going to rave about.
    4* = Most of what I read. I liked it, probably a lot, and would recommend it to someone looking for something similar.
    5* = loved!
    image
    Vellichor: The strange wistfulness of used bookstores
  • Raeily said:
    I basically just use what gr has.
    Do they have an actual criteria?

    image
    my read shelf:
    Jess (Shepherdjel)'s book recommendations, liked quotes, book clubs, book trivia, book lists (read shelf)
  • 1 - Just awful.  Either poorly written or something that falls way below my expectations.
    2 - Not great but not deserving of 1 star.  Usually I put stuff that is tedious/too long/in need of an editor here.
    3 - Not bad, not amazing.  Stuff I liked but that is ultimately forgettable.
    4 - Really good, just missing that 5 star quality.  I seem to give more 4 star ratings than any other.
    5 - Amazing books that I absolutely loved.  Occasionally something that was just beautifully written even if the subject matter wasn't my cup of tea.
    lBaby Birthday Ticker Ticker
  • 1 - Terrible
    2 - Bad
    3 - Generic - not exceptional either way
    4 - Liked it
    5 - Loved it

    When I do reviews though, I review the writing and how much I enjoyed it separately.  There have been too many really awful books that I've loved and too many really well written books that bored me to do anything else.
    imageimage image
  • I try to hold back a bit on rating a book 5*.  It has to be "OMG AMAZING!" to get 5*.  Books that are really, really, really good get 4*.

    For comparison, my books read in 2012 (I didn't read as much in 2013 due to moving) - 6/50 were 5* and 16/50 were 4*.

  • 1 - Terrible
    2 - Bad
    3 - Generic - not exceptional either way
    4 - Liked it
    5 - Loved it

    I think this is me, too.  The majority of my books are 4 stars, although I just came out of a run of 3 star books.

    Sometimes I'll give a 3 star rating to a book that I liked because something bothered me about the book, like an irritating MC.

    image
  • 1  - Horrible, will actively tell people how bad it was so they don't succumb to the same fate.
    2  - Dislike, wish I got my time back from reading it.
    3  - Not remarkable either way.  Not sorry I read it, but I will probably never think of it again.
    4  - Really enjoyed, will recommend, but not flawless.
    5  - OMG, AMAZEBALLS, SHOUT FROM THE ROOF TOPS.
    image
    116 books in 2016

    my read shelf:
    Lauren (SnShne322)'s book recommendations, liked quotes, book clubs, book trivia, book lists (read shelf)
    Wes: 10/8/2012


  • 1 - Terrible, I usually give out few of these
    2 - Pretty bad but not terrible
    3 - Okay, nothing profound
    4 - Liked it
    5 - Loved it, amazing, again I usually give out very few of these.

    I really want half star ratings already.
    image
    Books read in 2011: 111
    Books read in 2012: 100
    Books read in 2013: 75
    Books read in 2014: 130
    Books read in 2015: 98
    my read shelf:
    Jennifer's book recommendations, liked quotes, book clubs, book trivia, book lists (read shelf)
  • j*&p*j*&p*
    Tenth Anniversary 5000 Comments 250 Love Its Name Dropper
    member
    1*- Cormac McCarthy
    2*- really disliked it, or the book really wasn't for me
    3* - fun and worth reading, but not something I'd likely read again/ really deserves a 2* rating, but I don't want the bad karma of tearing down other people's hard work
    4*- something I really liked and probably gush about and push on reader friends
    5* - See 4*s, plus there's a little piece of my soul in the book somehow
    image image
  • 1 - I thought it was bad, and would encourage people not to read it.
    2 - Meh. I didn't think it was very good, but it has a few good points.
    3 - It was okay. There were some things I really liked, but I didn't think it was great.
    4 - Good. I really liked it, and I would probably recommend it, but it wasn't perfect.
    5 - Fantastic. Almost no negative points, and I would consider it a classic within its genre.
    image
  • I use GR's:

    1- did not like it
    2- is was ok
    3- liked it
    4- really liked it
    5- it was amazing
    Duxcaelo's book recommendations, favorite quotes, book clubs, book trivia, book lists (2011-goodreads shelf)
    Anniversary
  • Mine is pretty similar to GR:

    1- Actively disliked it
    2- It was ok
    3- Liked it, but probably wouldn't recommend it to others
    4- Liked it and would recommend to others
    5- Loved it. 


    image Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker

    My read shelf:
    Jessica Ninneman's book recommendations, liked quotes, book clubs, book trivia, book lists (read shelf)
  • fabkfabk
    5000 Comments 500 Love Its Fourth Anniversary First Answer
    member
    1- Hated it
    2- Disliked it
    3- It was okay
    4- Really liked it
    5- Can't stop thinking about it, everyone must read
Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards