Money Matters
Dear Community,

Our tech team has launched updates to The Nest today. As a result of these updates, members of the Nest Community will need to change their password in order to continue participating in the community. In addition, The Nest community member's avatars will be replaced with generic default avatars. If you wish to revert to your original avatar, you will need to re-upload it via The Nest.

If you have questions about this, please email help@theknot.com.

Thank you.

Note: This only affects The Nest's community members and will not affect members on The Bump or The Knot.

Buying a rental/vacation property

Hello MMers!

Just curious about other's experiences with buying and owning rental properties. DH and I are considering buying a mountain property that is about 2 hours from our current home. The main reason would be to have a place to go, especially once we have a family and spend time throughout the year. We are also planning on buying in close proximity (within 20 minutes) of a ski resort so that we could potentially rent out the property throughout the year. This would not be the main purpose of the property, but it would be a nice bonus. We are planning to spend $160,000 or less and probably buy a fixer upper to invest some time/money in over the years. So the mortgage would not be a concern to pay with our budget.

Our dream property would end up looking like this...http://jeffreal.idxbroker.com/idx/photogallery/a084/S393077

So, who has experience owning a rental property or vacation home? What has your experience been like?
Lilypie Pregnancy tickers

Re: Buying a rental/vacation property

  • I would love to do this, but I'm scared to take the leap for a few reasons.

    1) We live in Ohio and if I buy vacation property I want it to be at the beach.  That means we would have to hire a property manager to deal with it.

    2) If we buy a vacation property I'm worried that I will feel guilty if we vacation somewhere else since we have a "free" place to go.

    We may do it someday, especially if it is a place where we could retire to when we are older.  

    Things you will want to consider if you go this route (random thoughts off the top of my head):
    -Taxes on rental revenue
    -Wear and tear from renters
    -Property management (collecting money, arranging cleaning, billing for damages, etc.)
    -Insurance on a non-residential property
    -Carrying costs when not in use by you or renters
    Formerly AprilH81
    photo composite_14153800476219jpg

  • This is something DH would like to do and I think it would be awesome once we get more cash flow in our pockets.  We vacation sometimes in florissent CO and have stayed at a cabin twice now.  DH would like to buy some property in that area in the mountains and build our own cabin.  We would use it for vacationers and have a management property take care of it because we live in MO.  We would go there a couple times a year to use it ourselves.
    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
  • bmo88bmo88 member
    500 Comments Fourth Anniversary 250 Love Its Name Dropper
    @vlagrl29: We live about 1 hour from Florissant! Beautiful area!
    Lilypie Pregnancy tickers
  • We talk about this pretty frequently. We live in the Midwest, but H's dad lives in Florida and he went to school there, so we typically visit 2-3 times a year. I'd like something on the Space Coast but Orlando's real estate prices are more reasonable. I wouldn't do it now but once we have our primary mortgage paid off, I'd consider it. I'd also consider it if H becomes self employed or gets a job with a company that would allow him to work remotely, so that we could stay there during the winter months.
    HeartlandHustle | Personal Finance and Betterment Blog  
  • AprilZ81 said:
    I would love to do this, but I'm scared to take the leap for a few reasons.

    1) We live in Ohio and if I buy vacation property I want it to be at the beach.  That means we would have to hire a property manager to deal with it.

    2) If we buy a vacation property I'm worried that I will feel guilty if we vacation somewhere else since we have a "free" place to go.

    We may do it someday, especially if it is a place where we could retire to when we are older.  

    Things you will want to consider if you go this route (random thoughts off the top of my head):
    -Taxes on rental revenue
    -Wear and tear from renters
    -Property management (collecting money, arranging cleaning, billing for damages, etc.)
    -Insurance on a non-residential property
    -Carrying costs when not in use by you or renters
    I think that the bolded is a really important consideration. My inlaws own a lake house 1.5-2hours from us, and I basically feel guilty spending any money to go anywhere between may and october.  I always feel like we need to go stay at the "free" place.  I think that if we owned it, it would be even worse, feeling like we were paying for two vacations if we went away somewhere.  Not saying we won't ever do it, it's just something to think about.
  • bmo88 said:
    @vlagrl29: We live about 1 hour from Florissant! Beautiful area!
    Yes it is!  Last time we vacationed there a couple years ago he contacted a real estate agent in that area to look at properties for sale.  The actual cost of land is pretty cheap.  Our home is paid off and he is about to open his photog studio which he will pay off in 10 years - possibly after that we will do it.
    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
  • I think that the bolded is a really important consideration. My inlaws own a lake house 1.5-2hours from us, and I basically feel guilty spending any money to go anywhere between may and october.  I always feel like we need to go stay at the "free" place.  I think that if we owned it, it would be even worse, feeling like we were paying for two vacations if we went away somewhere.  Not saying we won't ever do it, it's just something to think about.
    I think we'd be in the same boat.  I think it works a lot better when you don't have limited time off or you get a place where you can get off work Friday night, drive there, come back Sunday night, and are the type to go out there every weekend or at least a bunch of them.

    Don't get me wrong, I love the idea, but we only get so much vacation time and I want to see the world.  Not feel like I have to go to the beach/lake/ski house.

    Just a thought though.....it might be worth looking into a condo or something similar just because then you wouldn't have to worry about the exterior maintainence.
    Daisypath Anniversary tickers
  • bmo88bmo88 member
    500 Comments Fourth Anniversary 250 Love Its Name Dropper
    jtmh2012: We have about 60 days vacation a year (we both work at school) and it often comes in the form of one week and two week breaks. So our plan would be to spend most of those breaks at the home. Also, if it's only 2 hours away, it would be easy to spend the weekend there.
    Lilypie Pregnancy tickers
  • hoffsehoffse member
    Sixth Anniversary 2500 Comments 500 Love Its Name Dropper
    edited March 2016
    We don't own a vacation property yet, but we run around with a lot of people who do.  I agree with the other posters that distance and guilt about going other places needs to be a consideration for you. 

    From what I have seen with other people, the "vacation" properties that really work the best for people in our area are the lake houses within a 90 minute drive of that person's full-time residence.  That's close enough that driving in on a Friday and even waking up early on Monday to drive back to work is NBD.  If/when H and I buy a second home, this is probably the model we will follow.  The people who own these kind of houses do vacation to other place, but their second home still sees plenty of use, and it doesn't usually sit around vacant.  The downside here is there is less rental potential because you're talking about a lake that's within a day's driving distance (round trip) for families who want to day trip in.  Also, while lakes are great, they aren't super unique... most people don't travel a great distance to get to a lake like they might for a ski resort or beach.

    We are a 4-5 hour drive to various parts of the Gulf, so I know a number of people with beach houses also.  These people rarely go anywhere else because it's far enough away that getting to the beach requires at least a long weekend to make the trip feel worthwhile.  Also, those properties are stupid expensive because of location, hurricane insurance, and maintenance with salt water and sand issues, so spending several thousand more per year to vacation elsewhere seems like a waste.  As much as H and I enjoy visiting the Gulf, we could rent houses 3-4 times per year and never come close to spending the money it takes to actually own something down there.  We both enjoy the beach, but 4 times per year is plenty for us.  That factor alone has convinced us that we will probably never buy down there.  The upside: massive rental potential.

    It sounds like your plans would mostly fall in the first category, so it could make sense for you guys. I would still do some number crunching to try to figure out what the rent v. own analysis looks like for that area.  I wouldn't saddle yourself with an extra house to maintain unless owning plays in your favor mathematically.
    Wedding Countdown Ticker
  • Since it sounds like you all want to own this long term, I'd definitely check out how well this area appreciates over time.

    Analyze how much you will use the house (vacation savings) vs. the monthly cost to maintain it (ie insurance, property taxes, mortgage).  You'll also want to take a hard look at how much you will use it, since you plan to use it as a rental the rest of the time.  Obviously, rental income will defray some of your costs but then, the more you use it for your family (the primary purpose) the less rental  income you will have.

    Rental income:  really analyze how much rental income you can expect and be conservative in your analysis.  For example, since it is near a ski resort, there might be great rental income in the winter, but minimal to no rental income during warmer parts of the year.  Check sites like AirBnB and VRBO for other vacation rental homes in the area.  It should give you a good look at both pricing and vacancy rates for the area.

    You're far enough away you'll need a good relationship with a property manager and a house cleaner and/or house cleaning service.  You might also look at hiring an independent contractor via Craigs List (or something like that) who would both manage the property and/or clean it.  Obviously vet them and meet them in person.  I saw a part-time ad on CL about a year ago where someone was looking for a person who would just meet guests coming in to rent the owner's French Quarter vacation rental condo, give them the lay down of the place, and give them the keys.  I still kick myself I didn't apply!

    But, keep these kind of costs in mind also.  For permanent renters, the place only needs to be cleaned between tenants.  For vacation rentals, the place needs to be cleaned between each stay.  Though, often, you can charge a cleaning fee.  Something else to check out when you are reviewing what other vacation rentals, rent out for.

    For a loan on a non-owner occupied property, you will need at least a 20-30% down payment.  You can save a substantial amount on insurance if you opt to not have the contents insured...or minimal contents insurance.  Because, think about it, your whole life (contents wise) will not be in this vacation home.  It will be furniture, appliances, and that's about it.

    For insurance, and I live in an area that has insanely high rates, I've found my insurance rate is lower for my non-owner occupied house than for my personal home, because there is no contents insurance needed.  However, since it is not continually occupied by somebody (yourself or a tenant), that could raise the rate.  For example, while I've been doing the rehab work on my rental duplex, my insurance is about $156/month because it isn't occupied.  However, once I have permanent tenants living there, it will drop down to $134/month.  So it's still not a huge difference, relatively speaking. 

    Contrary to popular belief, vacation renters tend to be much easier on homes than permanent renters.  At least that is the gist I get from my real estate investing forum and from my own (albeit very limited) experience.  Which is not to say there aren't bad apples out there, but your average vacation renter is going to be more affluent and with a more responsible personality, as compared to the general population.

  • Just a quick note on insurance.... that's definitely something to keep in mind in the area  you're looking in.  Insurance can sometimes be difficult to get in those areas because of the fires that have been there in the past 5ish years or so.  Some parts are probably fine, but others might be iffy... just something to keep in mind when adding up your expenses.

    My BFF lives just outside of Evergreen, and they haven't really had any fire really close to them, but their insurance is still pricey.  Also both the county and their insurance company come out every year to tell them what they have to do that year for fire prevention.  Last year they had to have 3 large evergreen trees removed, and this year they have to do more clearing of smaller and medium sized trees.  So, that's also an extra expense, especially if it's a wooded area.  
Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards