Money Matters
Dear Community,

Our tech team has launched updates to The Nest today. As a result of these updates, members of the Nest Community will need to change their password in order to continue participating in the community. In addition, The Nest community member's avatars will be replaced with generic default avatars. If you wish to revert to your original avatar, you will need to re-upload it via The Nest.

If you have questions about this, please email help@theknot.com.

Thank you.

Note: This only affects The Nest's community members and will not affect members on The Bump or The Knot.

MM: Artificial turf...do you have it? Does it actually save money?


We are in a bit of a predicament. We have a landscaped back yard that includes a 380ft section of grass (the majority is rock, mulch, trees and shrubs). We want a grassy area for when we do have kids one day. 

However, our problem is: our female dog!

We love her, we really do. But she is just slaughtering our grass. We have lived here for two years, and about 2/3 of the grass area is now yellow and dead. We have tried all the tricks (watering after she pees, re-seeding, grass supplements), and they do not work. The only advice I really get from landscapers is to get rid of the dog. Not going to happen. 

So, we are now considering getting artificial turf for the area. Even though it is small, it is somewhat pricey. To remove the grass, flaten the area and install turf, the best quote we got was $2,400 from a reputable local company. 

We can afford it, but geesh that's a lot of money for such a small area. But there are definitely perks. No watering, no dead looking grass, potential play area in the future.

So, questions for you MM'ers:

Do any of you have artificial turf or considered it? Was it worth the investment? Do you actually save money (i.e., water bill)?
Lilypie Pregnancy tickers

Re: MM: Artificial turf...do you have it? Does it actually save money?

  • Our neighbors have it for their dog area.  It looks nice enough.  I can't imagine the water savings for such a small area to be a big impact on your water bills though.  The $2,400 is more of an investment in aesthetics, vs cost savings/adding to house value.  
  • labrolabro member
    Fifth Anniversary 500 Comments 250 Love Its Name Dropper
    edited June 2016
    So will the dog still pee on the artificial turf? Do you think it could create some sort of smell/waste hazard issue if you have a very long, hot, dry spell?

    Something you could do, which admittedly takes time and effort, is start to physically walk the dog back to the mulched area of your yard and train her to do her business there. Once she becomes accustomed to using the back area of your yard for her eliminations, she'll just go out there automatically. Plus taking her out back there constantly to go will create a scent area for her and she'll start to recognize it as "her" place.

    Bonus, no cost to do this and you get to keep your grass. :)

    ETA: I'll admit I'm biased. We spend a lot of time on our lawn and I work hard to keep it looking nice and there's just nothing like lush grass under your bare feet. We have a dog too (a female) but luckily her urine doesn't seem to bother our bermuda grass much unless she goes regularly in one spot. But luckily the bermuda creeps back over those areas pretty quick. If you're in the southeast at all, that could be a secondary (but not cost-savings) resolution for you. Personally, I'd try to train the dog first before I spent money on fake turf.
  • bmo88bmo88 member
    500 Comments Fourth Anniversary 250 Love Its Name Dropper
    labro said:
    So will the dog still pee on the artificial turf? Do you think it could create some sort of smell/waste hazard issue if you have a very long, hot, dry spell?

    Something you could do, which admittedly takes time and effort, is start to physically walk the dog back to the mulched area of your yard and train her to do her business there. Once she becomes accustomed to using the back area of your yard for her eliminations, she'll just go out there automatically. Plus taking her out back there constantly to go will create a scent area for her and she'll start to recognize it as "her" place.

    Bonus, no cost to do this and you get to keep your grass. :)

    ETA: I'll admit I'm biased. We spend a lot of time on our lawn and I work hard to keep it looking nice and there's just nothing like lush grass under your bare feet. We have a dog too (a female) but luckily her urine doesn't seem to bother our bermuda grass much unless she goes regularly in one spot. But luckily the bermuda creeps back over those areas pretty quick. If you're in the southeast at all, that could be a secondary (but not cost-savings) resolution for you. Personally, I'd try to train the dog first before I spent money on fake turf.

    The turf we are considering is pet friendly and is set up to drain properly/not smell. We have tried the "training to pee in one area" technique, and she did not take to it well. She is an 9 year 90lb lab that is stubborn and set in her ways. Our dog trainer even said she was one of the most stubborn dogs she has encountered. 

    We live in Colorado and I have no idea what kind of grass we have to be honest. The cause of it dying is definitely her though because it is only where she pees. Our other dog is male and doesn't seem to affect the grass. 
    Lilypie Pregnancy tickers
  • bmo88bmo88 member
    500 Comments Fourth Anniversary 250 Love Its Name Dropper
    Our neighbors have it for their dog area.  It looks nice enough.  I can't imagine the water savings for such a small area to be a big impact on your water bills though.  The $2,400 is more of an investment in aesthetics, vs cost savings/adding to house value.  
    Yeah, I figured we wouldn't save much on water. At this point, we are getting really tired of how bad it looks....and it turns to mud during the rainy season. Ugh.
    Lilypie Pregnancy tickers
  • I've been considering turf too because our yard is currently a dirt pile (oops). It's tiny and shaded so I don't think grass has much of a shot even before our dog pees on it. We had taught him to pee on one bush and then we ripped it out (which is why he was allowed to pee on it anyways!) 
  • I've thought about doing this once we are all done with our backyard plans.  Now you are scaring me!  Prices I've seen...though more from websites/reviews, not from an actual landscaper...are that it is about $2/square foot, including materials and installation.  And DIY is not recommended.  But perhaps it is substantially more expensive than I am thinking.  I also will end up having a lot to cover.  Probably at least 1,000 sf.

    If you haven't already, I'd get a second quote.  Just to make sure the first one is in line.

    I love the way it looks and feels!  My backyard natural grass is hopeless.  It gets full sun all day and so the grass just totally dies in the summer.  Plus I have a dog and I often have tenants with dogs (next door, shared backyard)

  • bmo88bmo88 member
    500 Comments Fourth Anniversary 250 Love Its Name Dropper

    I've thought about doing this once we are all done with our backyard plans.  Now you are scaring me!  Prices I've seen...though more from websites/reviews, not from an actual landscaper...are that it is about $2/square foot, including materials and installation.  And DIY is not recommended.  But perhaps it is substantially more expensive than I am thinking.  I also will end up having a lot to cover.  Probably at least 1,000 sf.

    If you haven't already, I'd get a second quote.  Just to make sure the first one is in line.

    I love the way it looks and feels!  My backyard natural grass is hopeless.  It gets full sun all day and so the grass just totally dies in the summer.  Plus I have a dog and I often have tenants with dogs (next door, shared backyard)


    We have got 3 more quotes and the others were more expensive! They were: $3.800, $3,600 and $2,700. Most price around $3-$4 sq ft before installation.
    Lilypie Pregnancy tickers
  • bmo88 said:

    I've thought about doing this once we are all done with our backyard plans.  Now you are scaring me!  Prices I've seen...though more from websites/reviews, not from an actual landscaper...are that it is about $2/square foot, including materials and installation.  And DIY is not recommended.  But perhaps it is substantially more expensive than I am thinking.  I also will end up having a lot to cover.  Probably at least 1,000 sf.

    If you haven't already, I'd get a second quote.  Just to make sure the first one is in line.

    I love the way it looks and feels!  My backyard natural grass is hopeless.  It gets full sun all day and so the grass just totally dies in the summer.  Plus I have a dog and I often have tenants with dogs (next door, shared backyard)


    We have got 3 more quotes and the others were more expensive! They were: $3.800, $3,600 and $2,700. Most price around $3-$4 sq ft before installation.
    Thanks for the update.  I know prices can be different in different areas, but I obviously need to readjust my thinking!
  • I don't know if financially you'll ever "break even" but if it allows you to be happier with the appearance of your lawn, then it's worth it. Also not having to deal with the dead grass, reseeding & watering it daily until it takes has to be worth something, especially if you include how much time you invest to fix the patches every year. Then also think of the time you'll save not having to mow, fertilize or water that area. Time you can spend doing other, more fun things.  
  • Let me know if you do it.  I doubt we will do it now, but wow it seems so tempting.  No lawn work every year.  
    Priceless
Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards