Minneapolis/St. Paul Nesties
Dear Community,

Our tech team has launched updates to The Nest today. As a result of these updates, members of the Nest Community will need to change their password in order to continue participating in the community. In addition, The Nest community member's avatars will be replaced with generic default avatars. If you wish to revert to your original avatar, you will need to re-upload it via The Nest.

If you have questions about this, please email help@theknot.com.

Thank you.

Note: This only affects The Nest's community members and will not affect members on The Bump or The Knot.

I don't get the Gaga love

2

Re: I don't get the Gaga love

  • imageMrsKizdoodle:

    Holy Pete, AGREED on that last part.  I also agree about Beiber.  There are tons of kids that can sing, he just got lucky and found the right handlers and managers.  And hairstylists, natch.  Stick out tongue  Sure, he's charming and cute, but he's not he only person on this planet that is charming and cute.  It worries me how bonkers young girls go over him.  I think some take it to an unhealthy level.

    Yeah but people said that about Beatles, NKOTB, BSB, and NSYNC fans. There's been a nut or two (or 200) for all of them. Today's it's Bieber, tomorrow they'll go OCD on someone else.

    image
    Lilypie Premature Baby tickers

    AlternaTickers - Cool, free Web tickers
  • imageMinnaB:

    I think music is one of those "to each her own" things for me.  I love Gaga but I've only heard one Jason Mraz song, and I thought it was annoying.

    Blasphemy!?!?  Haha.  Stick out tongue  You keep Gaga, I'll keep Jason.  Everyone wins!  Big Smile

    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • imageJosiePosy:

    Yeah but people said that about Beatles, NKOTB, BSB, and NSYNC fans. There's been a nut or two (or 200) for all of them. Today's it's Bieber, tomorrow they'll go OCD on someone else.

    Very true.  Maybe it's because I'm getting older but it seems like they "go OCD" younger and younger!  Man...am I already a crotchity old woman??  Surprise

    :-)

     

    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • imageMrsKizdoodle:
    I think my main question that I'm still unclear on is if Lady Gaga has said, "Yes, my song sounds just like hers" or if she is saying, "That is nonsense, this is completely original."  If she admits to it, then cool.  I guess I find issue with people trying to pass off something as their own that clearly isn't.

    I am not sure I understand why you think that she needs to admit to anything. Does that make her better in your eyes if she admits something that people are assuming?
    Just because the songs are somewhat similar doesn't make it a copy. There are millions of songs out there that sound somewhat similar to each other.

    I don't think that it is fair to be judgemental and accusing of someone of something unless you have 100% the facts.

  • imageMrsKizdoodle:
    imageJosiePosy:

    Yeah but people said that about Beatles, NKOTB, BSB, and NSYNC fans. There's been a nut or two (or 200) for all of them. Today's it's Bieber, tomorrow they'll go OCD on someone else.

    Very true.  Maybe it's because I'm getting older but it seems like they "go OCD" younger and younger!  Man...am I already a crotchity old woman??  Surprise

    :-)

     

    I was crazy about NKOTB when I was 10.  I'm sure if I was 10 today I would love Justin Bieber, but since I'm old I'm okay with not being a fan of his.  Little girls are weird, but a Bieber obsession seems pretty harmless.

  • imageMrsKizdoodle:
    imageJosiePosy:

    Yeah but people said that about Beatles, NKOTB, BSB, and NSYNC fans. There's been a nut or two (or 200) for all of them. Today's it's Bieber, tomorrow they'll go OCD on someone else.

    Very true.  Maybe it's because I'm getting older but it seems like they "go OCD" younger and younger!  Man...am I already a crotchity old woman??  Surprise

    :-)

     

    Kiz, you are TOTALLY a bitter old hag of a woman. Let me fetch your cane and "KEEP OFF MY LAWN!" sign. Wink

    You know this whole Gaga/Madonna thing reminds me of Vanilla Ice and the little "tings" in his Ice Ice Baby song. LOL! But I do wonder if the similarities were intentional as well.

    I always get into these originality discussions with DH about rappers. A long time ago we got into it big time over some song (I really don't remember what it was) where a rapper had sampled something and I said something about the lack of originality in the music. DH held to his opinion that rappers are original, and I said they'd be more original if they didn't sample so much work from other people.  But even Kanye included in his songs something about "don't give me nothing I can't sample," so at least he owns up to it.

    image
    Lilypie Premature Baby tickers

    AlternaTickers - Cool, free Web tickers
  • imageMorningMania:

    imageMrsKizdoodle:
    I think my main question that I'm still unclear on is if Lady Gaga has said, "Yes, my song sounds just like hers" or if she is saying, "That is nonsense, this is completely original."  If she admits to it, then cool.  I guess I find issue with people trying to pass off something as their own that clearly isn't.

    I am not sure I understand why you think that she needs to admit to anything. Does that make her better in your eyes if she admits something that people are assuming?
    Just because the songs are somewhat similar doesn't make it a copy. There are millions of songs out there that sound somewhat similar to each other.

    I don't think that it is fair to be judgemental and accusing of someone of something unless you have 100% the facts.

    And you're judging my judging.  We all judge.  Stick out tongue 

    See the bolded part above.

    And does anyone ever have the facts 100%?  Rarely.  Yet people judge on much less, such is life.  

    Darn it...now I have Madonna in my head.  :-) 

    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • imageMinnaB:
    imageMrsKizdoodle:
    imageJosiePosy:

    Yeah but people said that about Beatles, NKOTB, BSB, and NSYNC fans. There's been a nut or two (or 200) for all of them. Today's it's Bieber, tomorrow they'll go OCD on someone else.

    Very true.  Maybe it's because I'm getting older but it seems like they "go OCD" younger and younger!  Man...am I already a crotchity old woman??  Surprise

    :-)

     

    I was crazy about NKOTB when I was 10.  I'm sure if I was 10 today I would love Justin Bieber, but since I'm old I'm okay with not being a fan of his.  Little girls are weird, but a Bieber obsession seems pretty harmless.

    I was crazy about NKOTB too but not crazy enough to send death threats and hate mail to my favorite members flavor of the week...like those Bieber fanatics do to who ever he's seen kissing or hugging, or canoodling with this week.

  • Young girls will obsess about someone no matter what.  Who do you think would be a better target of their obsession?  The kid is a good singer, that's a fact.  The teeny bopper songs they have him singing aren't great, but that's not up to him.  I think he is a much better target than someone older or completely without merit.

    I don't foresee a future where a bunch of young girls will have posters of nobel prize winners tacked to their walls.

    I can't believe anyone cares about any of this.  Stop reading Perez if you don't want to hear about these people.  

    image
    Judging
  • imageMinnaB:
    Little girls are weird, but a Bieber obsession seems pretty harmless.

    And then there is THIS girl.  :-) Poor thing and her heartache...

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dTCm8tdHkfI

    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • imageMelindaMG:

    Young girls will obsess about someone no matter what.  Who do you think would be a better target of their obsession?  The kid is a good singer, that's a fact.  The teeny bopper songs they have him singing aren't great, but that's not up to him.  I think he is a much better target than someone older or completely without merit.

    I don't foresee a future where a bunch of young girls will have posters of nobel prize winners tacked to their walls.

    I can't believe anyone cares about any of this.  Stop reading Perez if you don't want to hear about these people.  

    I couldn't agree more!

    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
  • imagehuwehotaling:

    imageMelindaMG:
      I can't believe anyone cares about any of this.  Stop reading Perez if you don't want to hear about these people.  

    I couldn't agree more!

    Confused   The chick is everywhere, it's annoying.  Everyone seems to be talking about her, including me - yes, so it's clearly not as simple as ignoring Perez. 

    It's obvious she is successful in getting conversations going regardless of the opinions about her.

    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • imageMrsKizdoodle:
    imagehuwehotaling:

    imageMelindaMG:
      I can't believe anyone cares about any of this.  Stop reading Perez if you don't want to hear about these people.  

    I couldn't agree more!

    Confused   The chick is everywhere, it's annoying.  Everyone seems to be talking about her, including me - yes, so it's clearly not as simple as ignoring Perez. 

    It's obvious she is successful in getting conversations going regardless of the opinions about her.

    I must be out of touch.  I don't think I would ever hear about her unless I read about Grammy gossip or something.  

    image
    Judging
  • imagemrsdawnmarie:
    What's Perez?

    Coll.  At least Dawn is more out of touch than me.  I win.

    image
    Judging
  • I don't mind Lady Gaga, I've never heard Justin Bieber sing and I can't stand Taylor Swift.  She seems like a sweet person and for that, I will give her props.  However, I think that much like Justin Bieber, her music is not targeted at me.  Teenage angst is so not for me.  Smile  Its all about the audience in a lot of cases. I'm not going to begrudge anyone who likes her or call them silly.  Just different strokes for different folks is all!
  • imageMelindaMG:

    I must be out of touch.  I don't think I would ever hear about her unless I read about Grammy gossip or something.  

    I can't seem to avoid her!  Is she stalking me?? 

    FWIW, I stopped reading Perez after it's clear they hired someone who didn't pass 3rd grade grammar and spelling to write the posts.  Eep!

    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • imageMrsKizdoodle:
    imageMelindaMG:

    I must be out of touch.  I don't think I would ever hear about her unless I read about Grammy gossip or something.  

    I can't seem to avoid her!  Is she stalking me?? 

    FWIW, I stopped reading Perez after it's clear they hired someone who didn't pass 3rd grade grammar and spelling to write the posts.  Eep!

    She is always watching.

     image

    I still have Perez in my Google Reader but it takes an act of desperation, on a very slow work day to get me to open that thread.

    image
    Judging
  • imageMelindaMG:

    imagemrsdawnmarie:
    What's Perez?

    Coll.  At least Dawn is more out of touch than me.  I win.

    i thought perez was a dude. see how much i know?

  • imagestrength:
    imageMelindaMG:

    imagemrsdawnmarie:
    What's Perez?

    Coll.  At least Dawn is more out of touch than me.  I win.

    i thought perez was a dude. see how much i know?

    Perez is a dude!
  • Actually, I saw all these previews for the Bieber movie, and I thought "What?  He died?"  I mean, why else would there be a movie about him?  Shows how out of touch I am.

    A lot of my students LOVE Bieber.  And Twilight.  I'm always pushing Judy Blume on them. 

  • Oh dear.  I wonder how much she'll regret this later in life?

    image

    Don't get me started on Twilight tattoos....

    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • This is exactly why I steer clear of top 40 radio. Some of my friends like to put on KDWB and such and play make Jenny guess the song. I usually have no idea these days. I've seen some of Justin Bieber's YouTube videos, I agree that he's somewhat talented, but he certainly doesn't seem to pick songs that showcase that talent. 

    I guess I'm old and crotchety, but I'll stick to The Current and MPR Classical thanks. 

  • imageMrs.Izzy:

    I guess I'm old and crotchety, but I'll stick to The Current and MPR Classical thanks. 

    Me too!  Except I DO like Jason Matheson on MyTalk107.1  and once in awhile Lori & Julia but Julia's voice and mispronunciations drive me batty.

    OMG Jason's totally a geek.  Hah.  Love it.

    image 

    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • Kiz...I'm convinced that we are twins or something...I love Jason on the news, but I've never heard his show...gonna have to check that out. 
  • imageMinnaB:

    imageMrsKizdoodle:
    I love Jason Mraz because he is a huge advocate for a ton of causes.  I'd sign his petition ANY day.Wink

    I think music is one of those "to each her own" things for me.  I love Gaga but I've only heard one Jason Mraz song, and I thought it was annoying.

    YES. I don't know what it is.. but Jason Mraz makes me feel slimey. Like he's schmoozing me but he's just doing it for show. Blech. I loved the time that SNL parodied him, Jack Johnson, Dave Matthews and oddly enough, Ozzy Osbourne. SNL's parody hit it right on the head - even though I do like Jack Johnson and Dave Matthews (well, and obviously Ozzy too, but you can't compare them!) I understand what the appeal should be about Mraz, but I just can't get on board.

    To whomever wrote about listening to The Current - YES. It's what is on my radio 99% of the time - Joe and I usually do a pop/top 40 station for about an hour on the weekend to stay in the know with what's mainstream popular, but once we start hearing songs played more than once, it's back to MPR.. 

    image
    jack | born 9.13.12 at 40w4d | 9 lbs 12 oz | 23 in
    Lilypie First Birthday tickers
    imageimage
    my puppy loves - chloe & jenson
    pregnancy blog | chart
  • I love Gaga and Twilight.  I think Gaga is incredibly talented.  But I also get that she's not for everyone.  I just hate the notion (not necessarily here, but in general) that liking pop music means you aren't "cool" or whatever.  I like Gaga.  I listen to the Current.  I love Twilight.  My favorite book is Joseph Conrad's Heart of Darkness.  It is like people (I know a couple people like this) who are all "Oh, I don't watch television."  Great, you want a cookie?  I do watch tv.  And it doesn't make me dumb.  Just like reading Twilight or liking Katy Perry doesn't.  Variety is the spice of life and all that.
  • imagethedutchgirl:
    I love Gaga and Twilight.  I think Gaga is incredibly talented.  But I also get that she's not for everyone.  I just hate the notion (not necessarily here, but in general) that liking pop music means you aren't "cool" or whatever.  I like Gaga.  I listen to the Current.  I love Twilight.  My favorite book is Joseph Conrad's Heart of Darkness.  It is like people (I know a couple people like this) who are all "Oh, I don't watch television."  Great, you want a cookie?  I do watch tv.  And it doesn't make me dumb.  Just like reading Twilight or liking Katy Perry doesn't.  Variety is the spice of life and all that.
    FWIW, I read all four Twilight books, I still think they're terrible, terrible things to allow a young girl to read. I heart Katy Perry. I watch oodles of television, I can't stand the Current or N/MPR. I find them both horribly boring, and with bad music.

    Missy, Judy Blume is great, but there is a lot more fantastic literature out there, I'd be happy to hook you up with some awesome author names!

    ETA: and I still don't know what a perez is.

  • imagemrsdawnmarie:

    ETA: and I still don't know what a perez is.

    Behold...Perez Hilton, gossip blogger extraordinaire.

    image 

    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards