North Florida Nesties
Dear Community,

Our tech team has launched updates to The Nest today. As a result of these updates, members of the Nest Community will need to change their password in order to continue participating in the community. In addition, The Nest community member's avatars will be replaced with generic default avatars. If you wish to revert to your original avatar, you will need to re-upload it via The Nest.

If you have questions about this, please email help@theknot.com.

Thank you.

Note: This only affects The Nest's community members and will not affect members on The Bump or The Knot.

What if your dog mauled your child?

There's a reg on Pets who has two champion vizilas (sp?). They compete in agility and rallyO. They've had these dog for years. Her DD pushed the male while he was sleeping on the couch and yelled at him to move and the dog attacked. 50 stitches on her face. Usually they're diligent about supervision, but this time that was lacking. AC is not going to take the dog. He has to be on quarantine for 10 days and the rest is up to them. I dont think they've decided what to do yet. WWYD?
Photobucket Pictures, Images and Photos
«1

Re: What if your dog mauled your child?

  • There are too many variables left out of this story to say what I would do.
  • It's hard to say what I would do. I feel terrible for the person who has to make that decision.

    ETA: hard to say as in I'm not sure what I would do. Amsterdam is tiny and loves everyone so I can't imagine being in that situation. Then again my dad has a really mean little dog that always bites me so I know tiny doesn't mean nice.
    *Old Nestie, New Name*

  • I forgot to add that the DD is not afraid of the dogs and doesn't understand why he's being kept away from her. Sad I have no idea what I would do either. What a terrible spot to be in. I can imagine you would be judged no matter what you do.
    Photobucket Pictures, Images and Photos
  • I would also like to add that if this dog was a pit bull I'm sure there would be all kinds of different reactions. It's very upsetting to me that dog bites of any other breed besides pit get absolutely no media attention, just like the lab who killed an infant last week. Nobody heard about it.

    Also, I'm sorry for any family that has this happen to them.

    end rant/

  • I realize I will probably get flamed for this, but I'm okay with that. If one of our dogs hurt one of our kids like that, the dog would have to go. I love our dogs, but that does not compare to out kids.
    imageimage
    imageimage
  • imageKristin&Adam:
    I realize I will probably get flamed for this, but I'm okay with that. If one of our dogs hurt one of our kids like that, the dog would have to go. I love our dogs, but that does not compare to out kids.
    You're ok with what? It stated they didn't know what they were going to do.
  • I don't know.  Crying

    Thank you for the reminder to never leave kids unsupervised with dogs regardless.

  • I am with Kristen on this topic. While Toby is half of my heart...BUT if DS needed 50+ stitches then Toby would have to go. It would suck, but I wouldn't be willing to risk it happening again. No matter which decision those owners make, it won't be the correct decision in many peoples eyes.
    Another old nestie with a new name.
  • This situation is hard, and not enough details to really say for sure what I would do. Heartbreaking. 

    It almost sounds like the dog reacted out of fear, and I think my decision would depend a lot on what exactly its reaction was. 50 stitches is pretty serious business, but then again -- I sliced my finger and had 11, so it's easy to see that one quick bite from a large dog could have the same result.  I think if the dog repeatedly attacked even after the threat was removed, I would probably lean more toward finding a new/child-free home for it. Ugh, just typing that -- even having a small dog and no children -- makes me sick to my stomach.

    "You can make more friends in two months by becoming interested in other people than you can in two years by trying to get other people interested in you." - Dale Carnegie
  • imagePantsOffDanceOff:
    imageKristin&Adam:
    I realize I will probably get flamed for this, but I'm okay with that. If one of our dogs hurt one of our kids like that, the dog would have to go. I love our dogs, but that does not compare to out kids.
    You're ok with what? It stated they didn't know what they were going to do.
    I'm okay with getting flamed for my opinion on this one.
    imageimage
    imageimage
  • I think it's so hard to say what you'd do unless you were put in the position.

    I personally judge the crap out of people who get rid of their pets when the kids come along. If it's because pets have anger/jealousy issues, that's fine to find them a new home, but because it's too overwhelming or you just don't have time for the pets, I judge. 

    Now that I have a child along with my 3 dogs, I can say that I still love my dogs just as much as I did before. My baby doesn't even compare to my dogs, it's a completely different love. While my dogs love me, they don't need me the way the baby does (thank goodness, because this baby is demanding!) I'd like to think that under no circumstances would I ever give away any of my dogs if an accident like that happened though. I think I'm on the far end of the dog-loving spectrum, so I might be in the minority.

    Also, it would depend on exactly what happened and how it happened, in OP's case with the dog sleeping, DD approaching it and startling it and getting bit, I think I'd still keep my dog if the child wasn't afraid and I felt like it was a totally isolated case. However, I'd be much more careful with the dog and child interacting. 

    Love 9.3.03 Marriage 12.1.07 Baby Carriage 8.3.11
  • imageKristin&Adam:
    imagePantsOffDanceOff:
    imageKristin&Adam:
    I realize I will probably get flamed for this, but I'm okay with that. If one of our dogs hurt one of our kids like that, the dog would have to go. I love our dogs, but that does not compare to out kids.
    You're ok with what? It stated they didn't know what they were going to do.
    I'm okay with getting flamed for my opinion on this one.
    I'm not flaming you, I'm asking you what you are okay with. Getting rid of the dog, putting it down... it was never specified.
  • I'm agreeing with everything Ashlee said here. If the dog has never had any aggressive tendencies, I would carefully monitor the situation, consult a behavioral professional & a vet for peace of mind AND I would absolutely talk to DD about the fact that under no circumstances is that appropriate behavior around animals. In no way was it her fault, but what happened needs to be addressed. Stitches add up quickly, so I'm thinking she scared him shitless, he reacted with a bite (not a complete mauling smackdown) & now, here they are. If that's the case, I would keep the dog. No safety is ever 100% when animals are around no matter how well you know the animal. All you can do is supervise & educate.

    ETA: I'm with you on the rant, Pants!
    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • imagePantsOffDanceOff:
    imageKristin&Adam:
    imagePantsOffDanceOff:
    imageKristin&Adam:
    I realize I will probably get flamed for this, but I'm okay with that. If one of our dogs hurt one of our kids like that, the dog would have to go. I love our dogs, but that does not compare to out kids.
    You're ok with what? It stated they didn't know what they were going to do.
    I'm okay with getting flamed for my opinion on this one.
    I'm not flaming you, I'm asking you what you are okay with. Getting rid of the dog, putting it down... it was never specified.
    I realize that, I was answering your question in my reply - the thing I am okay with is being flamed for my opinion on this one. I never indicated that the person it happened to decided what to do.
    imageimage
    imageimage
  • Ok so we've been talking in circles because I still don't know what your flameful opinion actually is. I
  • Maybe since I don't currently have any pets, I don't find this decision to be tough. If I had a dog that hurt my baby, the dog is gone. The life of my child is way more important.
    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • Being that I have a child and don't have any dogs, my opinion of what I think I would do is most likely going to be different from what someone with dog(s) and no kids thinks they would do and what someone with dog(s) and kids thinks they would do.

    If we were in this situation, I think that I would try to find a new home for the dog, one where there are no children present.  It really is hard to say for sure, because I don't have the love in my heart for dogs like I know a lot of people do.

    Mungee and Me
    image
    How is it that my BABY is going to be 3?
    image

    BFP-2/25/11; 8 Wk U/S-3/25/11-No HB, measured 6.5 wks; D&C
  • imageJ-Pancakes:
    Maybe since I don't currently have any pets, I don't find this decision to be tough. If I had a dog that hurt my baby, the dog is gone. The life of my child is way more important.

    Yes, I can see where this decision would not be as difficult as I imagine it would be if I were thinking of a hypothetical dog and we didn't already have our dogs who are such a huge part of our lives and have personalities of their own and their own likes and dislikes with which we're intimately familiar.

    My heart breaks for any dog owner in this situation.

  • imagePantsOffDanceOff:
    Ok so we've been talking in circles because I still don't know what your flameful opinion actually is. I

    In her OP she's saying she's okay with getting flamed for her opinion that the dog would have to go. She did not address the poster Laner was talking about.

    imageKristin&Adam:
    I realize I will probably get flamed for this, but I'm okay with that. If one of our dogs hurt one of our kids like that, the dog would have to go. I love our dogs, but that does not compare to out kids.

    Please correct me if I'm misunderstanding as well, K&A.

  • Easy. Put the kid up for adoption.
    Image and video hosting by TinyPic
  • imageLucille Bluth:

    imagePantsOffDanceOff:
    Ok so we've been talking in circles because I still don't know what your flameful opinion actually is. I

    In her OP she's saying she's okay with getting flamed for her opinion that the dog would have to go. She did not address the poster Laner was talking about.

    imageKristin&Adam:
    I realize I will probably get flamed for this, but I'm okay with that. If one of our dogs hurt one of our kids like that, the dog would have to go. I love our dogs, but that does not compare to out kids.

    Please correct me if I'm misunderstanding as well, K&A.

    No I get that. I guess I'm trying to specify what "get rid of the dog" means...it's not so flameful to me for one to say we would have to rehome the dog. But if she means, take it out back and get rid of it, that's an entirely different story.
  • This has been a very confusing thread. lol

    Although I think it's kind of offensive to even think any of the dog owners here would do anything (dump at a shelter, "take it out back" - WTF?) other than rehome a dog in a worst case scenario. But again, maybe I'm wrong.

  • imageClaireDunphy:
    Easy. Put the kid up for adoption.

    Come on, CD. You can't go with the easy way out...  

    Love 9.3.03 Marriage 12.1.07 Baby Carriage 8.3.11
  • imageLucille Bluth:

    This has been a very confusing thread. lol

    Although I think it's kind of offensive to even think any of the dog owners here would do anything (dump at a shelter, "take it out back" - WTF?) other than rehome a dog in a worst case scenario. But again, maybe I'm wrong.

    Yeah, I completely misunderstood her at first. Sorry for the confusion. And I'm not trying to be offensive, that was an extreme example (and one I have seen during my rescue days believe me). However, there are plenty of people who would put the dog down.
  • imageClaireDunphy:
    Easy. Put the kid up for adoption.

    Yes  I know this is a sensitive subject, but this made me laugh.

    Another old nestie with a new name.
  • imagePantsOffDanceOff:
    imageLucille Bluth:

    This has been a very confusing thread. lol

    Although I think it's kind of offensive to even think any of the dog owners here would do anything (dump at a shelter, "take it out back" - WTF?) other than rehome a dog in a worst case scenario. But again, maybe I'm wrong.

    Yeah, I completely misunderstood her at first. Sorry for the confusion. And I'm not trying to be offensive, that was an extreme example (and one I have seen during my rescue days believe me). However, there are plenty of people who would put the dog down.

    My sisters best friends parents had their 9/10 yr. old cat and dog put down because they sold their house and moved to a pet-free condo. It seriously made me sick... they refused to try to re-home them. Nothing surprises me anymore, sad as it is.  

    Love 9.3.03 Marriage 12.1.07 Baby Carriage 8.3.11
  • imageMartiza:

    imageClaireDunphy:
    Easy. Put the kid up for adoption.

    Yes  I know this is a sensitive subject, but this made me laugh.

    It made me laugh too.
    *Old Nestie, New Name*

  • You had it right, LB. When I say the dog would have to go, it depends on a lot of things what "go" means and based on the details above, I can't say what I would do. It would either be put down or rehomed to a place without kids. I wouldn't take it out back an shoot it. I was curious though, so I posted this on my moms message board and every single one of the replies said that the dog would be removed from the home and probably 80% said they would put the dog down. A handful said the dog would be lucky if they or their husbands didn't kill it themselves. I don't envy the OP, it's a tough decision, but I really cannot understand keeping the dog there where it can potentially harm her child, especially considering she is pregnant (I went and found the post) and will soon have a newborn in her home. That's just me though. Before I had kids, my dogs were my babies and I swore they always would be. I don't love them any less now, but they are our pets and my kids safety comes first.
    imageimage
    imageimage
  • I can certainly understand why people would lean towards re homing. I really can't say with certainty what I would do. I would imagine that it would be pretty close to impossible to not freak eevry time DD goes near the dog...at least for awhile. However, if they decide to do this I don't think they should ever have another dog as long as they have children in their home. ANY dog can do this. Any. If they re home the male Vizsla, why keep the female?

    According to the mom, it was a single bite, not an attack. The people that are (not on this board) comparing the dog to a human, like, "what would you do if a person hurt your child like this?" are morons. Dogs just don't think the same way. Ya know, cause they're animals. Not people. I just feel so badly for everyone involved, including the pup.

    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • Yikes, sorry for the lack of formatting, I'm on my phone.
    imageimage
    imageimage
Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards