Family Matters
Dear Community,

Our tech team has launched updates to The Nest today. As a result of these updates, members of the Nest Community will need to change their password in order to continue participating in the community. In addition, The Nest community member's avatars will be replaced with generic default avatars. If you wish to revert to your original avatar, you will need to re-upload it via The Nest.

If you have questions about this, please email help@theknot.com.

Thank you.

Note: This only affects The Nest's community members and will not affect members on The Bump or The Knot.

Just a little vent. A "vent-ie", if you will.

The ILs have a dog. I'm a cat person and DH is both.

The dog occasionally needs caretaking (when the ILs go out of town, twice a year, for a week at a time) and again, yesterday, we got the standard "can you look after the dog on this and this date?" email.

I know they really love the dog, and I know my DH does as well, and since we don't allow him in our house (I use the cats as a reason, but it's totally justified and I'm sticking to my guns on that one), it's fine by him to go up to their home a couple of times a day (they live pretty close to us) and feed/walk the dog, but ... it's annoying. It totally kills any chance of a decent weekend and although it happens very rarely, it still bugs me.

Now they're asking about January and it's just bugging me that they feel that we're always going to help with the dog. I wish they'd be more amenable to a kennel. *sigh*

«1

Re: Just a little vent. A "vent-ie", if you will.

  • not an il issue. an issue with dh not being able to say no. when he says no is when they'll go the boarder route and not before.

    Friday, December 28 2012. The day I had emergency appendix surgery in Mexico and quit smoking. Proof that everything has a good side!! DH and I are happily child-free!! No due date or toddler tickers here!! my read shelf:
    Alison's book recommendations, favorite quotes, book clubs, book trivia, book lists (read shelf) 
  • imagealithebride:

    not an il issue. an issue with dh not being able to say no. when he says no is when they'll go the boarder route and not before.

    It's not really an "issue" as it is something we've both agreed to do. This is water under the bridge. But just 'cause we agreed to do it doesn't mean I don't harbor resentments. :P
  • wouldnt they do the same for you
  • So then why do you keep agreeing to do it? If you say no then they'll find someone else or board him in a kennel. They keep asking you guys to do it because you keep saying yes.

    Why can't you just bring the dog over to your house? Is the dog nasty, not housebroken, ill-behaved? Or do you just not care for dogs? If you aren't allergic to the dog and if he's a nice dog who won't destroy your house, then it seems like (if you insist on helping out the in-laws) it'd be easier to just suck it up and let the dog stay with you.

    Or you could stay at the in-laws' house to care for the dog and then go out and do things in their area, if they don't mind you staying at their place.

    image
  • imagevjcjenn1:
    wouldnt they do the same for you
    Probably. And like I said, I don't actually mind DH doing it too much, but it does get a bit annoying when I get that email. That's why I called this a "vent-ie" - it's not that big a deal, but I wanted to get some reinforcement that it's okay to feel this way.
  • Why would they put him in a kennel when they have their son to care for the dog?

    If it bothers you and you are in the neighborhood, why don't you look for a local kid to do it or at least go-in on the weekends? I loved dogs as a kid and I had a great deal going with an elderly couple when they went away for the weekend. They were great tippers.

    And just to be clear, you should be doing the tipping for the kid, since this is YOUR issue, your ILs already arranged great care for free.

    My darling daughter just turned 4 years old.
  • imagembcdefg:

    So then why do you keep agreeing to do it? If you say no then they'll find someone else or board him in a kennel. They keep asking you guys to do it because you keep saying yes. They'd never board him in a kennel - he's like their child. And he's not that bad a dog, I'm just not a dog person, I work outside the home but I have "easier" hours than DH, and so taking care of him would fall to me if he were in our house and I don't want that.

    Why can't you just bring the dog over to your house? Is the dog nasty, not housebroken, ill-behaved? No, he's actually quite sweet. I'm just not a dog person and I don't like taking care of pets that aren't mine, particularly when I already have three cats.

    Or do you just not care for dogs? If you aren't allergic to the dog and if he's a nice dog who won't destroy your house, then it seems like (if you insist on helping out the in-laws) it'd be easier to just suck it up and let the dog stay with you. It would be, yes, but I don't want that. Mostly 'cause I don't like the idea of having to walk him and all that, but also 'cause we have three cats and it's their home and I feel that it's unfair to them. But also this is a "jump on the furniture" dog and I really, really dislike that.

    Or you could stay at the in-laws' house to care for the dog and then go out and do things in their area, if they don't mind you staying at their place. No, they'd be fine with it, but we can't do that with our cats. And I hate staying at others' homes. I even don't like hotels. But that's not a big deal - their house is literally 15 minutes from us.

    I didn't mean for this to turn into a thing. I just wanted to vent; there's really nothing here to "solve" other than my mild - yes, MILD - resentment. :)

  • I don't think it's unreasonable to wish they'd just go to a kennel once in a while and leave you guys alone for a weekend, but on the other hand if you keep agreeing to it then obviously they think that you have zero problems doing this for them. I get that you're venting but it seems like you want them to read your mind, so you're venting about something that can be easily fixed just by opening your mouth.

    Is your H also annoyed with losing a weekend with you in order to go feed the dog? If so, he needs to tell his folks the next time they ask that you guys are busy and they need to find another pet sitter or board the dog somewhere. If not, then your real vent is that your H keeps agreeing to look after the dog and you wish he would say no once in a while ... in which case you need to say, "Look, H, I'd like a quiet weekend at home/I'd like to go and do something on [date]. If your folks ask you to watch the dog, can you please tell them that we can't do it?"

    Also, how old is the dog? If he's older, do you think your H just wants to spend some time with him before it's too late? My family dog (age 11) recently died, rather unexpectedly, and as she got older I wanted to see her more and more because I began to realize that she wouldn't be around forever.  

    image
  • imagelivinitup:

    Why would they put him in a kennel when they have their son to care for the dog?

    If it bothers you and you are in the neighborhood, why don't you look for a local kid to do it or at least go-in on the weekends? I loved dogs as a kid and I had a great deal going with an elderly couple when they went away for the weekend. They were great tippers.

    And just to be clear, you should be doing the tipping for the kid, since this is YOUR issue, your ILs already arranged great care for free.

    That's not a bad idea. Might bring it up with DH. Thanks. :)
  • imageJoEsther:
    imagevjcjenn1:
    wouldnt they do the same for you
    Probably. And like I said, I don't actually mind DH doing it too much, but it does get a bit annoying when I get that email. That's why I called this a "vent-ie" - it's not that big a deal, but I wanted to get some reinforcement that it's okay to feel this way.

    You can feel this way.

    I'd just do something about it rather than be resentful. Especially as an ongoing twice a year resentment.

    My darling daughter just turned 4 years old.
  • imagembcdefg:

    I don't think it's unreasonable to wish they'd just go to a kennel once in a while and leave you guys alone for a weekend, but on the other hand if you keep agreeing to it then obviously they think that you have zero problems doing this for them. I get that you're venting but it seems like you want them to read your mind, so you're venting about something that can be easily fixed just by opening your mouth. They know I'm not nuts about the dogwatching thing, but that's why - I think - they ASK if we can watch him instead of saying, "Hey, we'll be gone on dates XYZ and need you to watch the dog". But it's one of those questions that it's very hard to say no to, particularly with so much advance notice. I just feel as though we've created a reality in which DH is okay with going up to watch the dog and now we're stuck. I want to change that.

    Is your H also annoyed with losing a weekend with you in order to go feed the dog? If so, he needs to tell his folks the next time they ask that you guys are busy and they need to find another pet sitter or board the dog somewhere. If not, then your real vent is that your H keeps agreeing to look after the dog and you wish he would say no once in a while ... in which case you need to say, "Look, H, I'd like a quiet weekend at home/I'd like to go and do something on [date]. If your folks ask you to watch the dog, can you please tell them that we can't do it?" H loves the dog and wants to be, and is, very respectful in that he's good with boundaries for me (I'm a bit tougher with boundaries and have more set preferences in place than he does), but he has things that he enjoys doing too and for him taking care of the dog feels like something he wants to do. That said, if we had advance plans, he'd never commit to taking care of him and he'd be fine with saying no.

    Also, how old is the dog? If he's older, do you think your H just wants to spend some time with him before it's too late? My family dog (age 11) recently died, rather unexpectedly, and as she got older I wanted to see her more and more because I began to realize that she wouldn't be around forever.  Actually, the dog is really young - maybe 3 or so (which explains the hyperness, part of what I don't like about him). But H does love him (he loves all animals) and he enjoys his time with him. But if he had to say no, he would, no problem.

    Thanks for your inputs - I appreciate it.
  • imagelivinitup:

    imageJoEsther:
    imagevjcjenn1:
    wouldnt they do the same for you
    Probably. And like I said, I don't actually mind DH doing it too much, but it does get a bit annoying when I get that email. That's why I called this a "vent-ie" - it's not that big a deal, but I wanted to get some reinforcement that it's okay to feel this way.

    You can feel this way.

    I'd just do something about it rather than be resentful. Especially as an ongoing twice a year resentment.

    Yeah, you're right. Maybe it's time to take the bull by the horns here. I've gotten some good advice on this thread - I might have to take some of it. Thanks.
  • my dog is like our child and we board him all of the time for weeks on end when were on vacay. we have a great boarder and dont infringe on our family.

    i totally get that you dont want him in your house.  i suggest that you suggest to them to ask their vet for a rec for a dog sitter-they can pay the sitter to do the same thing your DH does (if he'll ever say no) and they can be fine with it.

    Friday, December 28 2012. The day I had emergency appendix surgery in Mexico and quit smoking. Proof that everything has a good side!! DH and I are happily child-free!! No due date or toddler tickers here!! my read shelf:
    Alison's book recommendations, favorite quotes, book clubs, book trivia, book lists (read shelf) 
  • I can understand your frustration, Jo.  It seems as though you don't mind watching IL's dog, but don't necessarily want to be their automatic go-to dog watcher either.

    2 full weeks per year seems a little excessive - even if you are a dog person and truly enjoy the experience. 

    DH & I have 2 cats & a dog and know that taking care of each is a very different task.  For cats - you put out the self waterer/self feeder & automatic litterboxes and you're done.  Dogs are more of a "pack" animal and need more attention, plus there's the walking, playing & taking outside.  I know that when DH & I aren't home (we're talking a quick trip to the grocery store or at work), our dog is stressed that we aren't coming back and sits by the window.  The cats, on the otherhand, are sound asleep in our bed! ha

    This is IL's responsibility and need not put on yours & DH's shoulders.  Come to a compromise with them.  Maybe 1 week is all you & DH can devote to them from now on and the other week, they are on their own finding alternate care for the dog.  Vocalize to them that although you enjoy it, you can only committ to that 1 week (more or less); whatever suits the two of you.

    Where's DH stance on this?  If he truly loves going over to take care of the dog, then you can't take that away from him.  Frustrating, yes, that his time is devoted to that, but it has to be his decision.

  • imagealithebride:

    my dog is like our child and we board him all of the time for weeks on end when were on vacay. we have a great boarder and dont infringe on our family. I really admire you for that. What a wonderful attitude.

    i totally get that you dont want him in your house.  Thank you.

    i suggest that you suggest to them to ask their vet for a rec for a dog sitter-they can pay the sitter to do the same thing your DH does (if he'll ever say no) and they can be fine with it.  He'd say no if I asked him to and explained why it bothers me.  I just don't know if I feel right about asking, but clearly the time has come.  That's a good idea re the dog sitter - thanks.

  • I just feel as though we've created a reality in which DH is okay with going up to watch the dog and now we're stuck. I want to change that.

    I think it's reasonable to be annoyed at this and to bring it up with your H.

    image
  • imageShannersLA:

    I can understand your frustration, Jo.  It seems as though you don't mind watching IL's dog, but don't necessarily want to be their automatic go-to dog watcher either. That's exactly it. And the issue for me is that I generally like my ILs - they're nice people and I really enjoy them, for the most part. But these emails are making me like them less and resent them more, and could have, if not taken care of now, a real detrimental effect on our relationship.

    2 full weeks per year seems a little excessive - even if you are a dog person and truly enjoy the experience. 

    DH & I have 2 cats & a dog and know that taking care of each is a very different task.  For cats - you put out the self waterer/self feeder & automatic litterboxes and you're done.  Dogs are more of a "pack" animal and need more attention, plus there's the walking, playing & taking outside.  I know that when DH & I aren't home (we're talking a quick trip to the grocery store or at work), our dog is stressed that we aren't coming back and sits by the window.  The cats, on the otherhand, are sound asleep in our bed! ha  Exactly. Cats are so much easier and that's part of why I prefer them. That, and they're just more "my style" FWIW. I'm not and never have been a dog person.

    This is IL's responsibility and need not put on yours & DH's shoulders.  Come to a compromise with them.  Maybe 1 week is all you & DH can devote to them from now on and the other week, they are on their own finding alternate care for the dog.  Vocalize to them that although you enjoy it, you can only committ to that 1 week (more or less); whatever suits the two of you.  It's not about watching the dog as much as it is about the expectation, I've noticed as I've read through this thread and the replies. I think it's a bit of that "being taken for granted" thing. As though we're expected to watch him and OMG what will happen if we say no. I don't like that at all.

    Where's DH stance on this?  If he truly loves going over to take care of the dog, then you can't take that away from him.  Frustrating, yes, that his time is devoted to that, but it has to be his decision. He's fine with going over but it's not something he'd search out. MIL says that when they got the dog, they got it "with their kids" and therefore it's all of their responsibility. I call BS - it's the ILs dog, not the kids', not anyone else's. He'd be fine with saying no, I think.

    Thanks for your inputs!!
  • "MIL says that when they got the dog, they got it "with their kids" and therefore it's all of their responsibility."

     

    Okay, now I'm annoyed, too.

    image
  • imageReturnOfKuus:

    "MIL says that when they got the dog, they got it "with their kids" and therefore it's all of their responsibility."

     

    Okay, now I'm annoyed, too.

    Ditto.  If MIL is still in this mindset, then she is wrong & needs a new perspective.  It is not DH's (or inheritantly yours) obligation to watch DH's "childhood" pet.  He is a grown, married man now w/his own responsibilities.  IL's need a reality check!

  • I know, right?  If it were really his pet, he'd have taken it with him when he moved out.
    image
  • O.k., the problem here is that this post makes me want a Starbucks Pumpkin Spice Latte .... 
    "Beer is living proof that God loves us and wants us to be happy."
    ~Benjamin Franklin

    Lilypie Third Birthday tickers
    DS dx with celiac disease 5/28/10

  • Ditto PPs, you have a DH problem here. We have dogs and when we go away, we board them at a kennel because we don't want to pawn our dogs off on someone else. Sure it's costly and sucks, but that's part of the responsibility of having a dog. What's wrong that your ILs cannot board this dog for the two weeks out of the year that they go away?

    Why is it your responsibility to take care of this dog?

  • imageEastCoastBride:
    O.k., the problem here is that this post makes me want a Starbucks Pumpkin Spice Latte .... 

    LOL!  You should try a white chocolate mocha w/chocolate chips....::drools::

  • I know that it is annoying and "ruins your weekend" but really it's only once or twice a year.  I ask my parents to look after my dog when I go off and they ask the same. We also watch MIL's dog when she goes off. Same goes for grandparents pets.  It is not as though they ask you to do this often, helping family when they need help, especially if they live close is a good thing.  I wouldn't leave my dog at a kennel, I would rather her sleep outside with "Uncle Thomas" and "Aunt Chloe" at my parents house than to sleep at a kennel where she doesn't have any familiar people taking care of her.  I know she is "just a dog" but I mean really why pay a kennel when you have family members that can and are willing to help out. Obviously this doesn't bother your husband and I really dont see why it bothers you so very much aside from not being a dog person. 
    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • imageEastCoastBride:
    O.k., the problem here is that this post makes me want a Starbucks Pumpkin Spice Latte .... 
    I just stopped into a Starbucks to check my email (3G takes up so much battery power) and saw this comment..... Love it! :)
  • imageJoEsther:
    I just stopped into a Starbucks
    Really?  REALLY?  You had to rub it in, didn't you?  :)
    "Beer is living proof that God loves us and wants us to be happy."
    ~Benjamin Franklin

    Lilypie Third Birthday tickers
    DS dx with celiac disease 5/28/10

  • The more I think about it, the more I realize that it's not so much about the dog as it is about my feeling as though we're being taken for granted, and the frustration and anger that creates. And that's a shame 'cause otherwise I really love my ILs. The dog is just the vehicle that creates that feeling. A conversation with the H is definitely in order. Thanks ladies!!
  • imageEastCoastBride:
    imageJoEsther:
    I just stopped into a Starbucks
    Really?  REALLY?  You had to rub it in, didn't you?  :)
    Oooh yeah... Smells so good in here! ;)
  • I think you're being a little whiney.  I'm sure they do things to help you guys out.  It's twice a year according to you, and sounds like you personally don't have to do anything...  That's what family does, help each other out.  No biggie.  If this is your biggest annoyance in life, count yourself lucky.
  • imagekristie6406377:
    I think you're being a little whiney.  I'm sure they do things to help you guys out.  It's twice a year according to you, and sounds like you personally don't have to do anything...  That's what family does, help each other out.  No biggie.  If this is your biggest annoyance in life, count yourself lucky.
    I am lucky, I know I am. And yes, it's not a big deal - I was just hoping to get some support and inputs from the ladies on here, and I did.

    BTW, telling someone that they are being a little whiney usually isn't helpful or problem-solving oriented, and neither is assuming what my ILs do or don't do to help us out. Just sayin'. :)

Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards