Starting Over
Dear Community,

Our tech team has launched updates to The Nest today. As a result of these updates, members of the Nest Community will need to change their password in order to continue participating in the community. In addition, The Nest community member's avatars will be replaced with generic default avatars. If you wish to revert to your original avatar, you will need to re-upload it via The Nest.

If you have questions about this, please email help@theknot.com.

Thank you.

Note: This only affects The Nest's community members and will not affect members on The Bump or The Knot.

s/o remarry.. would you remarry HIM?

2»

Re: s/o remarry.. would you remarry HIM?

  • imageMia2700:
    imageOnlyaFool:

    Good luck in therapy! I hope you're able to get a handle on your feelings and resolve your current situation :)

    Thank you, I appreciate that. 

    Whenever someone says that to me though, I always feel like they can clearly see the answer from the outside perspective but want me to figure it out on my own and drives me crazy lol

    Well, I can assure you that I do NOT have the "answer" to your situation! But I'm also not IN your relationship, so even if I thought I had the answer, the odds of me knowing the best thing for you to do would not be that great.

    I guess my only advice is to (1) really commit to therapy to find out what YOU want and need first, then (2) see if your husband can (and is willing to and wants to) provide that. THEN, (3) decide if you want HIM to be the one to provide it after all.

    There! 3 simple steps! Wink lol. We all know it's not that easy...

    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • imagetrafficgirl:

    It would still be an unequivocable no :) I think he/we would slip into old patterns and it would be miserable. I just can't trust him again, and also can't get past my feelings of disgust. I wouldn't be able to get over the all the past hurt. Nevermind the fact that I've now been in a healthy relationship for over a year and know what one is supposed to feel like.

    Makes sense.  So even without anything wild, you have a certainty to your answer.

    I just don't have that kind of confidence either way right now.  I feel like my H would be in the one to have the trust issues now since I may have gone a little crazy and ended up walking out on him. 

  • imageachase123:
    imageMia2700:

    imageachase123:
    I guess if I was declared legally insane, my friends and family were all dead (because they'd have to be to let me go through with it), I was living on a deserted island with only ex and P, he held a gun to my head the entire time, and he had offered me a billion dollars to do it, THEN I'd remarry him.

    lol  This is prettyyyyy much what I expected you to say.. although I would have thought you'd still say no at that point Wink

    Hey, I could do a lot with a billion!  Including hiring a hit man...just sayin'.  Plus, no one ever said I had to sleep with him again (Ick!) and I could divorce his asss the next day once the transaction went into my account!

    hahah that's more like it!  I should have known there was a motive behind that 'yes' lol

  • there is nothing in this life or the next that could make me re-marry him
  • I really don't think I could ever be with him, ever ever again.  Too much happened, too many hurtful experiences, and when I finally got wise enough to realize I'm better than all that crap...I just could never go back.
    image
  • imageachase123:
    I guess if I was declared legally insane, my friends and family were all dead (because they'd have to be to let me go through with it), I was living on a deserted island with only ex and P, he held a gun to my head the entire time, and he had offered me a billion dollars to do it, THEN I'd remarry him.

     

    Knowing what we all know about your XH, I'm guessing he'd probably see this and say, "So you're saying there's a chance?!" LOL 

    She's crafty - and she's just my type.
  • Even with the bad, I'm not sure I regret marrying him though.  He didn't really change until after we moved away from our hometown and by then, we were in the middle of planning the wedding and I was too dumb to see some of the signs.

    He blessed me with the two best things in my world.  And I'm very thankful for that.

    I just would never go back to him.

    image
  • imageOnlyaFool:

    Well, I can assure you that I do NOT have the "answer" to your situation! But I'm also not IN your relationship, so even if I thought I had the answer, the odds of me knowing the best thing for you to do would not be that great.

    I guess my only advice is to (1) really commit to therapy to find out what YOU want and need first, then (2) see if your husband can (and is willing to and wants to) provide that. THEN, (3) decide if you want HIM to be the one to provide it after all.

    There! 3 simple steps! Wink lol. We all know it's not that easy...

    As funny as it may seem, it's reassuring to hear you say that you don't know.  I get this paranoia when people are all "oh don't worry you'll figure it out..." that they are all laughing at me from a distance because they all know the right answer but I'm just too far "in" the situation to see it.

    I just made an appointment with my therapist to really dig into everything instead of telling her what I "know" because clearly there are things left unturned at this point.

    I wish it was this easy!  It seemed so easy the first time to just go with all the good feelings and dive right in!  Now suddenly it's like I feel the need to examine every little detail - which I think is going to cause more harm than good right now. Confused

  • imageMintChocoChip:
    If he was on his death bed, listed me as his life insurance beneficiary and his health care proxy with a direct order to pull the plug...even then I'd probably say hell no.

    I love you MCC.

    imageimage. Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
  • imageMia2700:
    imageOnlyaFool:

    Well, I can assure you that I do NOT have the "answer" to your situation! But I'm also not IN your relationship, so even if I thought I had the answer, the odds of me knowing the best thing for you to do would not be that great.

    I guess my only advice is to (1) really commit to therapy to find out what YOU want and need first, then (2) see if your husband can (and is willing to and wants to) provide that. THEN, (3) decide if you want HIM to be the one to provide it after all.

    There! 3 simple steps! Wink lol. We all know it's not that easy...

    As funny as it may seem, it's reassuring to hear you say that you don't know.  I get this paranoia when people are all "oh don't worry you'll figure it out..." that they are all laughing at me from a distance because they all know the right answer but I'm just too far "in" the situation to see it.

    I just made an appointment with my therapist to really dig into everything instead of telling her what I "know" because clearly there are things left unturned at this point.

    I wish it was this easy!  It seemed so easy the first time to just go with all the good feelings and dive right in!  Now suddenly it's like I feel the need to examine every little detail - which I think is going to cause more harm than good right now. Confused

    Nah, I know what you mean. I'm pretty sure no one is laughing at you.

    re: therapy, sounds like you're going in with a good and open attitude, so that can only help.  :)

    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • Because he had an affair and infidelity is a deal-breaker for me, the answer to that one is no. I do know a couple who divorced (after marrying young) and eventually remarried one another and are very happy together. However, I don't think that is the norm.
    image

    "No longer lend your strength to that which you wish to be free from." -Jewel

  • I'm also on the hell to the no train. He was abusive, cheated since the day I met him, and made me feel like I couldn't finish anything. Since splitting I have good credit, money in the bank and have more control over my life. I completely lost myself in my marriage.

    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • imagePhoenixRising11:
    Because he had an affair and infidelity is a deal-breaker for me, the answer to that one is no. I do know a couple who divorced (after marrying young) and eventually remarried one another and are very happy together. However, I don't think that is the norm.

    Agreed that I don't think that's the norm.  I would be curious as to what caused the initial divorce, that they are now able to live with?

  • imageDarthNBJenni:
    I'd rather poke my eyes out with a fork. 

     

    Hahahaha THIS!

  • I would consider it if and only if 1) one of us changed (legitimately, seriously changed and not just pretending to change) our opinions on having kids (he wanted them, I didn't), 2) he lived on his own for a while (not with his parents), 3) we lived in the same state, and 4) I weren't in a happy relationship
  • I wouldn't remarry him -- but I also wouldn't trade the years that I was married to him for the world.  My ex is a wonderful, kind, fun person.  We just weren't meant to be for the long haul.  I loved the vast majority of the decade we spent together, but I have no qualms about moving on.

    So we beat on, boats against the current, borne back ceaselessly into the past.

  • imageGhostofZeldaFitzgerald:
    I wouldn't remarry him -- but I also wouldn't trade the years that I was married to him for the world.  My ex is a wonderful, kind, fun person.  We just weren't meant to be for the long haul.  I loved the vast majority of the decade we spent together, but I have no qualms about moving on.

    These are the stories that freak me out a little.  Why, then, if he's so wonderful, can you not make it for the long haul?  You don't have to answer, I just don't understand when people say that what it means.

  • It means that a marriage is more than living like siblings or really cool roommates.  It means that I came to terms with the fact that we really weren't more than friends, and that we both deserved a shot at a more fulfilling relationship.

    I wanted more for myself, and for him.  So even though we weren't angry, even though nothing terrible happened, we acknowledged that we just weren't a good couple.  Too many fundamental personality conflicts.  And we decided to end it on good terms.  He's still one of my closest friends.  He's still my family.  He's just not my husband anymore.  

    So we beat on, boats against the current, borne back ceaselessly into the past.

  • Nope.

     

    image
    They see us rollin'...they be hatin'.
  • imageGhostofZeldaFitzgerald:

    It means that a marriage is more than living like siblings or really cool roommates.  It means that I came to terms with the fact that we really weren't more than friends, and that we both deserved a shot at a more fulfilling relationship.

    I wanted more for myself, and for him.  So even though we weren't angry, even though nothing terrible happened, we acknowledged that we just weren't a good couple.  Too many fundamental personality conflicts.  And we decided to end it on good terms.  He's still one of my closest friends.  He's still my family.  He's just not my husband anymore.  

    Ok, that makes a lot of sense.  Thank you for that.

    I am also infamous for looking at others' stories and wondering how I relate or if my timelines match or if the outcome would be the same, etc, etc. I realize it's a terrible habit because no ones stories are exactly the same, but it's sort of temporarily comforting to think that we aren't as alone as we feel sometimes.

  • No. No one can have a lontg-term relationship with a narcisistic sociopath. I should have dumped him before the marriage. The signs were there.
    image
  • Sure, in a heartbeat.

    If by marry him you mean shoot him.

    Vacation
  • hells no. I shouldn't have even dated him, and I knew the day of the wedding it was a mistake, but then I freaked out and didn't stop it. 

    I honestly think he has a personality disorder. He is incapable of telling the truth and has absolutely no empathy for anyone. Everything else is just a spinoff from that. 

    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards