Politics & Current Events
Dear Community,

Our tech team has launched updates to The Nest today. As a result of these updates, members of the Nest Community will need to change their password in order to continue participating in the community. In addition, The Nest community member's avatars will be replaced with generic default avatars. If you wish to revert to your original avatar, you will need to re-upload it via The Nest.

If you have questions about this, please email help@theknot.com.

Thank you.

Note: This only affects The Nest's community members and will not affect members on The Bump or The Knot.

Do you call the police if you see a car crash?

2»

Re: Do you call the police if you see a car crash?

  • I was in what seemed like a minor fender bender on the DC beltway and immediately called 911.  They asked if there were any injuries and before I was finished saying "I don't think so" they had transfered me to the non-emergency highway services line, or something like that.  Folks in the cars behind me had to be taken to the emergency room (after someone else called and EMS was sent).  I realize that 911 is busy and needs to deal with true emergencies, so it was a good lesson that I should spend 10 seconds to take stock of the situation before calling.  I wonder if 911 passed you off so quickly because it was clear that you didn't know what had happened or if anyone was injured.  Not excusing them.

  • Here's one for ya-

    I witnessed an accident while sitting at a stop light in which a little sedan t-boned an SUV that was running a red light. The SUV flew up into the air and rolled over probably 5 or 6 times, ejecting both passengers. The guy flew probably 30 feet into the air and looked like a rag doll.

    At that point I would say that probably 10 cars immediately stopped and ran to help these people.

    So, while I was calling 911, I got a busy signal for probably 5 solid minutes.

    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • I usually call 911 or the highway patrol to report it.

    Last year, I saw an accident.  I saw a car swerving behind me but they missed me.  I also saw a motorcyclist behind that car swerve, saw him go down, roll and get back up.  I called 911 to report it and the person that answered was really pissy about it and gave me a hard time.  She refused to send anyone to respond b/c there were people standing around the guy and he was upright at that point.  She said they'd only send someone to respond if the people with him called (WTF?).  I called a family member who is a dispatcher to ask if I was crazy b/c that just sounded f-d up.  The family member was horrified.  I contacted the emergency services manager for the county and he pulled the call record and disciplined the dispatcher.  He told me if it happened again, to keep calling 911 until someone responded.
    I am the 39%.
  • imagefernane:
    imageMrsAxilla:
    imageDruidPrincess:

    I know if you're a trained medical professional and it looks like there might be injuries, it is incumbent upon you to stop and assist.

    Not true.  Unless by incumbent you mean "probably the moral thing to do." 

    No, I know in Texas we have a good Samaritan law in which you must stop and render aide in a situation like a crash..you could get in trouble if you ignore it. Sounds like you could have a similar law. Definitely worth looking into.OP...that's pretty scary! 

    No, ood samaritan laws protect from civil suit you IF you stop and help.  They do not mandate that you stop.

    And how in the world would they know if you just drive by?  There's absolutely no way of enforcing it. 

    image
  • Depends. Minor fenderbender with people exchanging information? I see that weekly, and no. Major crash where people might need to be examined at least by an EMT? Of course. I also encountered an accident once where the cars were each blocking a lane of traffic (in the middle of a 4 lane road, so only the 2 right lanes where available). The cars were definitely not able to be driven (entire front end of a BMW 3 series smashed in), but no one seemed hurt, and there were no emergency vehicles in site. I called the police and was simply told that the cops in my area don't respond to non-injury crashes. I was thinking they might want to redirect traffic, or at the very least take a report for insurance or the DMV reporting. They didn't seem suprised, though. I would imagine lots of people call things like that in.

    I also called in a good samaritan report when my friend saw someone slumped in his car once.

    my read shelf:
    Meredith's book recommendations, liked quotes, book clubs, book trivia, book lists (read shelf)
    40/112

    Photobucket
  • imageMrsAxilla:
    imageDruidPrincess:

    I know if you're a trained medical professional and it looks like there might be injuries, it is incumbent upon you to stop and assist.

    Not true.  Unless by incumbent you mean "probably the moral thing to do." 

    This is what I was going to say.  Unless your state has a good samaritan law I'd probably counsel against trying to help.  You could be liable for making things worse.

    Incumbent could also mean "by the standards of the medical profession you are a part of".  In any event, there is no legal obligation that I am aware of in NY.

  • imageLittleMoxie:
    imageMrsAxilla:
    imageDruidPrincess:

    I know if you're a trained medical professional and it looks like there might be injuries, it is incumbent upon you to stop and assist.

    Not true.  Unless by incumbent you mean "probably the moral thing to do." 

    This is what I was going to say.  Unless your state has a good samaritan law I'd probably counsel against trying to help.  You could be liable for making things worse.

    Incumbent could also mean "by the standards of the medical profession you are a part of".  In any event, there is no legal obligation that I am aware of in NY.

    Good Samaritan laws in Minnesota and Vermont do require a person at the scene of an emergency to provide reasonable assistance to a person in need, although that can be simply calling 9-11.  I don't know if driving past an accident = "at the scene of an emergency" though.  Seems like there might be a lot of gray area there.
    image
    Anything you can achieve through hard work, you could also just buy.
  • imagefernane:
    imageMrsAxilla:
    imageDruidPrincess:

    I know if you're a trained medical professional and it looks like there might be injuries, it is incumbent upon you to stop and assist.

    Not true.  Unless by incumbent you mean "probably the moral thing to do." 

    No, I know in Texas we have a good Samaritan law in which you must stop and render aide in a situation like a crash..you could get in trouble if you ignore it. Sounds like you could have a similar law. Definitely worth looking into.

    Wrong again.  http://www.examiner.com/article/the-texas-good-samaritan-law-encourages-citizens-to-give-emergency-care

     

     

    image
    Anything you can achieve through hard work, you could also just buy.
  • emisiemisi member
    I'd call.  I've also called for things like people driving erratically, and a man that looked like he was having a psychotic break for a good ten miles (he was punching at the air, pulling his hair, swerving, kind of scary).
    Image and video hosting by TinyPic


    BabyFetus Ticker

    VOTE on my Name List

Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards