Relationships
Dear Community,

Our tech team has launched updates to The Nest today. As a result of these updates, members of the Nest Community will need to change their password in order to continue participating in the community. In addition, The Nest community member's avatars will be replaced with generic default avatars. If you wish to revert to your original avatar, you will need to re-upload it via The Nest.

If you have questions about this, please email help@theknot.com.

Thank you.

Note: This only affects The Nest's community members and will not affect members on The Bump or The Knot.

Would you be ok with this?

My FI and I have a great relationship. A girl from his past whom he claims he never dated but very close with. This was when they were about 10yrs old-20. She lived with my FI and his parents as she did not have great parents.

 

She is married now with kids, and haven't talked to my FI in about 7 years. 

She texted him the other day, saying she misses him, and they should go to dinner. He said he was very excited, and they will do dinner. He also said he missed her too. He told me he last night he is excited to see her.

 

Do you think this is appropriate?

«134

Re: Would you be ok with this?

  • At face value, I see nothing wrong with this.  I believe men and women can be friends, and as such, I don't see why a man can't be excited to see an old childhood friend who happens to be a woman, and miss that friend. 

    Sounds like he's being on the up and up with you.  W/o any other details, I really don't see the issue. 

    "Beer is living proof that God loves us and wants us to be happy."
    ~Benjamin Franklin

    Lilypie Third Birthday tickers
    DS dx with celiac disease 5/28/10

  • Thanks for the reply.

    He deleted the text message he sent to her that said "I miss you". 

    She texted him this morning, he lied to me and said it was one of his guy friends.

     I am a slightly jealous person, and we have had some issues in the past with my insecurities. 

    Maybe he didn't want to make me upset?

  • imageemricmacy:

    Thanks for the reply.

    He deleted the text message he sent to her that said "I miss you". 

    She texted him this morning, he lied to me and said it was one of his guy friends.

     I am a slightly jealous person, and we have had some issues in the past with my insecurities. 

    Maybe he didn't want to make me upset?

    It could very well be he didn't want to upset you.  But my take on this - if everything is on the up and up, he HAS TO BE transparent about this woman. HAS to be.

    That's my other thing about male/female friendships.  I think they can absolutely happen - but that friendship has to be a "friend" to the marriage, and everyone have to be transparent.


    You know you have issues - and I think YOU need to deal w/ those on some level because your DH shouldn't have to take the brunt of your issues.  BUT he has to also understand that your issues aren't going to get BETTER by him hiding stuff from you.

    Because hiding stuff could absolutely also mean that there IS more to this friendship than he wants to tell you about.  And if that's the case, then maybe he needs to not be meeting her for dinner.... 

    "Beer is living proof that God loves us and wants us to be happy."
    ~Benjamin Franklin

    Lilypie Third Birthday tickers
    DS dx with celiac disease 5/28/10

  • He told me that she's a swetheart, and she was living with my FI and his parents growing up because her did didn't want anything to do with her.

    He told me last night they never even held hands. 

    He said she's married and has kids now. 

    I do have issues, and I do work on them everyday. 

    I'm thinking the whole him deleting that he missed her was trying not to upset me, as I do use his phone sometimes.

    I guess just a little bit of jealously is coming out. I don't know if it is appropriate to have dinner with a female with not inviting his SO. 

    He would be very upset if I went to dinner with a past male friend. 

  • It sounds like they were raised almost as brother and sister. He has stated that they were not romantic in the past, and it sounds like you believe that. While I don't agree with him hiding things from you, this sounds innocent. He told you about the meeting. 
  • They have a bond like a brother/sister. You need to learn that not every situation warrants jealousy. I'm sure he did delete his text to her, he doesn't want a fight or to deal with it. Why would you go to dinner with them? Her H and kids aren't going and they will be catching up and talking about the past. You may want to look into counseling for yourself. You are punishing your H over your issues not something that he did.
  • All of this sounds okay to me.  Is there something more to the story, like he always liked her or something?  Or do you get the impression that this was the case?

    ed:  Okay, I see that he'd be upset if you went to dinner with a male friend.  What's with that?  Why the double standard?

    image
  • Thank you for all the replies.

    We have had some trust issues in the VERY beginning of our relationship, that has not helped our relationship, but have gotten over that.

    As the 2nd month we were dating, I caught him seriously sexting a girl he has slept with before me. I have gotten over this, but will never forget it.

  • O.k. - not cool w /the double standard.  And I just saw your post on Family Matters about $$.  I'm going to be honest.... there seem to be some pretty decent issues going on in  your relationship.  And $$ can be a HUGE issue - even bigger than this jealousy issue. 

    I'm not going to say "leave him/ end things", but i'd encourage you to do some soul searching and decide if this is REALLY the right relationship for you.  He seems to be more concerned about other people than with you. 

    "Beer is living proof that God loves us and wants us to be happy."
    ~Benjamin Franklin

    Lilypie Third Birthday tickers
    DS dx with celiac disease 5/28/10

  • He didn't say anything about liking her. He said she was like a little sister.

    I have never gone out to dinner with another male as long as I have been with him. He has also not gone out with another female to dinner as long as he has been with me. 

    Last 4th of July, an engaged male friend who always calls people hun, texted me and said Happy 4th of July hun, my FI saw that, and didn't talk to me for the rest of the night.

    It is somewhat a double standard. 

  • He does  A LOT for me, never yells at me, treats me great. He said he's never been this happy.

    We do have some issues. We don't fight about the In-law issues with money. We barely fight, and we only do when it involves another female. 

    I know, I take all the blame for my jealous fits. 

  • So he thinks it's okay for him to sext a previous lover, but it's not okay for a platonic friend to wish you a happy fourth of July.

    This is not a good guy.  This is a cheater.  You're right not to trust him.  You don't have a good relationship aside from this, because there IS no aside from this. 

    image
  • imageemricmacy:

    He does  A LOT for me, never yells at me, treats me great. He said he's never been this happy.

    We do have some issues. We don't fight about the In-law issues with money. We barely fight, and we only do when it involves another female. 

    I know, I take all the blame for my jealous fits. 

    "Not fighting" about the money issue doesn't mean it's not an issue, though.  Being able to say "we never fight!" can also mean "our communication sucks!".

    You posted about the money issue - so clearly there IS an issue.  But you don't want to "tell him what to do" - so you don't actually talk to him about it much, do you?  Hence, why you all never actually fight about it. 

    "Beer is living proof that God loves us and wants us to be happy."
    ~Benjamin Franklin

    Lilypie Third Birthday tickers
    DS dx with celiac disease 5/28/10

  • imageReturnOfKuus:

    So he thinks it's okay for him to sext a previous lover, but it's not okay for a platonic friend to wish you a happy fourth of July.

    This is not a good guy.  This is a cheater.  You're right not to trust him.  You don't have a good relationship aside from this, because there IS no aside from this. 

    And hell, this.

    It's not "somewhat" a double standard.  It IS a double standard.

    The vibe I'm getting from this is that he's pretty controlling, wants things his way, and if you dare to say 'boo', you feel bad and take all the "blame" (yes, you may have jealousy issues, but I'm beginning to think there may be a pretty good reason for that....).   And you sit back and let him pretty much do whatever he wants. 
     

    "Beer is living proof that God loves us and wants us to be happy."
    ~Benjamin Franklin

    Lilypie Third Birthday tickers
    DS dx with celiac disease 5/28/10

  • I think if it was innocent and they were really "just friends" he would have invited you to go with them. He would want you to meet her since they grew up as brother/sister. He shouldn't have deleted any of the texts and should have been completely honest with you.

     I completely understand the double standard thing because I go through the same thing.  

  • Thank you ladies for all the response.

    I have let the past go, I do think he talks to other women. I found about the sexting the 2nd month of dating, as I looked through his phone(yes I know it's wrong, I had a feeling). He was so upset, because all of his ex's went through his phone. He then put a password on it. I know the password now, and even though I haven't found him texting other girls, he could easily delete them.

    I do worry sometimes, and my jealously does get the best of me. :-(

  • Maxine, why are you going through the same thing?
    image
  • He is the controlling type to an extent. On a daily basis, he doesn't try to tell me what to do, etc.

    But when it comes to other things, he's independent. He's always been like that his family says. They say he's always had a password on his phone, etc.

    The only time we have ever fought is when he claims I have a "little jealous fit" over things to do with women.

    Long story SHORT. He dated a crazy girl when he was 17 for 2 months, 2 months, and she still contacts him, reams him out for being engaged, and he will still call her back. LONG STORY!

  • imageemricmacy:

    Thank you ladies for all the response.

    I have let the past go, I do think he talks to other women. I found about the sexting the 2nd month of dating, as I looked through his phone(yes I know it's wrong, I had a feeling). He was so upset, because all of his ex's went through his phone. He then put a password on it. I know the password now, and even though I haven't found him texting other girls, he could easily delete them.

    I do worry sometimes, and my jealously does get the best of me. :-(

    Then why did you marry him? You aren't over the cheating from the past, if you where over it you would trust him.  

  • That's what I thought! I thought he would have invited me, even if it is innocent. If a male friend from the past invited me to dinner, I would have invited him, as I think it's out of respect for your SO.

     

  • imageemricmacy:

    Thank you ladies for all the response.

    I have let the past go, I do think he talks to other women. I found about the sexting the 2nd month of dating, as I looked through his phone(yes I know it's wrong, I had a feeling). He was so upset, because all of his ex's went through his phone. He then put a password on it. I know the password now, and even though I haven't found him texting other girls, he could easily delete them.

    I do worry sometimes, and my jealously does get the best of me. :-(

    Well look, I'd be jealous too if my SO was into talking to other women and about other women all the time. I wonder why you are/were attracted to this man?  

  • imageMLE2010:
    imageemricmacy:

    Thank you ladies for all the response.

    I have let the past go, I do think he talks to other women. I found about the sexting the 2nd month of dating, as I looked through his phone(yes I know it's wrong, I had a feeling). He was so upset, because all of his ex's went through his phone. He then put a password on it. I know the password now, and even though I haven't found him texting other girls, he could easily delete them.

    I do worry sometimes, and my jealously does get the best of me. :-(

    Then why did you marry him? You aren't over the cheating from the past, if you where over it you would trust him.  

     

    She didn't marry him; he's just a FI at this point.  What he should be is an ex-FI.

    image
  • imageemricmacy:

    I have let the past go, I do think he talks to other women. I found about the sexting the 2nd month of dating, as I looked through his phone(yes I know it's wrong, I had a feeling). He was so upset, because all of his ex's went through his phone. He then put a password on it.

    OMG.  I"m sorry, but this is too funny for words.  He's upset because "all" of his exes went through his phone?  No- he's upset because he was CAUGHT.  And they probably went through his phone for the same reason you did - something didn't feel right.

    Come on honey....  to quote Kuus, why settle for this guy when there are 3 million other guys out there to pick from?  

    He isn't a good guy.  He just isn't. 


    "Beer is living proof that God loves us and wants us to be happy."
    ~Benjamin Franklin

    Lilypie Third Birthday tickers
    DS dx with celiac disease 5/28/10

  • I don't know for a fact that he does still talk to other women, but he said before me when he was single, he had women all the time asking him out. He loves women.
  • Just that my husband can talk to whomever he wants (women included) but one of my high school friends who lives across the country from me now, who I haven't talked to in 20 years, sent me a message on facebook just to catch up and I caught all manners of hell about it. 
  • It's three BILLION men, EastCoast.  Three billion.  No need to settle for these kinds of douchebags.

    Maxine, what does your husband say when you point out his double standard and tell him to piss up a rope?

    image
  • imageMaxineC:
    Just that my husband can talk to whomever he wants (women included) but one of my high school friends who lives across the country from me now, who I haven't talked to in 20 years, sent me a message on facebook just to catch up and I caught all manners of hell about it. 

    Can you elaborate? 

  • imageemricmacy:
    I don't know for a fact that he does still talk to other women, but he said before me when he was single, he had women all the time asking him out. He loves women.

    Why did you keep dating this person if he was already talking with other women 2 months into your dating? And why do you think this guy is marriage material again? 

  • imageReturnOfKuus:

    It's three BILLION men, EastCoast.  Three billion.  No need to settle for these kinds of douchebags.

    I knew I'd get it wrong!  ;)  BILLION!!!! 
    "Beer is living proof that God loves us and wants us to be happy."
    ~Benjamin Franklin

    Lilypie Third Birthday tickers
    DS dx with celiac disease 5/28/10

  • I'm not sure really, I fell for him, too hard. I should have ended it right there, but I didn't.

    Thing is, I treat him like a KING. Laying out his PJ's, making B,L,D. Bring him coffee every day when I get out of work, etc, etc, etc, etc. I do it because I want to. But how can I do everything he wants, and have that done to me?

    Like I said, I don't know if he still talks to women or not!!

Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards