Married Life
Dear Community,

Our tech team has launched updates to The Nest today. As a result of these updates, members of the Nest Community will need to change their password in order to continue participating in the community. In addition, The Nest community member's avatars will be replaced with generic default avatars. If you wish to revert to your original avatar, you will need to re-upload it via The Nest.

If you have questions about this, please email help@theknot.com.

Thank you.

Note: This only affects The Nest's community members and will not affect members on The Bump or The Knot.

married by court but want to still plan a wedding ceremony (LONG)

Hi everyone!

I've been married now for 2 1/2 years to my Husband and am loving every moment with him! We did a simple court wedding because my husband and I knew we wouldn't be financially stable till we started our careers (we're currently college students) and we wanted to be married to each other finally. We knew that we wanted to have a big ceremony where we invited all our family and friends but figured we could wait when we were more stable financially.

Recently my good friend got engaged this week (whoohoo!) and I'm happy for her, but seeing her plan her wedding has made me feel sad that I hadn't planned my own wedding like she is. I feel very happy for her but now I want to plan mine. Is it too late to look into doing a wedding ceremony after being married for 2 1/2 years or should I still do it? Anyone gone through this or have advice? Thank you! :-)
«1

Re: married by court but want to still plan a wedding ceremony (LONG)

  • You already had a wedding ceremony.  That was when you said your vows in the courthouse.   It would be silly to have essentially a fake wedding years later because you feel like you missed out on a party. I'd give my friend or family a giant side eye and if they wanted me to come to a 'wedding' years after they were already married.  And probably RSVP no.  If you truly feel like you missed out on something, have a vow renewal at 25 years or something.  (Although I think that's pretty ridiculous too but it's more socially acceptable anyway.)

    Look, I got married in the courthouse.  And I've helped friend's plan weddings.  It's fun for a week and then it becomes an expensive, stressful hell.  I've never once regretted skipping the big wedding.  It's the marriage that's important.  Not what you were wearing and who was there when it started.
    Image and video hosting by TinyPic Lilypie Third Birthday tickers Lilypie Pregnancy tickers
  • I had a court marriage followed by a full-scale wedding, because we had to get married early for immigration reasons. Everyone understood that it wasn't the way we really wanted to do things, so no one had any issues with us having the full wedding 6 months later. However, 6 months is a lot less than 2½ years, and we never really advertised the fact that we were legally married in the meantime (I didn't change my name or anything).

    Why did you need to get married back then?  Insurance? Military deployment? Custody or visitation rights? Since these things aren't fully in your control, your friends and family will probably understand.

    However, if you just got married because you wanted to get married, it seems a bit strange to have a wedding so much later. In that case, maybe you could consider just having a great party to celebrate some other event instead.
    image
  • edited September 2013
    Don't do it.

    And here is why:

    As somebody's pointed out, you and your H already have had a legal ceremony.

    Bear in mind that what you will be planning is NOT a wedding.

    A wedding is an event that legally unifies 2 people who currently are not wed to anybody.

    It also throws a monkey wrench into a religious ceremony, if you are planning on one.  You simply cannott bend a rule in some denominations. (Catholics do covalidation ceremonies but by no means is it for couples who want the big bell and whistle "wedding" when they are already wed.)

    What you would be having is some sort of a vow renewal ---- I can only see the point in vow renewals for couples married for an astonishing amount of years -- maybe a 40th or 50th anniversary.

    I also frown on the whole idea of a "wedding" after a couple's been legally wed.  It seems like an after thought and a draw for attention and a pitch for presents.

    To say that some type of ceremony is a "wedding" when you've already been legally wed is also a breach of etiquette to me.

    Save your money and do something else with the money for the "wedding" when the time comes. Maybe go on a neat trip somewhere or spend it on something the 2 of you have always wanted.

    There is nothing wrong with being married in a courthouse. A friend of mine did that --- after the courthouse ceremony they had a small reception for 30 people at a local restaurant...and I say this is one of the smartest things I've ever seen a couple do. They avoided a financial onslaught and they still got the day they wanted, with the people that mattered the most.
  • Hi everyone! I've been married now for 2 1/2 years to my Husband and am loving every moment with him! We did a simple court wedding because my husband and I knew we wouldn't be financially stable till we started our careers (we're currently college students) and we wanted to be married to each other finally. We knew that we wanted to have a big ceremony where we invited all our family and friends but figured we could wait when we were more stable financially. Recently my good friend got engaged this week (whoohoo!) and I'm happy for her, but seeing her plan her wedding has made me feel sad that I hadn't planned my own wedding like she is. I feel very happy for her but now I want to plan mine. Is it too late to look into doing a wedding ceremony after being married for 2 1/2 years or should I still do it? Anyone gone through this or have advice? Thank you! :-)
    I agree with all the PPs. You had a wedding. Does the dress and the party really mean more to you than being married to your husband? Because that's what you're saying here.
  • GilliC said:

    Why did you need to get married back then?  Insurance? Military deployment? Custody or visitation rights? Since these things aren't fully in your control, your friends and family will probably understand.

    However, if you just got married because you wanted to get married, it seems a bit strange to have a wedding so much later. In that case, maybe you could consider just having a great party to celebrate some other event instead.
    I think this is where I ultimately fall.  In thinking about my good friends - I know that if there was some issue that was out of their control and they got married quickly because of it, but then later (but probably w/in the year) had the full on ceremony/party, I'd gladly participate.

    But if you were just young and got ahead of yourselves and got married because, well, "OH- we just want to be MARRIED" (and I'd bet you probably attached some concept to it of "oh, we're so grown up now!") and then over 2 years later threw a full on wedding - I'd absolutely side-eye it.

    And to quote Kimbus, "It's the marriage that's important.  Not what you were wearing and who was there when it started.".  Repeat this to yourself.  It's the MARRIAGE that matters.  Not the wedding. 
    "Beer is living proof that God loves us and wants us to be happy."
    ~Benjamin Franklin

    Lilypie Third Birthday tickers
    DS dx with celiac disease 5/28/10

  • Wait until you've been married for 5 or 10 years and then have a big vow renewal party!  Same experience, but no one is compelled to give you a gift.  Or just throw a party.  But you cannot have another "wedding."
  • You could host a formal party if you just want to dress up. 
  • i agree with the pp's. There is nothing wrong with a court ceremony. Throwing a "wedding" for the sake of having the party that you didnt originally have is a waste of money, weddings are expensive and stressful.  If you didnt have a honeymoon,  do that instead, Take a nice vacation somewhere,celebrate and enjoy your marriage.
    imageimage
  • As a recent newly wed I say skip the wedding. All that planning while worth it is pointless and you have already been married 2.5 years and as PP said that is what matters. If you want to have a celebration there isn't anything wrong with that but don't expect people to treat it like a wedding. I would wait till 5 years and do a vow renewal if it means that much to you.
    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • Bear in mind that what you will be planning is NOT a wedding.

    A wedding is an event that legally unifies 2 people who currently are not wed to anybody.
    It behooves me to be pedantic, but this simply isn't true.

    The term "wedding" has nothing to do with the legality. In fact, in many countries a legal marriage must be performed at a courthouse, so weddings have absolutely no legal implications at all. Due to the limited schedules of government offices, the legal ceremony may take place days or even months before the wedding.

    Full Definition of WEDDING

    1
    :  a marriage ceremony usually with its accompanying festivities :  nuptials
    2
    :  an act, process, or instance of joining in close association
    3
    :  a wedding anniversary or its celebration —usually used in combination <a golden wedding>
    image
  • If I were invited to a wedding 2.5 years after the original vows were taken, I would think "Oh, they want a GIFT!"
  • GilliC said:

    I had a court marriage followed by a full-scale wedding, because we had to get married early for immigration reasons. Everyone understood that it wasn't the way we really wanted to do things, so no one had any issues with us having the full wedding 6 months later. However, 6 months is a lot less than 2½ years, and we never really advertised the fact that we were legally married in the meantime (I didn't change my name or anything).


    Why did you need to get married back then?  Insurance? Military deployment? Custody or visitation rights? Since these things aren't fully in your control, your friends and family will probably understand.

    However, if you just got married because you wanted to get married, it seems a bit strange to have a wedding so much later. In that case, maybe you could consider just having a great party to celebrate some other event instead.
    My husband is an immigrant and he needed to get his papers processed faster (he was going thru his parents legal status) and since we both loved each other and knew we wanted to be together for the rest of our lives we decided to get married by court. We couldn't spend money on a wedding because his papers were going to cost a lot but we told each other that we can always have one when we are more financially stabled. I understand why you would think everyone would see it as "attention" for everyone to be there and "gifts" but honestly its because I was living 9 hours away from family and friends who couldn't be there for a court wedding. I wanted to wait. I know time has passed a while now but I would like to hold a celebration for our marriage and have everyone who is important to me that didn't go to our original court wedding to our celebration at least.
  • I have to sort of disagree (sort of) with some of the posters.

    I think that yes, it's true, you had a wedding. I wouldn't plan a WEDDING, but I think if you and your husband decide that you have the resources to plan a party, or celebration and that is something that you two would really like to experience then go for it.

    I also REALLY disagree with people who are saying others will think it's for attention. Yeah, maybe some will - but this is about the two of you. People who really love you guys and support your marriage, and those who really know you (hopefully) won't think that.

    Weddings are too much about other people, and not enough about you - so if it's something you're both needing to really celebrate and make your marriage official - then do it! Invite those who could not come, rent a nice venue and have a party!

    That being said, I do like what was said about possibly waiting until you've been married for say 5 years, and then doing a commitment ceremony type thing!

    If it's important to you, you should do it before you have kids and all the rest!
  • My DH had an allergic reaction right after our ceremony and had to go to the ER. We essentially missed our entire reception. But, I never looked at it like I "missed out on something". Stuff happens, it's out of our control, and at the end of the day... we got married. That's the important part. 

    The stress of planning a wedding was just that, a lot of stress! If I had to do it all over again, I'd elope in Hawaii.

    I've already told DH that for our 5th anniversary I want to go back to Hawaii and renew vows. That  would be my same suggestion to you. Renew your vows at 5 years, and go to a nice dinner with your loved ones. There is truly no point in having a huge hooplah celebration right now. 2.5 years is a long time to wait to throw a wedding. You're closer to the 5 year anniversary mark now anyways. Just wait it out. 
  • Honestly, I would put whatever money that would have gone towards a wedding to a nice vacation, just the two of you.

    Or possibly take your nearest and dearest to a nice restaurant to celebrate your anniversary ?  Having a wedding and reception so long after just seems silly. 

  • Sorry Madisonghope, but attention is exactly what a fake wedding is about. If it were truly just about the two of them, they'd be happy with the fact that they're already married and have been for 2.5 years now. OP, that sucks that you now regret not having the big fancy party. But it's done now, and you would look like an idiot having a fake do-over "wedding".
    Lilypie Kids Birthday tickers Lilypie Second Birthday tickers
  • And a vow renewal (or whatever) at 5 years is pretty lame and stupid too. I mean, you want a cookie for making it to 5 years?
    Lilypie Kids Birthday tickers Lilypie Second Birthday tickers
  • Maybride2 said:

    Sorry Madisonghope, but attention is exactly what a fake wedding is about. If it were truly just about the two of them, they'd be happy with the fact that they're already married and have been for 2.5 years now.

    OP, that sucks that you now regret not having the big fancy party. But it's done now, and you would look like an idiot having a fake do-over "wedding".

    You seem very harsh on the idea of celebrating with others but that's your opinion and I respect that. I only regret not being able to have the finances and time to do a celebration for my husband and I and for everyone to share our joy together. I really like the idea of doing a 5 year anniversary celebration as a way to have our friends be there when they couldn't before. Plus, I wouldn't dream of having friends feel "obligated" to bring presents as a reason for our celebration, I'm not selfish in that way and appreciate the company more than anything.
  • I have to sort of disagree (sort of) with some of the posters.

    I think that yes, it's true, you had a wedding. I wouldn't plan a WEDDING, but I think if you and your husband decide that you have the resources to plan a party, or celebration and that is something that you two would really like to experience then go for it.

    I also REALLY disagree with people who are saying others will think it's for attention. Yeah, maybe some will - but this is about the two of you. People who really love you guys and support your marriage, and those who really know you (hopefully) won't think that.

    Weddings are too much about other people, and not enough about you - so if it's something you're both needing to really celebrate and make your marriage official - then do it! Invite those who could not come, rent a nice venue and have a party!

    That being said, I do like what was said about possibly waiting until you've been married for say 5 years, and then doing a commitment ceremony type thing!

    If it's important to you, you should do it before you have kids and all the rest!

    I appreciate you being on the positive side of me wanting to celebrate with others and I might consider that 5 year mark for us to have everyone get together and celebrate with us. Thank you!
  • Maybride2Maybride2 member
    Ancient Membership 5000 Comments 100 Love Its Combo Breaker
    edited September 2013
    No, I'm not "harsh" on the idea of celebrating with others. I waited until I was a grown up to get married, and in doing so we could afford to have the big fancy party (which I thoroughly enjoyed). To make this a little more simple - it doesn't matter if you wouldn't want to make people feel obligated to bring gifts, or to come off like an AW......that's what it's going to look like, to most everyone. Especially people older than you are (which sounds like most people). A 5 year celebration is going to come off as incredibly AWish and narcissistic, not to mention silly. You asked for opinions.
    Lilypie Kids Birthday tickers Lilypie Second Birthday tickers
  • I think it depends what you mean by a wedding. If you mean big white dress, fancy dinner and dance and speeches, I think you missed the boat on that one, and there would be no way to do it without it seeming like a huge money/gift/attention grab. If, on the other hand, you're talking about throwing something modest at your house, with snacks and drinks and a small, intimate guest list, and no white dress, then sure. But either way, I think you might be obsessing over the "wedding" concept. You can celebrate with your family all the time now, as a married couple. Do you really need everyone to get together for the sole purpose of celebrating your relationship? And is there really any way of pulling that off without seeming selfish and like you need attention? (Sorry, not trying to be harsh, I just don't see how you could do it without it seeming really forced and awkward for your guests.) And P.S. I hated planning my wedding, and the day was not worth the stress (aside from being married.) Lots of people don't get the day they wanted, even if they have the big wedding. You get over it and appreciate that at the end of the day, you achieved the main goal - marrying your husband.
  • I had a court marriage followed by a full-scale wedding, because we had to get married early for immigration reasons. Everyone understood that it wasn't the way we really wanted to do things, so no one had any issues with us having the full wedding 6 months later. However, 6 months is a lot less than 2½ years, and we never really advertised the fact that we were legally married in the meantime (I didn't change my name or anything).

    Why did you need to get married back then?  Insurance? Military deployment? Custody or visitation rights? Since these things aren't fully in your control, your friends and family will probably understand.

    However, if you just got married because you wanted to get married, it seems a bit strange to have a wedding so much later. In that case, maybe you could consider just having a great party to celebrate some other event instead.
    My husband is an immigrant and he needed to get his papers processed faster (he was going thru his parents legal status) and since we both loved each other and knew we wanted to be together for the rest of our lives we decided to get married by court. We couldn't spend money on a wedding because his papers were going to cost a lot but we told each other that we can always have one when we are more financially stabled. I understand why you would think everyone would see it as "attention" for everyone to be there and "gifts" but honestly its because I was living 9 hours away from family and friends who couldn't be there for a court wedding. I wanted to wait. I know time has passed a while now but I would like to hold a celebration for our marriage and have everyone who is important to me that didn't go to our original court wedding to our celebration at least.
    I'm confused. Did you do the legal married for the immigration paperwork? Because you say that he was applying under his parent's status. So was the marriage related to the immigration issues or not?

    I admire your decision to not put yourselves into debt over a wedding when you had immigration fees to deal with, but if the marriage wasn't related to the paperwork, why didn't you just wait until you could save up for the wedding you wanted? There are plenty of people who have long engagements, because they know they want a wedding, so they're waiting until they can pay for it.

    But then, I don't really buy into the concept of "We got married because we love each other and want to spend the rest of our lives together." There is nothing stopping two people who love each other from spending the rest of their lives together. A legal document doesn't change that. Making a public commitment doesn't change that. If two people want to be together, they can be together. The reasons to get married are predominantly legal, financial, or religious.

    What kind of status was your H applying for? If he doesn't have and is considering citizenship, maybe you two can throw a huge party for that.
    image
  • artbyallieartbyallie member
    500 Comments Fourth Anniversary 100 Love Its First Answer
    edited September 2013
    GilliC said:
    Bear in mind that what you will be planning is NOT a wedding.

    A wedding is an event that legally unifies 2 people who currently are not wed to anybody.
    It behooves me to be pedantic, but this simply isn't true.

    The term "wedding" has nothing to do with the legality. In fact, in many countries a legal marriage must be performed at a courthouse, so weddings have absolutely no legal implications at all. Due to the limited schedules of government offices, the legal ceremony may take place days or even months before the wedding.

    Full Definition of WEDDING

    1
    :  a marriage ceremony usually with its accompanying festivities :  nuptials
    2
    :  an act, process, or instance of joining in close association
    3
    :  a wedding anniversary or its celebration —usually used in combination <a golden wedding>
    Presumably you are not in one of the countries where that is a requirement, however. Here in the U.S., church ceremonies are every bit as legally binding as courthouse ones, so your argument falls rather flat.
  • We got married in court for his dad (who was sick and passed shortly after) and then wedding ceremony/reception 9 months later. We were already in middle of wedding planning when his dad got sick so we decided to do court wedding with just our parents present. If there was a good reason for you getting married legally 2.5 yrs ago (situation like mine or deployment, immigration reasons) then I don't see anything wrong with planning a dinner or reception now.
  • Maybride2 said:
    No, I'm not "harsh" on the idea of celebrating with others. I waited until I was a grown up to get married, and in doing so we could afford to have the big fancy party (which I thoroughly enjoyed). To make this a little more simple - it doesn't matter if you wouldn't want to make people feel obligated to bring gifts, or to come off like an AW......that's what it's going to look like, to most everyone. Especially people older than you are (which sounds like most people). A 5 year celebration is going to come off as incredibly AWish and narcissistic, not to mention silly. You asked for opinions.

      image

    Wow!  Who shit in your cheerios this morning?

    @michaela89 I would suggest not inviting Maybride to your 5 year vow renewal!


     

  • I'm just going ot say that while you're getting upset w/ people being "harsh", you have to realize that we - total strangers - are only saying out loud what some of your family and friends will probably say to themselves.

    Yes, SOME people will think nothing of it.  But SOME will roll their eyes.  They'll come, put a smile on, and have fun - but some of the people absolutely WILL think that you're doing it for the attention.  They are just too polite to say it out loud. 

    I know it's cynical, but I really don't see why you need to have other people celebrate your relationship - and especially at only 5 years along.
    "Beer is living proof that God loves us and wants us to be happy."
    ~Benjamin Franklin

    Lilypie Third Birthday tickers
    DS dx with celiac disease 5/28/10

  • Oh, and I hate the argument of "the people who really love you".  I can really love someone but STILL side-eye them if they are being AWs! 
    "Beer is living proof that God loves us and wants us to be happy."
    ~Benjamin Franklin

    Lilypie Third Birthday tickers
    DS dx with celiac disease 5/28/10

  • No one shit in my Cheerios.  I'm just being honest..........and honestly, I'm being rather nice with my honesty. I'm guessing you weren't around in the Nest's heyday.

    No, please don't invite me to a 5 year vow renewal. Unless you have a different type of marriage where your vows actually expire after 5 years, I really think it's silly and premature to have a big celebration for such a short time being married. 

    OP can do whatever she wants, and if she and her husband want to throw themselves a pretend wedding there is nothing stopping them.  She asked for opinions, and she's getting them - blunt, honest opinions that surely other people in her life will no doubt have, but might be too nice to share with her. 

    I was 9 months pregnant when I graduated grad school.  I didn't have a big party or anything to celebrate my graduation.  Maybe now, 6 years later, I should throw myself a graduation party.  You know, because those people that truly love me will of course want to come celebrate my grad school graduation and pretend like it just happened.  Oh, but I don't want gifts or attention, I just want to celebrate my degree!!!!!! 

    Lilypie Kids Birthday tickers Lilypie Second Birthday tickers
  • Disneygeek77Disneygeek77 member
    Ancient Membership 2500 Comments 500 Love Its First Answer
    edited September 2013
    Ha ha. I never had a sweet 16 party. Maybe I should have one 19 years later.

    Look, some people don't get weddings , just like some people don't get  bridal / baby showers , or engagement parties, or sweet 16 parties , or quineaneras , or bar mitzvahs. It's just the way it is sometimes. Sure it is sad, but it happens. Put your money towards something better.
  • edited September 2013
    You have the wedding you can afford.

    That's the bottom line.

    Stop watching TV and stop keeping up with the Joneses.

    There is a woman that a friend of mine works with --- the coworker decided, at age 57 and 2 teenage kids later, to have a full out bells and whistles "marriage ceremony" followed by a huge reception for 200.

    She went the full 9 yards with a white gown and veil and bridesmaids --- and somebody even gave her a wedding shower.  THat to me is a breech of etiquette; you're married, why do you want a shower? 

    (And if you are going to have one, let it be with all gag gifts or something that the guest brings that can be donated to a charity.  What does a couple with a home and 2 kids and everything they need -- they go on a fancy trip each year -- want with a shower?)

    The day of the festivities, it rained....

    And how.... all day long. All night long. And clear through the weekend.

    Torrential rain up the wazoo -- and the reception was in an area of the state that was way off the beaten path and not well lit at night. Must have been horrrible for the guests trying to find their way to that reception.

    Silly to have a ceremony and a reception that many years later.   And silly to have one at all, after you've already been wed, in a courthouse or whereever.

    Don't do it.

    You guys are still getting on your financial feet --- save your money.

    In 5 years when you've got a pretty good penny saved, do something else, like I said.  Maybe even get a fabulous ring that you can eventually pass on to a daughter.:)
Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards