Holidays
Dear Community,

Our tech team has launched updates to The Nest today. As a result of these updates, members of the Nest Community will need to change their password in order to continue participating in the community. In addition, The Nest community member's avatars will be replaced with generic default avatars. If you wish to revert to your original avatar, you will need to re-upload it via The Nest.

If you have questions about this, please email help@theknot.com.

Thank you.

Note: This only affects The Nest's community members and will not affect members on The Bump or The Knot.

Husband did not give a gift - has this happened to anyone?

2»

Re: Husband did not give a gift - has this happened to anyone?

  • imagefoundmydr1:
     am not going to jump down your throat.  Giving presents to the ones that you love at Christmas are a standard tradition within the US and many cultures around the world.  It is the ESTABLISHED PRACTICE for American Relationships that are AN EXPRESSION OF LOVE (rightly or wrongly).

    Her Husband did not discuss his decision to go against the norm without talking to her.  THAT PART was wrong.  You discuss major decisions with each other.  Especially when your action is something that could possibley be concieved as hurtful. 

    Now, there is absolutely NOTHING wrong with wanting to cut costs.  And if he had gone to her about this to begin with (which would have stopped her from buying HER gifts for him.....but he seemed to be happy recieving those.....) and she still complained, then yes she woudl be greedy.

    But just NOT telling her what was on his mind (bad communication) and not doing something that 95% other husbands do for their wives do, is just a bit hurtful.

     

    THIS. EXACTLY.

    I'm ashamed to witness the lack of empathy on a HOLIDAYS board.  And I call bullsh*t on those who think they wouldn't be hurt on (any, let alone) a first Christmas when money was spent on gifts for cousins but nary a card or poem or anything was thought of for his new bride.  If his cousins had any class or grace they would tell him that for them, its the thought that counts and he should have saved some money on their gifts to give her something, anything.

     

     

    I think on some of these boards, someone says something mean to another (such as what happened here) and the next person is eager to jump on the Mean Girls bandwagon. I don't get people like that. Like ooh...we're so tough, this one's a whiner, or a sissy. Let's see their Hs don't give them anything on a special occassion, but bothers to give even the coworkers little somethings, and not tell them why he didn't get her anything. I wonder how they'll feel if it happened to them.

  • imagefoundmydr1:
     am not going to jump down your throat.  Giving presents to the ones that you love at Christmas are a standard tradition within the US and many cultures around the world.  It is the ESTABLISHED PRACTICE for American Relationships that are AN EXPRESSION OF LOVE (rightly or wrongly).

    Her Husband did not discuss his decision to go against the norm without talking to her.  THAT PART was wrong.  You discuss major decisions with each other.  Especially when your action is something that could possibley be concieved as hurtful. 

    Now, there is absolutely NOTHING wrong with wanting to cut costs.  And if he had gone to her about this to begin with (which would have stopped her from buying HER gifts for him.....but he seemed to be happy recieving those.....) and she still complained, then yes she woudl be greedy.

    But just NOT telling her what was on his mind (bad communication) and not doing something that 95% other husbands do for their wives do, is just a bit hurtful.

     

    THIS. EXACTLY.

    I'm ashamed to witness the lack of empathy on a HOLIDAYS board.  And I call bullsh*t on those who think they wouldn't be hurt on (any, let alone) a first Christmas when money was spent on gifts for cousins but nary a card or poem or anything was thought of for his new bride.  If his cousins had any class or grace they would tell him that for them, its the thought that counts and he should have saved some money on their gifts to give her something, anything.

     

     

     

    This. Gifts don't need to cost money- when my DH was "just a friend" he wrote me a sweet poem.

    epic fail photos - Legitimate Business FAIL
    see more funny videos, and check out our Yo Dawg lols!
  • MrsTravis52- exactly. Which is why I included that as an option. You know I think I'd rather get a poem than some gifts others might beg for- what a great thing to treasure and share with your children.
  • While your post does seem a little immature and greedy, I can understand where you are coming from.  Yes, you need to take into consideration that he was not mobile because of his surgery and that money was tight, but he could have at least acknowledged Christmas with a card, or SOMETHING special for you.  And if he knew he couldn't do that, he should have communicated to you that you should hold off because he won't be able to get you something.  

     

  • I would be disappointed too.  Nothing seems strange... I guess even if we were really struggling financially, I would have made a card for DH, and maybe a favorite batch of cookies. 

    The core of the issue seems to be that there really should have been better communication. 

     

    I would drop the issue for now and then next year in November ask if he would like to exchange gifts, or do something special as a couple.  I could see DH and I giving up a wrapped gift exchange to go see a play or have a weekend get-away. 

    Wedding Countdown Ticker
  • Sorry people are jumping down your throat a little. I mean he was recovering and not working and had some medical bills so I understand why he didn't get you something but it probably should have been discussed. Each year before xmas my husband and I have a discussion on gift limits and what we will spend. If we ever decide not to buy each other gifts it would be discussed for the very reason that when you give him and gift and get nothing back it does hurt a little. During the first year of our marriage it was my birthday and the night before I was like to my husband (who's bday was a month before and I got him a small gift, made him a cake, etc..) can I open my gift early? And he was like what gift, I didn't get you one. So I was like ok well then are we doing something, going somewhere...is there at least a card? Nope. I was pretty pissed. His response was no where near as good as your hubbys, he was like oh we are married I didn't think we had to do gifts. He knows better now.
  • imagecirclebar1967:
    Thank you (llumine) for not jumping down my throat like everyone else did! AND you totally understood what I was trying to say! Giving presents at Christmas is a standard tradition and a time that 95% husbands do give their wives presents and if my husband had discussed the decision with me I would have been fine with it, but there were a few times gifts were mentioned and he not once said, "I don't think we should give gifts this year". The gift did not have to be expensive, he didn't even have to BUY one, a poem that he had written (which he happens to be good at), coupons for a massage or dinner when he was better, etc. And for the nosy one about my finances, yes I work and make a resonably good salary for our area. I have spent the last 10 years of my life taking care of a handicapped brother and elderly mom that my dad ran off from to be with another woman and that has drained me severely financially and I still have financial obligations to them, that is why the income is not "ours". He pays our bills and I continue to pay my family's bills but I do contribute to our household expenses some, I am not that greedy as some of you implied! And to those of you that think I need to grow up - I just got on here to ask a question and see if anybody had experienced it and how they handled it - I had no idea that I would receive such rude responses!! I will not be asking another question on these discussion boards!

     

    Wow, the comments on this thread are just appalling. This is the exact reason I stopped posting on this website, everyone is just so rude, you all just look for any reason to jump down someone's throat and attack them. Most people come here looking for a place to vent, or a place to get some anonymous advice, and everyone on here makes that VERY difficult. You don't know the op, you don't know anything about them except exactly what they tell you, but you like to act like you do and you like to criticize the SMALL amount of information that you have. You take advantage of being an anonymous random person on the internet, and you use it against people. I strongly urge each and every one of you to take a step back and look and the way you talk to people online. Look at what you just said on this thread... would you say that to a close friend or family member? Have some compassion and understanding, give a little respect, and for god sake, act like a decent human being, geeze.

    Anyway, in reply to the OP, I totally understand your situation. I mean, it's one thing if your grandma or your uncle doesn't get you a gift, but your HUSBAND? There really is no excuse for that. It doesn't even have to be expensive. If you don't have the money, do something sweet, like framing a photo of a special memory or writing a love letter. I really don't see how that is selfish. I LOVE buying people gifts, but I would be lying if I said I wouldn't be disappointed if my husband didn't get me anything at all. I think you should just talk to your husband about how you feel and hope that it changes next year.

  • to the OP-- You are not being greedy, selfish, or childlish.  Like PPs have said, your husband definatly should have talked to you about it so that you weren't expecting something.  In his defense he could have been embarrassed about the situation and it was just easier to avoid the conversation and to assume you'd understand.  We all know where ASSuming gets us. 

     A card, love note, or photo would have been nice. I am sorry that you have this hurt --definatly talk to him rather than have your hurt turn to anger.

     
  • to the OP-- You are not being greedy, selfish, or childlish.  Like PPs have said, your husband definatly should have talked to you about it so that you weren't expecting something.  In his defense he could have been embarrassed about the situation and it was just easier to avoid the conversation and to assume you'd understand.  We all know where ASSuming gets us. 

     A card, love note, or photo would have been nice. I am sorry that you have this hurt --definatly talk to him rather than have your hurt turn to anger.

      
  • lurker coming around..

    OP-did it ever occur to you to talk to your husband about gift giving for christmas, instead of assuming that he was planning on getting you a gift?

    i understand you being upset by the fact that there was no gift for you. but it was something that should have been discussed prior to christmas, probably even prior to his surgery, so that you both knew what each other's expectations were. DH & i don't always do gifts, but we always talk about it beforehand so we know.

    also, i think you need to realize that this is a classic case of a husband feeling that he is showing how much he cares by providing for his family. and his wife's family, as well. my guess is he felt that he was already going above & beyond by providing for you and everyone else.

    being in a marriage means effectively communicating, rather than assuming, pouting when you don't get your way and stomping your feet like a child when people don't give you the sympathy you're looking for. from now on you should consider actually talking with your husband and setting expectations.

    oh. and did i miss the part where you fill us in on what you bought your husband for christmas? i'm curious.

    Thanks to our wonderful RE our family is complete!
    DS #1 10.12.12
    DS #2 10.24.14

    image
    image
Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards