CP- circumcision

blueeyedblossom · November 2013

Will you circumcise?

MadeOfAwesome · November 2013

Yes, I did.

PandPMeant2B · November 2013

This was a really heated discussion on another message board I'm on. I was surprised to see that the majority were completely against it.

MadeOfAwesome · November 2013

The circumcision debate ALWAYS gets heated. People feel really strongly about it, one way or the other

LooneyLife · November 2013

I don't have a strong opinion either way, but yeah, we'd do it.

LuckyAngel07 · November 2013

I think we'd probably do it. DH is circumcised, so I don't see why not.

LittleLady77 · November 2013

I don't have a strong opinion either way but if the decision was totally mine I probably wouldn't do it. Hubby, however, strongly believes we should do it- so we will. No biggie for me... I don't have a penis. This is kind of his thing to decide.

botanicalbliss · November 2013

I am strongly against it. I see no reason to do it. Nature put it there for a reason and the reasons to do it don't outweigh the reasons not to do it for me.

lfk2013 · November 2013

I don't think we'd do it if the time came. I don't think it would be my call, though, since I don't have one. I think DH would have to decide that one.

lilliesandvino · November 2013

I don't know enough about it to make an informed decision yet.

cloudymeatballs · November 2013

I'm pretty sure we would do it. My H is circumcised and it would mostly be his decision too, since I have a vag, not a wiener. His call.

sparklingdiamond · November 2013

We likely would, but I would leave the decision up to DH.

PandPMeant2B · November 2013

I don't feel strongly either way, but I don't understand the "I don't have those parts so I'll leave it up to DH" POV. Having the same sex organs doesn't automatically make someone smarter or more educated on a certain topic.

arj14 · November 2013

I haven't discussed this with DH, but I'm more inclined not to do it.

brij2006 · November 2013

This would be left up to H, but I can't stand that my insurance doesn't cover it. It's considered an "option" to them, so they will not cover the procedure at all.

BruinsBabe33 · November 2013

@pandpmeant2b I left the decision up to Alan because he has a penis and odds are MT will see it and Alan would have to answers questions about it. We discussed it a lot and didn't go into it without doing our own research and weighing the pros and cons. If I had been strongly for or against it he would have taken my opinion seriously it wasn't just his decision.

PandPMeant2B · November 2013

@BruinsBabe33, sounds like you and Alan made an informed decision together; you did your research, which is my point. Sure, DH is likely to feel more strongly about something like this and that should be taken into consideration, but I would never say, "You have the right plumbing; you decide!" Maybe not everyone means it so literally, but I have heard women say that and mean it before. I just can't imagine leaving a decision like that up to one parent just because they have the right bits.

Aimothy · November 2013

I guess I just assumed that those ladies who said, "my H has the peen, he'll decide" would also have taken time to have the same discussion as bruins. But then again, maybe I'm just assuming too much about the ladies here .

I have no strong feelings either way, but we will be circumcising if we ever have the need to be able to do it.

BruinsBabe33 · November 2013

I thought so, too @aimothy .

PandPMeant2B · November 2013

Aimothy said:

I guess I just assumed that those ladies who said, "my H has the peen, he'll decide" would also have taken time to have the same discussion as bruins. But then again, maybe I'm just assuming too much about the ladies here.

You would hope that (I would too), but I've literally heard women say they want nothing to do with the decision because it should default to the male, just because he has a peen and they don't know anything about it (so they think having a unit gives them magical knowledge on the topic and are obviously too lazy to do some research). I hope I didn't insult anyone with what I said.

BruinsBabe33 · November 2013

brij2006 said:
This would be left up to H, but I can't stand that my insurance doesn't cover it. It's considered an "option" to them, so they will not cover the procedure at all.

Well, it is an elective procedure. A lot of insurances don't cover it unless there is a medical need.

cloudymeatballs · November 2013

Of course we will discuss this. Just saying, lol

sparklingdiamond · November 2013

BruinsBabe33 said:

@pandpmeant2b I left the decision up to Alan because he has a penis and odds are MT will see it and Alan would have to answers questions about it. We discussed it a lot and didn't go into it without doing our own research and weighing the pros and cons. If I had been strongly for or against it he would have taken my opinion seriously it wasn't just his decision.

This is how I feel. When I say it's up to DH, obviously I am putting in my input too. Just that ultimately, he might have a stronger opinion on it than me.

amandaf6383 · November 2013

We will circumcise if it ever comes to it.

pinotgirl · November 2013

I wasn't planning on it, however DS has something called hypospadia so they needed the skin in order to repair the problem. So he's circumsized. If we had another boy, I guess I would do it since DS already is.

GoodWolf · November 2013

Fun fact: DH was born without a foreskin. When this discussion came up, he said, "Well I don't remember any pain of being circumcised, so why would our son?". To which I had to remind him, he was never actually circumcised....

I think we will though. Just a personal choice. I think it is everyone's prerogative to make their individual decision.

LuckyAngel07 · November 2013

GoodWolf said: Fun fact: DH was born without a foreskin. When this discussion came up, he said, "Well I don't remember any pain of being circumcised, so why would our son?".
LOL! Even if he had been circumcised, unless you're waiting until the boy is older for religious/ceremonial reasons, most boys are circumcised in infancy. Of course they're not going to remember it!

CincodeMayoLove · November 2013

Up to H. We have had a discussion and he's on the fence. I am kind of leaning towards no, but again, I dont want the final say on this one. There are pros and cons to both, so we will see when we get there and continue to inform ourselves in the meantime

Apollo11235 · November 2013

We'll have to talk about it some more once we're closer to deciding. I say no, but I mentioned this to DH and his response was along the lines of, "WTF, ew!"

lb1117 · November 2013

I did some research and talked to DH about it. I felt like I could go either way on it. R feels strongly about doing it, even though the cost is OOP, so that's what we are planning to do.

callitcompulsive · November 2013

I waffle back and forth on the topic.

I tend to lean towards not doing it, and H really doesn't care. I guess we'll figure it out when the need arises. (lol, everyone loves a penis pun, right?)

CP- circumcision

CP- circumcision 81 votes

Re: CP- circumcision

Choose Another Board

Search Boards