Married Life
Dear Community,

Our tech team has launched updates to The Nest today. As a result of these updates, members of the Nest Community will need to change their password in order to continue participating in the community. In addition, The Nest community member's avatars will be replaced with generic default avatars. If you wish to revert to your original avatar, you will need to re-upload it via The Nest.

If you have questions about this, please email help@theknot.com.

Thank you.

Note: This only affects The Nest's community members and will not affect members on The Bump or The Knot.

Getting married young...

13»

Re: Getting married young...

  • schuette2 said:
    I find it funny this board is all about statistics yet they seem to ignore the ones about living together. I can't even tell you how many times I have seen people here tell couples they should live together before marriage, yet statistics show that couples who do so have a higher divorce rate. Yes it is true getting married young can lead to divorce but is it the cause? No especially in a day in age when over half of all marriages are ending anyway. It really has nothing to do with age in my opinion it has everything to do with the people. They say that if you can get past year 7 you are pretty well good to go because years 5-7 are the highest for divorce at any age. 

    I was never suggesting everyone go around telling young people to get married. But if someone has decided it is for them I think it is wrong for someone to talk them out of it based on age alone. It's not fair to stereotype like that. 

    Ha! Yes! Where have you seen these statistics, I'd like to have a look. DH thought we should move in before we got married, but I told him no, and here's why:
    All my aunts and uncles - and a few cousins - lived together before they got married. Each one of them has gotten divorced. My parents and grandparents did not live together prior to marriage, and they're still going strong. Poo poo me if you want, but that's not a coincidence in my eyes. 
    Correlation =/= causation.
    as a researcher I agree. there is definitely a high probability that there is some confounding in those data. 1. a high percentage of people co-habitate before marriage 2. divorce rates are high. so it's likely that a high percent of divorced people co-habitated before marriage.

    from what I can tell the CDC doesn't stratify divorce statistics by cohabitation. they report data for marriages and cohabitation separately. (fyi unmarried cohabitants are about twice as likely to break-up than their married counterparts at any given time). 

    Factors the CDC found to play an important role were; Age at the beginning of marriage, marital status of parents, SES, male unemployment rate, among a few others...pre-marital cohabitation was not listed on their list of significant corelations.


    Me: 28 H: 30
    Married 07/14/2012
    TTC #1 January 2015
    BFP! 3/27/15 Baby Girl!! EDD:12/7/2015
  • It doesn't matter how old you were when you got married, whether you lived together or not, etc.

    If you feel that you have to justify your life choices to a message board full of strangers, it suggests that you have your own doubts.
    image
  • Adding my own two cents, I quiet honestly believe that either way doesn't truly matter. What matters is knowing who your SO is before getting married. Some people can know their SO well enough to know what they are committing themselves to, flaws and all, before marriage without living together. Some people still are blind to things their SO does even when they live together.Yes your morals come into play and we are all very diverse on our views there, but you need to know who your SO. (Plus being financially stable and so forth.)

    Example: if he's punching down doors before your married that wont stop just cause there's a ring on his finger. Marriage isn't the magical bandage. Much like a baby isn't a magical bandage. Both will really put your relationship through the ringer.
    image
    imageimage
  • Sillygirl45Sillygirl45 member
    500 Comments 250 Love Its First Anniversary Name Dropper
    edited April 2014
    Adding my own two cents, I quiet honestly believe that either way doesn't truly matter. What matters is knowing who your SO is before getting married. Some people can know their SO well enough to know what they are committing themselves to, flaws and all, before marriage without living together. Some people still are blind to things their SO does even when they live together.Yes your morals come into play and we are all very diverse on our views there, but you need to know who your SO. (Plus being financially stable and so forth.)

    Example: if he's punching down doors before your married that wont stop just cause there's a ring on his finger. Marriage isn't the magical bandage. Much like a baby isn't a magical bandage. Both will really put your relationship through the ringer.
    I think @Lilyrose4242 hit the nail on the head here. 

    She has mentioned in her posts (and not made a huge deal of it) that she is a young bride who married her first love. I think that's great. I really do. I don't think it's for everyone, but for someone who has the insight and maturity to make it work...fantastic! 

    The issue is, as other posters have said, if you need an anonymous message board to legitimize your marriage...it's likely you have an issue. If you come here for advice and your issue is tied to getting married young...to someone who doesn't respect you because of immaturity...yep, you're going to get honest opinions.

    It's not about getting married young, it's about why you need to pose the question.
  • Ok, I also was always called "very mature" and an "old soul", and "went through a lot".  Blah blah blah.  That doesn't mean that my growth as a person and changes to who I am were all done before I hit 25.  Heck, I am STILL growing and changing. 

    Hopefully, as you grow and change your spouse will also grow and change WITH you in a way that you will have a long and happy marriage.  This is the same hope I continue to have in my own marriage, and we're in our forties.  Yep, still growing and changing, both of us.

    IGNORING that as a young couple you face some additional obstacles as you are entering a phase of your life where you will experience MAJOR change is not going to help you.  Burying your head in the sand about this could be to your peril. 

    Thinking that your life experiences were just SO much more daunting than everyone else's  and therefore that prepares you for marriage, is also so way off. 

    Going through tough times growing up is not an indicator of future marital success.  Unfortunately, tough childhoods can spill over into adulthood as "issues" to be dealt with.  Folks with "issues" face additional challenges when in relationships.  Kids from tough homes aren't set up for better marital success. 

    Basically, every argument made by the OP defending young marriage doesn't help the case. People get married at all different ages and some work and some don't.  More people who marry young fail in their marriages.  For LOTS of reasons.  And I hope the OP isn't one of them.  But I wouldn't judge the likelihood of success or failure of their union based on ANYTHING she has posted here.  Honestly, unfortunately, several of the comments raise red flags.

    I wish success to all the folks here, whether they married young or old.  A successful marriage is fulfilling, and certainly age is only one indicator, and anyone can beat or lose the odds.

     

    Lilypie Pregnancy tickers
    DMoney will be a kickass big sister
    Lilypie - Personal pictureLilypie Third Birthday tickers
    image
  • Maybe not, but it seems a pretty strong coincidence. I don't know why they all divorced, as they all did so either before I came along or shortly thereafter and was never told the story or didn't care. 
  • Hi All,
    I have been married for almost 2 years now. I got married at the age of 17. I am still be-littled everyday. I get it all the time "why so young?" well yes, I was pregnant at the time but now we are so happy. We have had our ups and downs just like any relationship. But some how, we always find the love again and things go great. I am proud to say that we have a successful marriage, great jobs, a nice apartment, and a very smart little boy who we both adore. I hope everyone thinks before they judge. Those who judge must not been happy in their own relationship and try to make us who are happy second guess ourselves. 
  • I was 21 when i got married. he was 22.  Even in the last 4 months of marriage, I've grown and changed.  I'm constantly developing as a person.

    Our relationship isn't bad by any means and we're really happy.  But who I am....is always evolving.  
  • SydsWed01 said:
    Hi All,
    I have been married for almost 2 years now. I got married at the age of 17. I am still be-littled everyday. I get it all the time "why so young?" well yes, I was pregnant at the time but now we are so happy. We have had our ups and downs just like any relationship. But some how, we always find the love again and things go great. I am proud to say that we have a successful marriage, great jobs, a nice apartment, and a very smart little boy who we both adore. I hope everyone thinks before they judge. Those who judge must not been happy in their own relationship and try to make us who are happy second guess ourselves. 
    Not everyone who judges is unhappy.  Some people who judge are just more experienced and have more self awareness and realize that what is and who you are now is not always what will be in twenty years, or even in 5 years.

    I was pretty young when I got married.  23.  I'm 9 years in and we're happy.  But I look back and go "Holy Shit. I was such a baby. I can't believe we didn't fuck it up.  We're really lucky."  I'd never recommend to anyone to get married that young.  I don't regret doing it but I realize we're the exception, not the rule.  And like anyone else, I have absolutely no idea what the future will bring.
    Image and video hosting by TinyPic Lilypie Third Birthday tickers Lilypie Pregnancy tickers
  • I felt shunned and judged when I first came here as well, so I have hesitated to post anything in the community.  Wish more people were kind and lifted women up instead of passing judgement on them.  
  • Kimbus22 said:
    Yep. Plus people who don't believe in living together before marriage are also less likely to believe in divorce as an option and more likely to stay in a crappy marriage.  Just because you stay married 50 years doesn't necessarily mean you're in a good marriage.  Just like getting divorced after 10 years doesn't necessarily mean you had a bad one.
    I'd also like to point out that just because a marriage ultimately ends in divorce doesn't necessarily mean the couple never should have married in the first place.  There was a segment on the Daily Show last week about a couple who were finally, after several years, granted a divorce, even though the State of Texas didn't officially recognize their marriage, on account of them being a same-sex couple.  So why the importance of getting divorced when the government doesn't even recognize your marriage?  Well, one of the mom's hadn't been allowed to see her child in years.  There was no divorce, and therefore there was no official custody arrangement, and the child and one of the parents got screwed.  Perhaps in a perfect world, we'd all choose the right person when we got married, and we'd all choose to only have children with a person we'd still want to be with for ever and ever.  But in real life, people make mistakes, and when a marriage (or a relationship like a marriage) dissolves, being able to get divorced can be an important right.  
  • A marriage doesn't fail because of the age you got married, a marriage fails either A. You weren't right for each other when you got married B. You gave up. If you vow to be with somebody forever it is your responsibility to fight through the hard times and make it work.

    Before we got married we were watching tv and saw a discussion on Pre nuptual agreements, we both wondered why anybody in their right mind would do that. You are setting yourself up for a divorce. If you take divorce off the table from the start and agree that you love each other enough to make it work, then there shouldn't be an issue.

    Divorce has NOTHING to do with age and anybody who doesn't agree with something because of statistics is a ding dong in my book.

    I just got married and we are 20 and 24. Don't let anybody tell you that you made a bad choice girl. At least we get a longer time to spend with our husbands: )

     

     

    Lol.  You are 20 and just got married; of COURSE you have the wisdom and life experience to tell everyone why marriages fail and how they can be made to work.  That makes perfect sense.*






    *to college-aged kids
    image
  • I love your response.

    I'm 22.  I'm dumber than a rock when it comes to marriage.  :) 
  • Onceinalovetime -

    That's great that you have a wonderful outlook on marriage and life - but you may find that there is a reason that people get divorced, and it's not necessarily because either of them were bad people or 'weren't a good fit'.

    Life happens and it changes people. In some ways for the better, in some ways worse.

    Have you yet dealt with the death of a parent? A sibling? Your child? A serious illness? Financial ruin? These things have the power to drastically change a person - and a couple, even though they were great together, might easily drift apart. Your husband seems fantastic now, but what if he developed a serious illness? Not critical, but chronic. He spirals into a depression that you stand by him for - but he never comes out despite your efforts. He stops working and you are facing financial ruin. He turns on you, his personality changes and you end up slaving away at work only to come home to a living hell. For the rest of your life.

    Or your husband becomes a successful yet raging workaholic (or you do). Putting in more hours at work to the point that you only see each other in passing. For years. You start to realize that there is more to life than leaving saran-wrapped dinners in the fridge every night. He won't change (or you won't) and you start to look elsewhere for affection and intimacy... while he looks for someone more challenging and up to his pace.

    Or your once charming husband experiences something traumatic or profound and goes all snap-shitsu and ends up either in prison or having become the leader of the cult of potato plant worship.

    Or your darling husband seems like he would be a great father but it turns out that he abandons you and the triplets constantly to go to work, then to go golfing, then to play video games... you are stressed and the two of you fight constantly. Suddenly living without him, just for avoiding the constant fights and disappointment, seems like a rational choice.

    Or your darling husband turns out to be a ringleader in a secret terrorist cell. Don't you watch TV?!?!

    My point is that people change and your husband is only 24. He WILL change and it may very well be a positive growth and development. It might not. You will change too. Divorced people aren't bad people. I agree with you though that divorce is not always the answer.

    Having them killed is sometimes much less messy.
    image

    Chronically hilarious - you'll split your stitches!
    I wrote a book! Bucket list CHECK!
  • JanimalJanimal member
    Tenth Anniversary 100 Comments 5 Love Its Combo Breaker

    "Pre-nups are bad" - said by someone who doesn't have any money.

     

    Lilypie Pregnancy tickers
    DMoney will be a kickass big sister
    Lilypie - Personal pictureLilypie Third Birthday tickers
    image
Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards