Trouble in Paradise
Dear Community,

Our tech team has launched updates to The Nest today. As a result of these updates, members of the Nest Community will need to change their password in order to continue participating in the community. In addition, The Nest community member's avatars will be replaced with generic default avatars. If you wish to revert to your original avatar, you will need to re-upload it via The Nest.

If you have questions about this, please email help@theknot.com.

Thank you.

Note: This only affects The Nest's community members and will not affect members on The Bump or The Knot.

second time i have caught him cheating online

This is my first time posting on the nest in a while. I just really don't know who to talk to or go to. I'm sorry if this is rambling or incoherent.

We haven't been married long. Almost 4 years and we were together for two years or 3 before that. This is the second time I have caught him. The first time was when we were dating. We never went to therapy. We didn't all out ignore it. I just thought we could handle it ourselves. He looked up what to do to regain my trust. He talked about it openly and why he felt he did it. I slowly forgave him.

The first time it was on accident that I found his hidden email account where he had not only responded to craigslist adds but he had clearly posted some. In the emails he talked about meeting up with them but he said he had never actually met any of them. We started from square one. There were a few slip ups too. Like when I found one of the craigslist persons had made a facebook account (fake name with 5 friends) and he had not only friended them but messaged with them about how he couldn't speak to them because he was focusing on his relationship.

I forgave him but I don't think the trust was completely repaired. I would still snoop on his phone up until about two years ago.Last night I was searching for something and using his phone (my phone is dead.) I saw that he had made some craigslist posts from his phone that were verified via text. I then found he had an email created and attached to his personal email. There were craigslist posting replies and his own postings.

Again he says he hasn't met any and that he was "bored."

On my side we haven't been having sex regularly. It is something we have talked about but it has a lot to do with my lack of libido lately and his work schedule (we see each other twice a week.)

I don't even know where to go with this. I don't want to tell friends/family because if we move past this I don't want it to be something they know about. I'm feeling lost and alone.

We are trying to make an appointment with a therapist and I asked for his passwords to any sites he is on.
Image and video hosting by TinyPic
«13

Re: second time i have caught him cheating online

  • Wow. Just wow. I don't really know what to say, since I am not a good forgiver. The 1st time, okay I guess, you decided to stay. This time, you found something again, and he says it is because he was bored? IMO he really should not be doing any thing close to that since you already went thru it once. I have a feeling he is not being honest with you. He was Bored, but he went and made another email account? That right there is weird to me. I would definitely see a counselor!!! Get checked, just incase. You and him haven't been having much sex, perhaps he has. I don't know, you never know and that would freak me out a bit. Just finding out my H was doing something, as if he was someone else, that's creepy....

       Image and video hosting by TinyPicimageimage

  • Wow. Just wow. I don't really know what to say, since I am not a good forgiver. The 1st time, okay I guess, you decided to stay. This time, you found something again, and he says it is because he was bored? IMO he really should not be doing any thing close to that since you already went thru it once. I have a feeling he is not being honest with you. He was Bored, but he went and made another email account? That right there is weird to me. I would definitely see a counselor!!! Get checked, just incase. You and him haven't been having much sex, perhaps he has. I don't know, you never know and that would freak me out a bit. Just finding out my H was doing something, as if he was someone else, that's creepy....

       Image and video hosting by TinyPicimageimage

  • I feel alone. I don't want to tell any friends or family but it is all I can think about.

    I wish there was a right/wrong answer and someone could just tell me what to do or I could see forward 5-10 years and know it would be okay.

    Who wants to be divorced before 30? I know that isn't why you stay in a marriage but it is a nagging thought.

    I also misspoke about how long we have been married. We have only been married for 2 and a half years almost 3. I'm a little out of it. Didn't get enough sleep last night and my mental state isn't there.
    Image and video hosting by TinyPic
  • "This is my first time posting on the nest in a while. I just really don't know who to talk to or go to. I'm sorry if this is rambling or incoherent.

    We haven't been married long. Almost 4 years and we were together for two years or 3 before that. This is the second time I have caught him. The first time was when we were dating. We never went to therapy. We didn't all out ignore it. I just thought we could handle it ourselves. He looked up what to do to regain my trust. He talked about it openly and why he felt he did it. I slowly forgave him.

    The first time it was on accident that I found his hidden email account where he had not only responded to craigslist adds but he had clearly posted some. In the emails he talked about meeting up with them but he said he had never actually met any of them. We started from square one. There were a few slip ups too. Like when I found one of the craigslist persons had made a by Coupon Companion Plugin" id="_GPLITA_1" href="http://forums.thenest.com/discussion/12008742/second-time-i-have-caught-him-cheating-online#">facebookimage account (fake name with 5 friends) and he had not only friended them but messaged with them about how he couldn't speak to them because he was focusing on his relationship.

    I forgave him but I don't think the trust was completely repaired. I would still snoop on his phone up until about two years ago.Last night I was searching for something and using his phone (my phone is dead.) I saw that he had made some craigslist posts from his phone that were verified via text. I then found he had an email created and attached to his personal email. There were craigslist posting replies and his own postings.

    Again he says he hasn't met any and that he was "bored."

    On my side we haven't been having sex regularly. It is something we have talked about but it has a lot to do with my lack of by Coupon Companion Plugin" id="_GPLITA_0" href="http://forums.thenest.com/discussion/12008742/second-time-i-have-caught-him-cheating-online#">libidoimage lately and his work schedule (we see each other twice a week.)

    I don't even know where to go with this. I don't want to tell friends/family because if we move past this I don't want it to be something they know about. I'm feeling lost and alone.

    We are trying to make an appointment with a therapist and I asked for his passwords to any sites he is on."

    fool me once shame on you, fool me twice shame on me. you should leave before you waste any more of your time. he doesn't care enough about your feelings. i'm so sorry!
  • The only advice I have gotten is to leave him. I also shared on an Infidelity Support Group Site.

    I'm not complaining it is just hard to hear what you don't want to hear. I don't plan on only using online support. I have been at work and unable to do anything other than think about this and how I can't tell anyone, we can't go to couples therapy till Thursday, and I won't see him till Thursday.

    I have always been someone that said they wouldn't accept infidelity and look at me.
    Image and video hosting by TinyPic
  • Honestly, the main reason why I said leave him is because this is the SECOND time he has done this. So it looks like he won't change. Its up to you, and I know its hard to leave someone you love. But if they aren't treating you the way they should, then you have to either accept his behavior or move on. I hope you feel better. maybe therapy will help, but only you can answer that.
  • He is getting an STD test Wednesday morning and we are going to therapy Thursday night.

    I never thought of myself as that woman but I can feel a strong part of me wanting to ignore it and pretend like it never happened.
    Image and video hosting by TinyPic
  • Disneygeek77Disneygeek77 member
    Ancient Membership 2500 Comments 500 Love Its First Answer
    edited December 2013

    Because that is the easy thing to do.  Bury your head in the sand.

    You have a few choices here.

    1. be divorced before you are thirty but go on to have a wonderful life with a man that respects, admires and cherishes you.

    2. Be 32-33 and have a husband that has cheated on you 3 times and from there go on to be married to a man that has cheated on her even more times. 

     Do you want to spend the rest of your life wondering what kind of horrible diseases he is exposing you to every time you have sex ?

    And what is the point of having his passwords.  He can simply create new accounts ?

     

     

  • The first thing that came to me was fool me once shame on your fool me twice shame on you. He obviously is not taking your relationship seriously. I believe this will just keep happeing whenever he decides hes "bored"
    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • Sorry, but I really think you should just leave him.  
    image
  • Again, hard to hear what you font want to hear but I need to hear these things.

    He works nights so I am spending this time journaling and reflecting before we go to therapy.

    I can't believe he did this again. This is the only real issue we have ever had. We don't crazy fight. If we have a disagreement we will have a discussion, maybe an argument, but nothing unhealthy. We don't fight in front of others and we don't talk negatively about each other to friends. We are the couple that is that picture of happy endings that my friends all say "I want that." I feel like a liar. I feel like my life is built on lies and I am angry at him for that.
    Image and video hosting by TinyPic
  • Being divorced before 30 is a hell of a lot easier than after 30. Or worse once you have kids with this petri dish.

    Divorce him. Leave. No more chances. Gather some respect for yourself. HE IS POSTING ADS ON CRAIGSLIST! Do you hear yourself!?

    He didn't get caught up in a moment, he didn't meet a really neat coworker at a weak time in his life, he went on Craigslist to look for whores to do nasty shit. 

    Oh yes, must be your fault because you're not having enough sex with him (sarcasm). Please listen to yourself. THIS IS NOT YOUR FAILT! He has major issues you do not want to deal with. I was almost 35 when I married. You have so much time to be happy and not deal with this bull shit. 

    Please, please, please do better for yourself.
  • so, you caught him the 1st time and really did nothing to address it except him looking something up on line.

    now you caught him AGAIN and are still considering staying?

     

    hmmm.....I wonder WHY he thinks its ok



  • HandBananaHandBanana member
    10 Comments Second Anniversary
    edited December 2013
    I don't know your relationships and I understand that I came here with my story looking for advice.

    What I have learned from my own life in this situations is how easy it is to say what to do when you aren't in the situation.

    I'm not looking for you all to tell me it will be okay and to be nice nice but I didn't think some of you would have such know it all attitudes about something like this. I mean I expect this on The Knot when a bride comes on to try and talk shit about her BM not being able to afford a destination bachelorette but not about something like infidelity and divorce.

    eta: not all replies. I can handle straight forward advice. It is what I came here for. The implication from the poster above that I was asking for it by forgiving him originally are bothersome.
    Image and video hosting by TinyPic
  • edited December 2013
    Like I said, go get checked, make sure he hasn't given you any stds, then really sit back and think about what has happened here. He did this..... Again. He did it again and I think you knew all along he would. Your intuition has been telling you something isn't right. IMO, you never did get over it and you obviously had every right not to. He is the one who screwed up, and I know it hurts now, but if you decide to stay, I think it will hurt you much more down the road. You deserve much better and need to remind yourself that he was a lucky man to have you and he's shit outta luck now. So what, you divorced by 30. Better than to be married with kids down the road married to a pile. Good luck and I hope things work out for you. Be strong. xoxo Oh, and I am so the type of person who is usually very opposed to divorce. Just sayin....

       Image and video hosting by TinyPicimageimage

  • Like I said, go get checked, make sure he hasn't given you any stds, then really sit back and think about what has happened here. He did this..... Again. He did it again and I think you knew all along he would. Your intuition has been telling you something isn't right. IMO, you never did get over it and you obviously had every right not to. He is the one who screwed up, and I know it hurts now, but if you decide to stay, I think it will hurt you much more down the road. You deserve much better and need to remind yourself that he was a lucky man to have you and he's shit outta luck now. So what, you divorced by 30. Better than to be married with kids down the road married to a pile. Good luck and I hope things work out for you. Be strong. xoxo

       Image and video hosting by TinyPicimageimage

  • Who wants to be divorced before 30? 

    You do, so you can stop wasting your life with this dimwit. Find someone who actually respects you. 
  • Friday we have a family picture with his family that I organized. Am I not suppose to go? Do I cancel?

    Not that I have made a decision I just don't know.

    It feels unreal to think of divorce. I was so naively happy 24 hours ago.

    Sorry. Stuff is kind of sinking in more now.
    Image and video hosting by TinyPic
  • I don't know your relationships and I understand that I came here with my story looking for advice. What I have learned from my own life in this situations is how easy it is to say what to do when you aren't in the situation. I'm not looking for you all to tell me it will be okay and to be nice nice but I didn't think some of you would have such know it all attitudes about something like this. I mean I expect this on The Knot when a bride comes on to try and talk shit about her BM not being able to afford a destination bachelorette but not about something like infidelity and divorce. eta: not all replies. I can handle straight forward advice. It is what I came here for. The implication from the poster above that I was asking for it by forgiving him originally are bothersome.


    really? my response was bothersome? because I called you out on ignoring a huge problem BEFORE you got married? you married a  man who cheated on you, you did not deal with it, and now you are surprised? im sorry if that is bothersome. I don't know how else to tell you that married a cheater, who has done it more than once and if you want to be respected you need to stop allowing it.

     

     



  • edited December 2013
    This is my first time posting on the nest in a while. I just really don't know who to talk to or go to. I'm sorry if this is rambling or incoherent.

    We haven't been married long. Almost 4 years and we were together for two years or 3 before that. This is the second time I have caught him. The first time was when we were dating.


    If you and he were a mutually exclusive couple when this was going on, you needed to say goodbye then. This is a guy who wasn't down with a one on one relationship, and a monogamous one, at that.

    If you were casually dating and there was no agreement yet between the both of you that you were an item,. then, nothing you can do. He's up for grabs and so are you.

     We never went to therapy. We didn't all out ignore it. I just thought we could handle it ourselves. He looked up what to do to regain my trust. He talked about it openly and why he felt he did it. I slowly forgave him.

    The first time it was on accident that I found his hidden email account where he had not only responded to craigslist adds but he had clearly posted some. In the emails he talked about meeting up with them but he said he had never actually met any of them. We started from square one. There were a few slip ups too. Like when I found one of the craigslist persons had made a facebook account (fake name with 5 friends) and he had not only friended them but messaged with them about how he couldn't speak to them because he was focusing on his relationship.

    I forgave him but I don't think the trust was completely repaired. I would still snoop on his phone up until about two years ago.Last night I was searching for something and using his phone (my phone is dead.) I saw that he had made some craigslist posts from his phone that were verified via text. I then found he had an email created and attached to his personal email. There were craigslist posting replies and his own postings.

    Again he says he hasn't met any and that he was "bored."

    He's got no business doing this; boredom is no excuse.

    On my side we haven't been having sex regularly. It is something we have talked about but it has a lot to do with my lack of libido lately and his work schedule (we see each other twice a week.)

    I don't even know where to go with this. I don't want to tell friends/family because if we move past this I don't want it to be something they know about. I'm feeling lost and alone.

    We are trying to make an appointment with a therapist and I asked for his passwords to any sites he is on.
    A guy like this has cheating on his mind, even if he hasn't physically done anything.

    I don't know what you want to do --- do you want to work through this with him or do you wish to move on?

    The choice is yours.

    To me, once a cheater, always one and when they do it once they will do it again.

    Again, whether you go or stay and work this out with him is your choice. GL.

    PS: Ask for no passwords.

    You aren't a cop or his mother and it is of no use; he can get other passwords to other places using other names.  That you have to have this kind of sword of Damocles over your head is bad news alone.


  • I don't know your relationships and I understand that I came here with my story looking for advice.

    What I have learned from my own life in this situations is how easy it is to say what to do when you aren't in the situation.

    I'm not looking for you all to tell me it will be okay and to be nice nice but I didn't think some of you would have such know it all attitudes about something like this. I mean I expect this on The Knot when a bride comes on to try and talk shit about her BM not being able to afford a destination bachelorette but not about something like infidelity and divorce.

    eta: not all replies. I can handle straight forward advice. It is what I came here for. The implication from the poster above that I was asking for it by forgiving him originally are bothersome.




    really? my response was bothersome? because I called you out on ignoring a huge problem BEFORE you got married? you married a  man who cheated on you, you did not deal with it, and now you are surprised? im sorry if that is bothersome. I don't know how else to tell you that married a cheater, who has done it more than once and if you want to be respected you need to stop allowing it.

     

     

    I use to sit on pretty high horse too.

    I don't mind straightforward advice but the holier than thou attitude in something as serious as divorce and infidelity is over the top. Reminds me of the knot but on the knot it was appropriate in those shallow topics.

    We did deal with it. The only thing I said was we didn't go to therapy about it. We dealt with it he accepted blame we moved on.
    Image and video hosting by TinyPic


  • This is my first time posting on the nest in a while. I just
    really don't know who to talk to or go to. I'm sorry if this is rambling
    or incoherent.



    We haven't been married long. Almost 4 years and we were together
    for two years or 3 before that. This is the second time I have caught
    him. The first time was when we were dating.


    If you and he were a mutually exclusive couple when this was going on, you needed to say goodbye then. This is a guy who wasn't down with a one on one relationship, and a monogamous one, at that.

    If you were casually dating and there was no agreement yet between the both of you that you were an item,. then, nothing you can do. He's up for grabs and so are you.

     We never went to therapy. We didn't all out ignore it. I just thought
    we could handle it ourselves. He looked up what to do to regain my
    trust. He talked about it openly and why he felt he did it. I slowly
    forgave him.



    The first time it was on accident that I found his hidden email
    account where he had not only responded to craigslist adds but he had
    clearly posted some. In the emails he talked about meeting up with them
    but he said he had never actually met any of them. We started from
    square one. There were a few slip ups too. Like when I found one of the
    craigslist persons had made a facebook account (fake name with 5
    friends) and he had not only friended them but messaged with them about
    how he couldn't speak to them because he was focusing on his
    relationship.



    I forgave him but I don't think the trust was completely repaired.
    I would still snoop on his phone up until about two years ago.Last
    night I was searching for something and using his phone (my phone is
    dead.) I saw that he had made some craigslist posts from his phone that
    were verified via text. I then found he had an email created and
    attached to his personal email. There were craigslist posting replies
    and his own postings.



    Again he says he hasn't met any and that he was "bored."



    He's got no business doing this; boredom is no excuse.

    On my side we haven't been having sex regularly. It is something
    we have talked about but it has a lot to do with my lack of libido
    lately and his work schedule (we see each other twice a week.)



    I don't even know where to go with this. I don't want to tell
    friends/family because if we move past this I don't want it to be
    something they know about. I'm feeling lost and alone.



    We are trying to make an appointment with a therapist and I asked for his passwords to any sites he is on.



    A guy like this has cheating on his mind, even if he hasn't physically done anything.

    I don't know what you want to do --- do you want to work through this with him or do you wish to move on?

    The choice is yours.

    To me, once a cheater, always one and when they do it once they will do it again.

    Again, whether you go or stay and work this out with him is your choice. GL.

    PS: Ask for no passwords.

    You aren't a cop or his mother and it is of no use; he can get other passwords to other places using other names.  That you have to have this kind of sword of Damocles over your head is bad news alone.


    That is how I felt about the passwords the first time. This time I just don't know.

    I don't want to file for divorce but I don't want to be in a marriage of lies.
    Image and video hosting by TinyPic
  • OP, cut yourself some slack, especially since you just found out. I totally understand that you can't go from thinking things are fine to being ready to divorce in 24 hours. It's tough, you're going to have to do a lot of thinking and processing, and of course you feel confused, betrayed and uncertain. All I hope for you is that you keep a clear picture in your mind of what your ideal marriage would look like. What would he treat you like, what kind of person would he be, and how would you feel? Keep that as your standard for yourself, and don't settle for less. I've left a cheater, and I know how hard it is, because you want to believe that they'll change and that one day things will be perfect. What saved me was constantly reminding myself that this was NOT how I wanted to be treated. Whenever my ex tried to persuade me or knock me off course, I'd ask myself if compromising on my dream relationship was really good enough for me. It wasn't. And 30 is so young, you have so many years to be happy, find yourself and find a good relationship! I didn't meet my DH until I was 31. You deserve to be with someone who thinks cheating is immoral and that Craig's list is gross. I really wish you all the best, I know this isn't easy at all.
  • I was divorced before I was 28. At the time it was devastating and I kept seeing/dating my ex hoping we would work it out. The best thing I did was stop seeing him. I met someone new and was happily remarried by thirty. Don't wait and don't worry about any stigma. It happens to lots of people. You want to give yourself lots of time to find someone new and start a family. It is tough at first but it will get better.
  • I'm not going to tell you to flat out leave him, because everyone handles things differently, and I truly believe that a couple can recover from infidelity if both parties really want to (I'm not sure about twice though). I will say that there's nothing wrong with being divorced. It took me years to reach that point, but I've been so much happier since my divorce than I ever was married. And I wouldn't have even said that I was in an unhappy marriage most of the time.

    You need to think about what you really want, and more importantly, what's keeping you from leaving him? If you're not sure you want to leave yet, absolutely go to counseling. It's great that it sounds like he's willing to go, but you might also consider solo counseling to help you talk through your own conflicted feelings.

    Personally, I think it sounds like he would likely do the same again, and you should seriously consider cutting your losses now. But having faced a divorce, I know that it's not always the easiest decision.

    There is no rule that says you have to make the decision as soon as you find out. Take your time.
    image
  • I don't know your relationships and I understand that I came here with my story looking for advice. What I have learned from my own life in this situations is how easy it is to say what to do when you aren't in the situation. I'm not looking for you all to tell me it will be okay and to be nice nice but I didn't think some of you would have such know it all attitudes about something like this. I mean I expect this on The Knot when a bride comes on to try and talk shit about her BM not being able to afford a destination bachelorette but not about something like infidelity and divorce. eta: not all replies. I can handle straight forward advice. It is what I came here for. The implication from the poster above that I was asking for it by forgiving him originally are bothersome.


    really? my response was bothersome? because I called you out on ignoring a huge problem BEFORE you got married? you married a  man who cheated on you, you did not deal with it, and now you are surprised? im sorry if that is bothersome. I don't know how else to tell you that married a cheater, who has done it more than once and if you want to be respected you need to stop allowing it.

     

     

    I use to sit on pretty high horse too. I don't mind straightforward advice but the holier than thou attitude in something as serious as divorce and infidelity is over the top. Reminds me of the knot but on the knot it was appropriate in those shallow topics. We did deal with it. The only thing I said was we didn't go to therapy about it. We dealt with it he accepted blame we moved on.


    Nothing holier than thou about telling you that you obviously didn't REALLY deal with it if he did it again. If you want to continue to deny that, that's ok. no one wants to admit that maybe they were fooled, especially since they really loved that person. no one wants to admit that the

    person they married wasn't who they thought they were. 

    you were looking for advice, I gave mine....stop wasting your time with this lying cheater, expect more for yourself, and stop allowing a man to treat you like crap.  the nerve of me I know.

    sorry if that isn't what you wanted to hear or how you wanted to hear it, but you don't get to choose how people respond. maybe you should actually listen to what im saying instead of getting defensive about how I said it.

     

    you are right you don't know my story, but I can tell you that its not a high horse im talking from, its from past experience.

     



  • Question:

    I was thinking of taking a personal day on Friday. It is the day after therapy and the day of a family photo with my in laws. I'm worried that a personal day will make things worse if I am not at work and busy. I feel like this is all in my head with the only people I have talked to being on the internet and myself (journaling.)

    Our insurance won't cover couples therapy. The cover individual though and he is scheduling us for that. He is trying to find a place with a sliding pay scale. This situation is terrible but then our opposite schedules is making it even harder to communicate about what is going on.

    The other part being a work in a small divorce firm (11 people total) and it isn't like a big place where I just put in a slip. This is a small place and I never take personal days.
    Image and video hosting by TinyPic
  • You are the only person I took issue with and I received the same advice from several other people. Maybe you should look inward instead of thinking I am being ridiculous.
    Image and video hosting by TinyPic
  • That is how I felt about the passwords the first time. This time I just don't know.

    I don't want to file for divorce but I don't want to be in a marriage of lies.


    I guarantee you that this mess will go on. He'll take advantage of you being a doormat and do it repeatedly.

    Why would you want to stay married to somebody who is making it crystal clear he does not want to be in a committed relationship with you?

    Get out before a child enters the picture. You will really be stuck with him then! Even if you divorce him after a kiddo comes along, you're going to have him on your hands until your child reaches majority.

    If you stay with him, you aren't saying much about yourself. You are more or less telling him "it's fine that I am married to an adulterer."

    If you and he were a couple when he did this before you were married, you indeed needed to tell him goodbye then, as I said.


Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards